Choose Your Own Pies - 2 Pack

Arrives after Halloween

Opened in 2006 by husband-wife team Rick & Val Thompson, Estes Park Pie Shop bakes pies from scratch using recipes and techniques passed down from their great grandma in Estes Park Colorado. The bakers at Estes Park Pie Shop fill every one of their world-famous pies with 6 cups of bursting-with-flavor seasonal fruit (double the amount used by most bakeries) and never include any preservatives or canned fruit. Their signature crunchy sugar crumb topping seals the deal, adding a distinctive texture and crunch.

This sweet apple pie is a multiple Blue Ribbon winner! Granny Smith apples and cinnamon combined with the brown sugar and oat crumble topping, drizzled with caramel and chopped pecans make this a pie to remember.

More Details

  • This package includes 2 pies of your choice
  • Each pie is 9" round and serves 8 people
  • Pie arrives in a reusable aluminum pie tin
  • All pies are vegan—naturally made with vegetable shortening and no lard

Flavor Options Include

  • Caramel Apple Pecan
  • Rhubarb
  • Strawberry Rhubarb
  • Dutch Apple
  • Blueberry Peach
  • Blueberry
  • Cherry Peach
  • Cherry
  • Peach
  • Apple Ginger Peach

Instructions / Storage

  • Pies are baked fresh and arrives ready to enjoy
  • Upon arrival, place pies at room temperature, in the refrigerator or in the freezer. Pies can be stored at room temperature or 4-5 days, in the refrigerator for 7 days or in the freezer, wrapped tightly for up to 6 months
  • Enjoy at room temperature or serve warm. To warm, heat pies in a 350F preheated oven for 20 minutes
  • Pies do not contain any artificial colors, sweeteners or preservatives
  • The reusable pie tin is dishwasher safe. Do not place in the microwave

Shipping Details

  • Items are prepared fresh and shipped directly from the shop
  • Estes Park Pie Shop ships Monday-Friday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Recommended for you

More from Colorado


The package was protective & maintained a proper temperature. It was so delicious, from the buttery crumb topping, the fruit filling a perfect texture & just right balance of sweet & tart, down to the flakiest most flavorful crust. I'm really not doing it justice. I'll probably have to get another one to be sure it's that good.
Jill E. - Grass Valley, CA
The pie was well packaged and still cool. Looked great !
Mary O. - Carlsbad, NM
The crust and topping were buttery and delicious and were the best part of the pie.
Sharon P. - Winter Garden, FL
It is juicy and all-around excellent.
Robert B. - Orovada, NV
The first pie was utterly delicious. We will be sharing the others at an upcoming party.
Robert B. - Orovada, NV
The pie was great and it was delivered right on time.
Chad K. - New Orleans, LA
I was super impressed with the rhubarb pie from Estes Park Pies. It was shipped from Colorado to San Diego and was still so good! Shipped frozen and ready to eat. 
Elizabeth K. - La Jolla, CA
Delicious & fresh. Best Carmel apple pie EVER!
Mary K. - Riviera Beach, FL
I am so very happy to have found Goldbelly! The choices are unbelievable and the service outstanding! I ordered the Caramel apple pecan pie and the rhubarb pie from Estes Park Bakery and they came to me just as I requested, the day before Thanksgiving, and were in pristine condition, plus both absolutely delicious! My family can’t stop talking about the caramel apple pecan pie. I ordered the rhubarb just for me as I knew it wasn’t their favorite as it is mine and plain rhubarb is so difficult to find. I have already ordered 2 gift cakes to be sent as Christmas gifts from a different bakery. I feel certain they will be as successful a purchase as the pies. Goldbelly has a new repeat customer! Thank you!
Anne P. - Stockton, CA
I ordered the rhubarb pie for Thanksgiving as a surprise for my daughter-in-law’s father who had mentioned several weeks prior that he hadn’t eaten straight rhubarb pie in years because you couldn’t find it in CA. The look on his face was priceless! He said it was the best he had ever eaten.
Sharon B. - Livermore, CA
It's rare to find a rhubarb pie. This pie was delicious. It was packed solid with rhubarb and was not overly sweet. The pie arrived in perfect condition. I'll be ordering another one after the holidays.
Doris C. - League City, TX
Delivery was when promised. Pie was very high quality and pleased my guests.
James C. - Livermore, CA
Very well packed... I was given 2 pies from the Estes Park Pie Shop, they arrived completely intact. No cracks and not a crumb out of place. They also were the best bakery pies I've ever eaten.
Peter S. - Salida, CA
Let me just say that everything was excellent from the packaging, delivery & last but certainly not least, the quality of the pie was over the top. I don't know what sort of magic they use at the Estes Bakery but their strawberry rhubarb pie is exquisitely exceptional. From the best crust you've ever had to the fabulous filling, incredible texture & mind blowing taste sensations. It's quite simply the greatest.
Jill E. - Grass Valley, CA
The pie was well packaged and still cool. Looked great !
Mary O. - Carlsbad, NM
Delivered on time and pie was delicious.
Gary G. - Hobe Sound, FL
Delivered when promised, recipient loved the pie, said it was the best they ever had, flakey crust & lots of blueberries in the filling
Tyler G. - Boulder, CO