Panna Dream Ice Cream Cake - Create Your Own

Photo Credit: @mikejchau

We’re inviting you to design your dream ice cream cake! Our customers in NYC love doing this and we’re excited to offer it nationwide now. Pick 2 dream ice cream flavors for the 2 layers of the cake, pick your crust, pick your fillings (crunch and drizzle – this is the most fun part) and pick the message you want to be written in chocolate on top of the Panna frosting!

Inspired by the cafes and gelaterias of Rome, which are a ubiquitous part of daily life in the eternal city, Caffè Panna is Hallie Meyer’s love letter to ice cream and Italy. They churn every ice cream flavor onsite daily using the finest ingredients. Fresh fruits are sourced from their neighbors at the Union Square Greenmarket and specialty ingredients are imported from Italy. You can taste the difference!

More Details

This package serves 12 people and includes a 10" Ice Cream Cake

  • Choose to add a chocolate inscription to your cake!
Pick Your 1st & 2nd. Ice Cream Layer
  • Vanilla* -
  • Chocolate*
  • Red Flag* - sweet cream ice cream with strawberry swirl and graham crunch
  • Caffe Bianco Stracciatella* - white coffee ice cream with Amano chocolate Stracciatella
  • Oreo* - we infuse actual Oreos into our sweet cream so this flavor tastes exactly like the cookie!
  • Pistachio* - Sicilian pistachio pure and simple.
  • Peanut butter* - smooth and creamy
  • Nocciola* - Piedmontese hazelnut ice cream that goes great with a Chocolate layer
  • Eggnog* - lightly spiced frozen custard that goes great with graham crunch crust
  • Gingerbread* - we infuse spiced gingerbread cookies and biscoff cookies to create a smooth gingerbread base
  • Chocolate Sorbet (v)* - the darkest chocolate ever and happens to be totally vegan
Choose Your Crunch Filling
  • Graham Crunch - our classic buttery graham crunch
  • Oreo Brittle - buttery slightly salted Oreo crunches. Like a Carvel cake but better.
  • Chocolate Chip Cookies
  • Salted Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
  • Candied Pecans
  • No Filling*
Choose Your Drizzle Filling
  • Strawberry Drizzle
  • Fig Drizzle
  • Crema di Nocciola - like Nutella but made with absurdly good hazelnuts
  • Peanut butter Drizzle 
  • Sicilian PIstachio Drizzle 
  • Fudge Drizzle
  • *Caramel* - slightly salted and dark
Choose Your Crust
  • Graham Crunch Crust - our classic buttery graham cracker brittle crust
  • Oreo Brittle Crust - buttery slightly salted Oreo brittle crust
Choose an Inscription
  • No Inscription
  • *

Ingredients

Cream, milk, sugar, corn syrup, butter, salt

  • Vanilla* - (cream, milk, sugar, Heilala vanilla beans, corn syrup, salt)
  • Chocolate* - (cream, cocoa, milk, sugar, corn syrup, salt)
  • Red Flag* - (cream, milk, sugar, corn syrup, salt, strawberry, pectin, graham crackers, butter)
  • Caffe Bianco Stracciatella* - (cream, milk, sugar, corn syrup, salt, coffee beans, raspberry, chocolate)
  • Oreo* - (cream, milk, sugar, corn syrup, salt, Oreos, vanilla)
  • Pistachio* - (cream, milk, sugar, corn syrup, salt, 100% pistachio paste )
  • Peanut butter* - (cream, milk, sugar, corn syrup, salt, peanut butter)
  • Nocciola* - (cream, milk, sugar, corn syrup, salt, 100% hazelnut paste)
  • Eggnog* - (cream, milk, sugar, corn syrup, salt, egg yolks, nutmeg, cinnamon, cloves, ginger)
  • Gingerbread* - (cream, milk, sugar, corn syrup, salt, flour, butter, baking soda, ginger, molasses, nutmeg, cinnamon, Biscoff cookies)
  • Chocolate Sorbet (v)* - (Amano chocolate, cocoa powder, water, sugar, corn syrup, salt, vanilla)
Crust Flavor
  • Graham Crunch crust - our classic buttery graham cracker brittle crust (graham crackers, butter, sugar, salt)
  • Oreo Brittle crust - buttery slightly salted Oreo brittle crust (Oreos, butter, sugar, salt)

Crunch Filling: 

  • Graham Crunch - our classic buttery graham crunch (graham crackers, butter, sugar, salt)
  • Oreo Brittle - buttery slightly salted Oreo crunches. Like a Carvel cake but better. (Oreos, butter, sugar, salt)
  • Chocolate Chip Cookies - (four, sugar, brown sugar, butter, eggs, chocolate, baking powder, salt)
  • Salted Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough - (four, sugar, brown sugar, butter, eggs, chocolate, baking powder, salt)
  • *Candied Pecans * - (pecans, butter, sugar, egg whites, salt)
Drizzle Filling
  • Strawberry drizzle - (strawberry, sugar, pectin)
  • Fig Drizzle - (figs, sugar, pectin)
  • Crema di Nocciola - like Nutella but made with absurdly good hazelnuts (hazelnuts, cocoa, sugar, salt)
  • Peanut butter drizzle - (peanut butter, coconut oil)
  • Sicilian PIstachio drizzle -
  • Fudge drizzle - (cocoa, sugar, corn syrup, water, salt)
  • *Caramel* - slightly salted and dark (sugar, corn syrup, French butter, sea salt)

Instructions / Storage

  • Ice Cream Cake ships frozen with dry ice
  • Do not remove dry ice with bare hands
  • Ice cream cake may be kept frozen for up to 2 months.

To serve

  • Remove the ice cream cake from the freezer 5 mins before serving
  • Enjoy!

Shipping Details

  • Caffè Panna ships Monday-Wednesday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New York

(
 4.9) REVIEWS

Shipment arrived on time. It was in perfect condition with plenty of dry ice to keep it frozen. It was packaged very carefully so nothing would be ruined.
Matthew S. - Cumming, GA
02/18/20
First problem dealt with perfectly, and everything rectified accordingly; ice cream came frozen and on time, in perfect condition.
Aaron G. - Highland Beach, FL
07/27/20
It arrived on time and was in great condition.
Ashley N. - Bridgewater, NJ
07/26/20
Ordering was very easy and the quality of all the products I ordered was amazing! Packaging was great as well.
Melanie N. - Houston, TX
03/11/21
Goldbelly customer service team was great about correcting an issue we had with shipping and it’s impact to the item. Would highly recommend based on customer service
Kelly M. - Lakewood, CA
12/10/20
Ice cream always arrives cold, hard and frozen. Good thing! Never melted. I marvel at how that is possible. Truly amazing! Fun stickers in the package from your brand. Super cute and nice to give kids.
Louis M. - Pacific Palisades, CA
10/28/20
Everything 10/10
nicholas d. - McKinney, TX
09/21/20
All six pints of ice cream came in perfect condition, and each was fantastic.
Aaron G. - Highland Beach, FL
12/21/20
Very easy to order, I found exactly what I was looking for, and delivery was very timely!
Kate K. - Saint Louis, MO
10/18/20
Everything was perfect
Stu G. - Ocean, NJ
02/25/21
Shipped on time, shipped to my door (apartment), food in good condition.
Lindsey C. - San Jose, CA
02/17/21
Shipping was fast and everything was still frozen.
Susan K. - Lakewood, WI
04/07/21
Tasty food, delivered on time!
Eleanor N. - Brooklyn, NY
04/11/21
Great ice cream!!
josh c. - Olympia, WA
06/13/21
caffe panna is incredible. timely delivery and great flavors
Lauren M. - East Hampton, NY
08/20/21