"The Pope's" Italian Olive Oil Cake

+ Free Shipping
This product is currently sold out.

Inspired by the flavors of Italy, “The Pope” Italian Olive Oil Cake is one of our renowned recipes, and it’s become a staple in our family business.

This cake begins with an almond flour base that’s baked with olive oil, walnuts and shredded coconut. It’s then filled with delectable almond mousse, frosted with homemade cream cheese buttercream and garnished with cream cheese dollops, toasted almonds on top and toasted almonds on the side.

More Details

This package serves 8 people and includes a 7" “The Pope’s” Italian Olive Oil Cake


Heavy Cream, Chocolate Chips, Wheat, Sugar, Olive Oil, Cake Flour, Water, Eggs, Almonds, Almond Meal, Coconuts, Milk, Walnuts, Lemon Flavor, Salt, Vanilla Extract, Gelatin, Baking Powder

Contains Almonds, Coconut, Egg, Milk, Nuts, Walnuts, Wheat

Instructions / Storage

  • This cake ships frozen with ice packs, may thaw in transit
  • Delicately remove the cake from styrofoam packaging and carefully remove the plastic wrap and cardboard shield surrounding the cake, but leave the plastic shield surrounding the cake
  • If serving immediately, place it on your counter to thaw out, otherwise store it in your fridge
  • This cake will last at room temperature for 6 hours
  • This cake will last up to 7 days in the fridge
  • This cake will last up to 1 year in the freezer
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Items are prepared fresh and shipped directly from the shop
  • Montilio’s Baking Company ships Monday-Friday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Recommended for you

More from Massachusetts


I ordered this for my daughter's 25th birthday because she is in the Air Force and stationed in Alaska. She said the cake looked beautiful and was absolutely delicious.
Debbi E. - North Pole, AK
Packaging to protect the cake was great and the cake was awesome. Fire all the way!
Eric C. - Phoenix, AZ
Excellent service. Food arrived quickly, beautiful, delicious & exactly how described.
Sarah C. - Seymour, CT
cake arrived still frozen after the dry ice had dissipated, all the way to Florida! My husband loved the cake!!
Karla C. - High Springs, FL
The cake was delivered in perfect condition and on time for my parents’ anniversary. They were thrilled with the cake, so I am very pleased with my overall experience.
Linda P. - Hackensack, MN
The Montilio's Bakery Company rum/custard birthday cake was a big hit for my best friend in the Chicago suburbs! She lived it, saying, “It was to die for!” I am in Japan, but wanted this to be an extra special birthday for her. It certainly achieved that! Thank you so much!
Kathleen H. - Vernon Hills, IL
The cake arrived safely in durable packaging with dry ice. Many said I’d was the best cake they ever eaten. Bravo!
Antoinette M. - Sewell, NJ
The whole experience was positive. Ordering was easy, delivery was on time, the cake was delicious! Will definitely order through Goldbelly again. Thank you for helping make my moms 90th Birthday even better!
Millicent R. - North Dartmouth, MA
The cake showed up right on my wife's birthday, in the morning, in great condition. Thanks! The delivery person put the cake on its side, despite the numerous labels. Thankfully it was packed securely enough that this did not adversely affect the cake. It was nice to have the information sheet explaining the cake's history.
Cara B. - Burbank, CA
I sent a cake to my sister for her Birthday and boy was she crazy about it and remarked how well it was packaged for shipment. I will definitely order again and soon!
Susan D. - Norwalk, CT
Easy ordering, shipped and received as promised in perfect condition. Cake was delish!
cynthia s. - Biloxi, MS
Cake was beautiful and tasted fantastic and fresh
Debra L. - Lagrange, KY
I'm honored to have eaten this cake ......Was the best cake ever ..cant wait to get another one
kelly o. - Bloomington, IL