An original farmhouse recipe, this pie contains only the finest ingredients including cream, sugar, and nutmeg. Wick built his business on Sugar Cream Pie over 70 years ago, and it remains a Hoosier favorite! It’s similar in taste to that of a crème brûlée; lightly sweet, smooth like a custard, and sure to be a family favorite.

Back in 1944, Duane "Wick’’ Wickersham opened a small cafe inside an Indiana factory to serve lunch to its employees. He relied on many of his grandmother’s recipes, including one for a classic Indiana specialty, Sugar Cream Pie. A full-service restaurant soon followed, within four years he was selling 300 of his pies every day, and Wick’s Pies was on its way to becoming one of Indiana’s most beloved pie makers. Wick’s pies are still made according to those same family recipes, and the Wickersham family still runs the company to this day.

More Details

This package serves 8 people and includes a Sugar Cream Pie

  • Each pie measures 9"


  • Sugar Cream Pie – Crust (Wheat Flour [Unenriched, Unbleached], Lard, Water, Salt, Dextrose, and Baking Soda), Filling (Skim-Milk, Cream, Sugar, Wheat Flour [Unenriched, Unbleached], Butter [Sweet Cream, Salt], Artificial Flavoring, Salt, and Nutmeg)
    Allergens: Contains Wheat (Gluten), Milk, and Tree Nuts (Coconut). Processed on the same line as Wheat, Milk, Eggs, Soy, Peanuts, and Tree Nuts. Facility contains Wheat, Milk, Eggs, Soy, Peanuts, and Tree Nuts.

Instructions / Storage

  • Pies ship frozen with ice packs, may thaw in transit
  • Upon arrival store in the freezer until ready to prepare

To Serve

  • Preheat oven to 350 degrees
  • Take pie out of Freezer
  • Remove plastic wrap
  • Remove plastic dome
  • Ensure all plastic is removed
  • Place in oven for 25 minutes at 350 degrees
  • Let pie cool for 10 minutes
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Wick’s Pies ships Monday-Wednesday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Indiana


Pie was very well packed.
Anne P. - Charlotte, NC
Easy ordering and the recipient was pleased!
LORI L. - Canton, OH
Arrived still frozen and on time
Vicki K. - Hereford, AZ
Everything was perfect! Product as promised, delivery as promised! My sister was very happy to receive her favorite pie even after the holidays.
Alicia W. - North Port, FL
I ordered two pies and they arrived on the exact day the tracking said they would. Both pies were as fresh as if they had just come out of the oven. Everyone enjoyed them!
Antonette M. - Sun City, CA
Quick shipping! Fabulous Mrs. Wick’s Pies !
Jewel T. - Chuluota, FL
I'm a "transplanted" Hoosier living in Arizona. You have no idea how happy you made me to be able to order a Wick's Sugar Cream pie. I will definitely be purchasing more. Thank you.
Peggy M. - Tucson, AZ
Arrived on time and perfectly chilled. Product was exactly as described.
Susan K. - Janesville, WI
The pies were AMAZING, so delicious. And the shipping was truly fantastic!! It arrived right on time, pies were still frozen and I am so grateful. I will definitely be spreading your name around.
Cathy M. - Mammoth, AZ
Everything went as expected. In other words, no negative surprises. And that's a rare experience for me these days!
WILLIAM W. - Clearwater, FL
Arrived in perfect condition.
Carol H. - Huntsville, AL
The products are pricey but good and delivery is usually prompt.
Karen P. - Johnson City, NY