Pumpkin Maple Whoopie Pies

(Customer Reviews)

A luscious, silky, maple marshmallow buttercream sandwiched between two pillowy soft pumpkin cakes. A customer favorite!

The bakers at this Portland, Maine, shop have made it their mission to bake the best all-American desserts and pies from scratch, every day. Two Fat Cats Bakery was started in 2005 and continues their legacy of quality desserts with exceptional pies, specialty cakes, cupcakes, and whoopie pies.

More Details

This package serves 12 people and includes 12 Pumpkin Maple Whoopie Pies

  • Whoopie Pies arrive individually wrapped


Cake – Flour, Butter, Brown Sugar, Sugar, Vegetable Oil, Eggs, Pumpkin, Milk, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Salt, Nutmeg, Cloves.
Filling – Egg Whites, Butter, Confectioner’s Sugar, Corn Syrup, Vanilla Extract, Maple Extract.

Instructions / Storage

  • Whoopie pies ship frozen with ice packs, may thaw during transit.
  • Upon arrival, store whoopie pies at room temperature or in the freezer.
  • Whoopie pies last up to 1 day at room temperature or up to 3 months in the freezer.

To Serve

  • Allow whoopie pies to thaw at room temperature for 20-30 minutes.
  • Serve and enjoy!
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Two Fat Cats Bakery ships Monday-Thursday of each week.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Maine


Quality of the Maine blueberry pie outstanding. Speed and care in packaging. Clear delivery.
Theodore C. - New York, NY
The pie was absolutely delicious. I wanted my family for years to taste a truly authentic Maine blueberry pie and this did not disappoint.
Kathryn W. - Georgetown, TX
Thank you Goldbelly for a success! The family came to my house this year & living in SC blueberry pies are not available. I ordered a blueberry pie for my son :-) It was SO good that I'm going to order another to be sent to his house in a few weeks. You guys ROCK!
Alyne H. - West Columbia, SC
The Maine blueberry pie was fresh and melt in your mouth delicious! The crust was nice and flaky too!
Jean K. - Mount Pleasant, SC
Delivery on point. The pie was the best blueberry pie I’ve ever had!! Will def order again. Thank you.
Kate A. - Wilmington, MA
Being able to buy a wild Maine Blueberry pie from a baker in my partner's hometown? Priceless Xmas present. Worth every penny.
Kerry M. - Los Angeles, CA
Item arrived timely, and in good condition. The Maine Wild Blueberry Pie from Two Fat Cats Bakery was delicious, and we enjoyed it!
Eileen S. - Southport, NC
Yummy! Didn't disappoint. 😊
Earl S. - Bellevue, IA
The package was delivered as expected and on time. I want to give a special shout out to Two Fat Cats Bakery in Maine. The blueberry pie that I ordered was for my son, who is in the military. It was for his 25th birthday. The pie was the best he's ever had. Thank you for helping to make his birthday away from his family a little extra special!
Daniel M. - Pensacola, FL
Package arrive exactly on the day you said it was going to and my family said the pie was delicious.
Kinglsey V. - Bonita Springs, FL
Delicious pie, well packaged and efficiently delivered.
Margaret K. - Westerville, OH
Made it 2 Kauai perfectly. My sister got it a day b4 my birthday & oven was heated & ready as soon as pie was delivered.
Roleen S. - Kalaheo, HI
Right on time with a yummers outstanding tart cherry pie from 2 Fat Cats, so we ordered a Maine blueberry and another tart cherry -- all the way from Maine to AZ! So appreciate the excellence: fresh and the bestest crust plus wonderful ingredients, just right/perfect on the sugar: not overly sweetened. Thank you!
Elizabeth E. - Litchfield Park, AZ
Easy site to use. The selections are endless...my Maine blueberry pie was OUTRAGEOUSLY delish!!
Kathleen V. - Dawsonville, GA
Delivery on time ! Pie in excellent condition! Great transaction! Thank you!
Terri S. - Silver Spring, MD
It was a breeeeze! From the selection, to the ordering to the delivery! Great Christmas presents....flavors from home!!! They were a big hit!! Thank You.
Sue M. - Ventura, CA
The Blueberry pie was superb! Would order again!
Sandra P. - Hayesville, NC
Everything! Pie was a gift and was delivered on time and in great condition!
Diane H. - West Palm Beach, FL
it was delivered when promised and in perfect condition I am enjoying my pie immensely!
Lorena C. - Muskogee, OK
Two Fat Cats Bakery has always been a reliable vendor with an excellent, consistent and delicious pie product. The packing and shipping and on-time delivery are the best of any vendor previously used.
Julia M. - Fort Myers, FL
Blueberry pie arrived when it was supposed to and it was in perfect condition.
Kerry D. - Liverpool, NY
Gift arrived on time and very fresh. My daughter-in-law loved it.
Lindsey L. - Fort Worth, TX
Delivery was relatively quick and the Wild Maine Blueberry Pie was incredible.
Don H. - Pittsboro, NC
I ordered Fat Cat Bakery Maine blueberry pie and it was delivered on time. The bonus was that the pie was amazing. Hands down the best pie I’ve ever had — and honestly I’m not a big blueberry pie fan.
Paula A. - Pasadena, CA
Delivery was as promised and pie was wonderful!!
Lynn S. - Houston, TX
Received on time and ready to enjoy!
Elizabeth E. - Litchfield Park, AZ
Arrived on time, was exactly as described and tasted great!
Sandy D. - Annapolis, MD
Shipped perfectly, and simply the best, obviously made with caring kindness! Grateful. Eliza and family, Litchfield AZ
Elizabeth E. - Litchfield Park, AZ
Prompt delivery and great product!
Georgiann Y. - Saint Joseph, MI
Delivered in excellent condition!
Becca K. - Sidney, ME
Delivery was as promised and pie was delicious!
Karen W. - Roswell, GA
My friends loved the black and blue pie; they said it tasted like home made and was full of fresh berries and not too sweet. The packaging and quality were outstanding.
Lee G. - Los Angeles, CA
It arrived on time and I heard the Whoopie's were great.
Tony R. - Charlotte, NC
Immediate action was taken after an unfavorable experience with not receiving items in a timely manner.
Rosemarie H. - Ravenswood, WV
Pie arrived on time (birthday) and recipient loved it.
Doris L. - Norwalk, CT
On time delivery and beautitul, delicious pie.
Mehul A. - Kaneohe, HI
Pie arrived frozen on specified date with 3 pkgs of dry ice. Great considering almost 100 degrees Texas weather.
Chieko M. - Killeen, TX
The pie arrived as promised—was well packaged—it was a true taste of Maine!!! Brilliant!!
Mary K. - Oxford, MD
It tasted so fresh! Delicious!
Viviana M. - Atlanta, GA
Arrived on time, food was delicious, well-packaged.
Rachel R. - New York, NY
The blueberry pie was delicious…..as always! Always a great gift to give or to receive!
Angela G. - Flushing, MI
All aspects of the process went very smoothly. End result: we had the opportunity to taste this amazing Maine Blueberry pie last night. WOW! The crust was very flaky, the filling was perfect; not too sweet, either. Highly recommend.
Carolyn K. - Chapel Hill, NC
The pie was delicious and arrived on time!! Wish I ordered 2. Cinnamon Apple & Cranberry was outstanding. Will definitely buy from you again!
Laurie P. - Westerly, RI
Delightful baked goods from Two Fat Cats. Delivery was exactly as promised and the products arrived in excellent condition.
Julia K. - El Cerrito, CA
Everything— I was worried about ordering blueberries this late in the year, but it was as delicious as more seasonal ones I've ordered before.
THEODORE C. - New York, NY
Excellent pies, just perfect, the crusts and all -- fresh, not too sweet: grateful!
Elizabeth E. - Litchfield Park, AZ
Easy to ship my favorite yummy food to family across the US.
Peter H. - Bethel, CT
Excellent taste.
Sarah L. - Easley, SC
Received order quickly fast service. Food was good. Fresh.
Brendon K. - Lebanon, OH
It arrived on time and packaged very well.
Emanuel B. - Silver Spring, MD
When I was on the site of the place I wanted to order from, Goldbelly came right up. Easy to get around and to order. Emails received during entire process! The pie was delivered on time, looked good and from what I hear tasted great!
James J. - Sarasota, FL
Two Fat Cats pie was delivered timely and in perfect condition.
Chelcey D. - Richmond, VA
Delivery and quality of the pie were right-on.
Matthew S. - Los Angeles, CA
Absolutely delicious.
Lorraine O. - Castle Hayne, NC
Everything arrived fresh and delicious - as usual! Well done & Bravo
Shannon F. - Lander, WY
Birthday girl recipient loved it
Kathy L. - Buffalo Grove, IL
The blueberry pie was the best! Nothing better than a blueberry pie from Maine!
Charisse H. - Cape Coral, FL
Delivery and packaging excellent. Products were delicious!
Janet P. - Bogota, NJ
My friend said the pie was delicious and the photos were really good, looked like a very well made pie. 10/10 for quality.
Pamela G. - San Jose, CA
Fast delivery product arrived in perfect condition
barbara w. - bridgewater, VT
Loved loved loved all of the notifications I received, letting me know every step of the way where my order was, and that it was delivered. Loved the great selection of wonderful food items, everything was just great!
Judi M. - Sanbornville, NH
Product arrived when expected, was easy to prepare, and was as delicious as described.
Cameron H. - Seattle, WA
The whole process was painless, and the pies were awesome.
Richard M. - Hollis, ME
Everything! Including days of eating................
William M. - Mitchellville, MD
Delivery was just as described. Everything was packaged well.
Caron R. - La Quinta, CA
Delivery in time and fresh. Food well packed. Free shipping.
Shelley B. - Wallingford, CT
On time, fresh delivery! Great communications!
Shelley W. - Pueblo, CO
The pie was delivered on time to my recipient. It was frozen, took two hours to thaw. He said it was very good, the crust was like a croissant which was nice. it looked sumptuous, but he did not say it was spectacular. I had a hard time finding another flavor of pie that day from the same bakery, although they have them. Your site was hard to navigate for that.
Richard S. - Scarborough, ME
Great food! Great experience!
Mike C. - San Francisco, CA
Although these were gifts, so I did not see or taste them but was told they were very good. One item was delayed a day, really no big deal for them I was told.
Jodi B. - Boones Mill, VA
Fantastic blueberry pie from Two Fat Cats Bakery for my Dad’s Valentine’s Day Birthday! And, extremely well packaged by Two Fat Cats Bakery.
Robert S. - Saint Louis, MO
It was delivered on the correct day. The pie was beautiful and delicious.
Patrick O. - Spring, TX