Choose Your Own Layer Cake - 2 Pack

Sugaree’s ships its famous cakes nationwide on Goldbelly! Now you can breathe easy because you don’t have to choose just one Sugaree’s cake. With this cake pack you get to try two whole layer cakes of your choice: rainbow, red velvet, strawberry, coconut, Mississippi Caramel, chocolate buttercream, Italian Cream, or Sampler Cake.

Sugaree’s is committed to keeping classic Deep South recipes and baking techniques alive by focusing on small-batch and from-scratch recipes. This New Albany, Mississippi, bakery was founded as a home-based business by Mary Jennifer Russell in 1997 and expanded to a retail shop in 2001. Sugaree’s makes each of its delicious pies and cakes the old-fashioned way in flavors like Italian Cream Cake and Chocolate Meringue.

More Details

This package serves 20-24 people includes 2 Cakes of your choice

  • Each Cake serves 10-12 people
  • Each Cake measures 9"

Cake Options Include

  • Rainbow
  • Red Velvet
  • Strawberry
  • Coconut
  • Mississippi Caramel
  • Chocolate Buttercream
  • Italian Cream
  • Sampler Cake

Ingredients

May Contain: Dairy, Nuts, Gluten, & Soy

Instructions / Storage

  • Sugaree’s cakes are made-to-order, frozen and carefully packed with dry ice to maintain freshness.
  • Upon arrival, let it defrost in the refrigerator or counter top to enjoy.
  • If you wish to preserve your cake for longer, store it in the freezer for up to 6 months.
  • Detailed storage instructions are included in the box.
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Due to the extra packaging Sugaree’s cakes require, there is a special shipping & handling fee of $30 for 2 day and $40 for overnight shipping.
  • Sugaree’s ships Monday-Thursday of each week.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge. Overnight shipments will incur an additional $35 charge. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Mississippi

REVIEWS

It was the best cake ever. My co-workers agreed. I was in cake heaven!
Charles H. - Cincinnati, OH
08/21/19
Packaged well. Great service from Sugarees. Delicious cake. Exceeded expectations.
Barbara S. - Venice, CA
08/29/19
Very fresh and moist!
Julia W. - Vacaville, CA
11/17/19
Cake arrived as described. We kept frozen for an additional two days before our party. It was AMAZING and still so fresh and delicious. Tracking and details were spot on. I also found the packing and serving instructions very helpful.
Andee B. - Tampa, FL
11/11/19
The coconut cake was amazing.
Michele H. - Winter Park, FL
11/01/19
Fresh and delicious!
Margarete O. - North Bergen, NJ
11/11/19
I ordered a cream cheese pound cake, half strawberry cake, and half coconut cake. I ordered the cakes for Christmas dinner and everyone loved them. The cakes were absolutely delicious and I look forward to ordering from Sugaree's again.
Crystal G. - Rock Hill, SC
01/19/20
Delivery was on time and pie was exceptional.
Tamara G. - New City, NY
12/19/19
Trustworthy delivery. Package arrived timely and in great shape. Thank you.
Laurel H. - Raleigh, NC
12/02/19
As always, both cakes were delicious!
Mildred B. - Houston, TX
12/27/19
Delivered on date that was promised. Cake was fresh and delicious. Packaging was secure.
Janis P. - Nashville, TN
12/27/19
The caramel layer cake brought back memories of my childhood days when my mom stood over a coal stove to make that frosting just right. It was delicious. The texture of the cake was good and the moisture in the batter could readily absorb the moisture from the frosting . This was my first purchase but it will not be my last!
Gloria W. - Adelphi, MD
12/27/19
The cake was nice and moist and the icing was so delicious. I would suggest to anyone who loves caramel cake to try it! Also it was wrapped VERY WELL which is very important to me. I have ordered cakes and they have been crumbles because it was not packed correctly.
Fred C. - Paducah, KY
12/27/19
The caramel cake is delicious and the packaging was very good! Came in a timely fashion and was enjoyed by all.
Mary W. - Mountain Brk, AL
12/26/19
The BEST caramel cake from Sugaree’s of ALL TIME...!!! I have ordered this and the Strawberry cake (at my boss’s request) so many times! It is all DELICIOUS and always comes perfectly wrapped and packed for freshness! WORTH EVERY PENNEY...!!!!
Gwen O. - San Diego, CA
12/23/19
Cakes arrived on time and perfectly wrapped and boxed. Both tasted like visiting my great grandmother and great aunts in Mississippi. Delicious!
Deborah W. - Tulsa, OK
12/26/19
The caramel on the cake was really delicious.
Margaret H. - Pittsboro, MS
12/26/19
The coconut cake was moist and just right in sweetness. Arrived beautifully and instructions were spot-on for preparing to eat!!
Gloria H. - Lansing, MI
12/30/19
My Mother's birthday cake on New Year's Eve, and she loved it! "This is the best cake I've ever had" she said. Thank you for making My Mom happy!
Jeanie G. - Laceys Spring, AL
01/05/20
Cake arrived as described. We kept frozen for an additional two days before our party. It was AMAZING and still so fresh and delicious. Tracking and details were spot on. I also found the packing and serving instructions very helpful.
Andee B. - Tampa, FL
11/19/19
Delicious, fun, get something from another part of country would never go to.
Karrie L. - Palm Springs, CA
02/06/20
My bff loved her cake and still is eating it!!!
Megan D. - Fort Smith, AR
02/09/20
Everything and very tasty.
john V. - Pittsfield, IL
02/16/20
The delivery was on time and cakes were amazing as usual.
Robyn R. - Giddings, TX
02/17/20
Everything! Delivery was received when expected and in perfect condition. Absolutely delicious! A special birthday treat the whole family enjoyed!
Rebecca H. - Lancaster, PA
03/13/21
A perfect order...on time, handsomely packaged, cake in pristine condition. And, oh, by the way, delicious!
Dr. G. - Washington, DC
02/21/21
I have ordered this cake sampler three times now. It is the best cake ever! All are moist and have the most delicious flavors.
Rachelle S. - Glendale, CA
02/19/21
Thank you! Everything was perfect!! The cake was a birthday gift. It arrived on time and in perfectly frozen condition. They loved it!! The quality and taste was wonderful. It was great to be able to send a cake during these crazy times... thank you!!
George Y. - Mountainburg, AR
02/01/21
Everything: variety of selection; variety of selection in the product type; ease of selection; ease of ordering; quality of product; speed of delivery; happiness of recipient; happiness of sender. Yay!
Barb S. - De Pere, WI
01/04/21
The recipient loved the item they received, and it was delivered well packed and on time. The notifications were excellent too.
Crystal B. - Burien, WA
12/23/20
I recently ordered a a strawberry cake from Sugaree's. Ordering was simple; information from Sugaree's was prompt and detailed; and the cake arrived on the promised day in perfect condition. Any concern I had about it being shipped and frozen were entirely unnecessary. When I served it to my family, the cake was as delicious as promised, perhaps even more so. I whole-heartedly recommend this cake. Many bakers will say that their cake tastes just like one you mom would have made. Most are exaggerating. Sugaree's is not.
Brian A. - Herndon, VA
04/26/21
Was a birthday cake for my visiting mother. Got here when it said it would in great condition. My family ate on the sampler cake for the next several days and had much fun picking our favorites and comparing. Goldbelly is "an experience gift"!
Jennifer S. - Madison, AL
05/22/21
Absolutely delicious cake delivered on time. I love how Goldbelly keeps us informed all through the shipping process. Such a great gift idea for the person who has everything!
Ellen M. - Santa Cruz, CA
05/20/21
Cake arrived exactly when expected and was very good! It was allegedly as close to our grandmother’s coconut cake as my sisters remember.
Donna B. - Swansea, IL
05/11/21
All the products I order are top notch!!!! The packaging is great. Sugaree’s was over the top amazing!!!!!
Mom K. - York, PA
05/10/21
Everything went well. This was a positive experience from beginning to the end of us finishing the last piece of this AWESOME coconut cake. We'll be back for more.
Judi P. - Munford, TN
05/10/21
Delivered in timely manner. Item was perfectly intact.
Kevin R. - Henderson, NV
07/26/21
No complaints. Everything was great!!! The cake was delicious!!!
Terric H. - Martinsburg, WV
07/12/21
From ordering to delivery all went well, and recipient was delighted with pies.
Jack C. - Jamestown, RI
07/06/21
Everything! Cake arrived on time packed immaculately, AND was the best pound cake I've ever had!
Kristina K. - Bay Point, CA
07/04/21
I ordered the coconut cake for my 75th birthday. The best coconut cake I have ever eaten since my Mother has passed. Keep up the good baking!
Mary S. - Graham, NC
06/20/21
Merry exceptional packaging!! Yummy cake delivered when promised!
Christine B. - Santa Rosa Beach, FL
06/20/21
The cake was delicious and it arrived in time with no issues at all
Dawn d. - Eddington, ME
06/14/21
The cake was terrific and packed really well.
Donna B. - Torrance, CA
06/09/21
Delivery was as promised. Delicious pound cake!
Jacquelyn R. - Waynesboro, VA
06/06/21
Everything. Shipment arrived on time. My family is loving the flavors.
Anne C. - Memphis, TN
06/02/21
My sister loves Strawberry cake. She said it was the best she had ever had. It was delivered perfectly and on time. It couldn’t have gone any better! Thank you!
Kasey T. - Lexington, KY
06/01/21
I was able to get the half strawberry cake also the half Italian cream cake and I found them on the website easily and got my order when I asked for it. Also the cakes were delicious as usual. Thank you Goldbelly I will be ordering again.
Velar W. - Warren, MI
05/31/21