New York Style Pepperoni Pizza - 3 Pack

(Customer Reviews)

Mother Kelly’s ships its famous New York Style Pepperoni Pizza nationwide on Goldbelly! Mother Kelly’s classic New York style pepperoni pizza has a light and crispy crust and is topped with loads of whole milk mozzarella signature homemade marinara sauce, and sliced pepperoni. Do yourself a favor and order some of this pizza perfection!

Since opening in Cedarhurst, New York, in 1969, Mother Kelly’s has become a go-to Italian restaurant for in-the-know Long Islanders. Mother Kelly’s is famous for its Italian classics like balsamic chicken, garlic knots, and creamed spinach pizza. Warning…these made-from-scratch menu items are seriously addictive!

More Details

This package serves 6-9 people and includes 3 Pepperoni Pizzas

  • Each pizza serves 2-3 people and measures 14"


Contains: Gluten, Dairy

Instructions / Storage

  • Pizzas ship frozen with ice packs, may thaw in transit.
  • Upon arrival, store pizzas in the refrigerator or in the freezer.
  • Pizzas last up to 2 days in the refrigerator or up to 1 month in the freezer.

To Serve

  • Preheat oven to 425°F.
  • Place pizza directly on center oven rack and bake pizza for 10-12 minutes.
  • Remove from oven and enjoy!
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Mother Kelly’s ships Tuesday-Friday of each week.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New York


Classic NY flavor, crispy crust, excellent sauce and plenty of great mozzarella! Really good pie!
Drew G. - South Portland, ME
We had a delivery issue with the first package but goldbelly made it right. We got our pizza the next day with the frozen packs completely frozen as was the pizza. Oh my and the pizza! It was wonderful! I think my favorite pizza ever! We had to control ourselves and not eat all three in one sitting. It was wonderful.
melissa p. - Lebanon, ME
Awesome packaging and it was delicious - truly worth it
Tamara P. - Sarasota, FL
The item was packed carefully and arrived on time. The tracking kept me informed of delivery. The pizza was delicious and tasted authentic.
Leena J. - Brentwood, CA
My pizza arrived here in Wisconsin from NY on time and in perfect condition..Great pizza great service.
frank m. - Waukesha, WI
The order shipped quickly and the pizza is phenomenal! A literal slice of heaven during the pandemic.
KRISTIN S. - Tonawanda, NY
The pizzas came on time, packed well and remained frozen. Heating instruction were perfect!
Barbara M. - Dallas, TX
Pizza was delicious. Delivery was on time. It was a surprise Birthday gift. Everything was perfect. Thank you.
Jesse R. - Los Angeles, CA
Everything went well.The food was great.The site is awesome and the food got here fast.I am very happy with the food I got from Mother Kelly's. I can't believe I just found Goldbelly.Very cool.
Justin L. - Colfax, CA
Called prior to order. Rep called back quickly, was helpful and very nice. The pizza was securely packaged and came on time/as accepted.
Elizabeth G. - Montclair, NJ
Everything went well. Delivered on time in perfect shape and my grandson said it was wonderful.
Dylan H. - Buffalo, NY
Perfect timing for delivery! 2nd time ordering pizza from here. It is delicious we loved it!!
Connie V. - Lake Elsinore, CA
The Balsamic chicken and rice was delicious. Especially the sauce! I suggest heating the rice separately so it doesn't absorb all the yummy sauce.
Pamela W. - Scottsdale, AZ
The balsamic chicken was delicious! And there was a lot of it. Very happy. Will be buying again. :)
Emma M. - Le Roy, NY
Everything. All loved the taste, and delivery was great. My friend very pleased! Will do again!
Toni J. - Madison, WI
It was as close to being in NY as you can get.. The pizza was delicious reminded me of home!
Brett S. - Fort Mitchell, AL
I ordered the Balsamic Chicken + Rice Dinner Kit for my grandparents as dinner for Mother's Day. The order arrived on time and in good condition. The meal is already cooked. All they needed to do was reheat and enjoy. They loved it! They found the food to every flavorful, and thankfully, the prep was easy.
Mary G. - Chicago, IL
food was delivered timely and in good condition--excellent review from the customers that received the food
JESSICA R. - Jacksonville, FL
My order was carefully packed, shipped on schedule and arrived here safely. The balsamic chicken was excellent. Preparation instructions were clear and easily followed.
Richard M. - Fairfax Station, VA