Peanut Butter & Jelly 4-Layer Cake
From
We Take the Cake
( 4.8)
We Take the Cake reimagined a favorite childhood classic sandwich and created the Peanut Butter and Jelly Cake! The moist and light peanut butter cake is filled with rich peanut butter cream cheese and sweet grape jam filling. The outside is frosted with cream cheese with swirls of peanut butter and topped off with cream cheese dollops and a dot of grape jelly. Grab a glass of cold milk and find your inner child as you bite into a slice of heaven. Yummy in your Tummy!!!
We Take The Cake has become one of the most sought after, made-from-scratch bakeries in the US. The team at We Take The Cake understands that it’s not just about sending a cake. It represents celebration, comfort, appreciation, love, and togetherness, even if you can’t be there yourself. They take pride in mixing the batters and frosting from scratch, using whole milk, fresh eggs and real butter, NEVER a cake mix or commercially made frostings.
More Details
This package serves 8-10 people includes a Peanut Butter & Jelly 4-Layer Cake
- Each Layer Cake is 6" round and 4.5" tall
- Cakes arrive in a beautiful branded box
Ingredients
Peanut Butter Cake – (Granulated Sugar, Wheat Flour, Sour Cream, Whole Eggs, Unsalted Butter, Shortening, Egg Yolks, Vanilla Extract, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Salt, Peanut Butter), Peanut Butter Cream Cheese Frosting (Cream Cheese, Unsalted Butter, Powdered Sugar, Peanut Butter), Buttercream Frosting (Shortening, Unsalted Butter, Powdered Sugar, Vanilla Extract, Salt), Grape Jelly, Cream Cheese (Cream Cheese, Unsalted Butter, Powdered Sugar)
Instructions / Storage
- Layer cakes are baked to order, frozen, and shipped with dry ice, may dissipate in transit
- Do Not remove Dry Ice with bare hands
- Upon arrival, place cake at room temperature, in the refrigerator or in the freezer.
- Cakes can be stored at room temperature for 3-4 days, in the refrigerator for up to 2 weeks, or in the freezer for up to 3 months.
To Serve
- Allow cakes to reach room temperature before enjoying (approximately 2-3 hours from frozen)
Shipping Details
- We Take the Cake ships Monday-Thursday of each week
- Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
- Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
- Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.
Corporate Gift Orders
You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.
Recommended for you
More from Florida
( 4.8) We Take the Cake REVIEWS
It was the best cake I have ever eaten!
Patsy H. - Saint Johns, FL
07/23/19
The packaging was lovely and very sturdy. The cakes themselves were totally delicious!
Cynthia S. - Big Spring, TX
08/28/19
The cake was amazing! Best Gluten Free cake we’ve ever had. You would never know it was gluten free.
Jessica C. - Vernon Hills, IL
09/04/19
It was delicious! It was gluten free but you could not tell as the taste and texture were exactly like a regular cake - a regular delicious cake! It was also beautiful in a beautiful package.
Kiesha P. - Sunbury, OH
09/17/19
Prompt delivery. Cake was in excellent shape and very fresh. Most importantly, it was the best vegan chocolate cake we’ve ever had!
Ben G. - Princeton, NJ
09/18/19
Gluten-Free Chocolate 4-Layer Cake: The cake arrived in perfect condition, and it tasted great! Everybody loved it and nobody could tell it was gluten free! It’s a wonderful way to get something out of the ordinary at home!
Valerie P. - Dalton, GA
09/27/19
Arrived on time. Cake was moist, tart, and wonderful! I love key lime! Would order again!
Melnyk W. - Ocala, FL
10/08/19
I loved everything about the Fresh Strawberry 4-Layer Cake. It was really fresh and moist. And, the frosting was amazing as well.
Katie G. - Merigold, MS
10/07/19
Awesome. Flavor was great, texture was great, icing was wonderful. Delivery / packaging was awesome. It was enjoyed be all. Will order again.
Janet C. - Selma, NC
10/24/19
Super easy to order from-shipment arrived on time in excellent condition. And it tasted fabulous! Can’t ask for more than that!!
Debra M. - Kissimmee, FL
10/18/19
The cake was delicious. We followed the instructions and it was great! This was for a special birthday, and the cake was delivered exactly on the requested date.
Mary L. - Napa, CA
10/16/19
Perfect cake enjoyed by a chocolate cake enthusiast who know a good chocolate cake!!!! Arrived exactly when I requested!
Ellen E. - Port Orange, FL
10/30/19
It is the first time I ordered a cake online and it was delicious. My daughter is vegan and she loved it!I guess my cakes will be ordered from Goldbelly for the future birthdays. Thank you!
Betty G. - Bronx, NY
11/05/19
The gluten free chocolate cake was the best cake I ever had! Soooo delicious and moist, it was hit for our family gathering!
Rezina W. - Vernon, AL
11/13/19
"The cake presentation was beautiful! My gluten free family members were shocked at how long the cake can be kept frozen and the taste was amazing! I'll be ordering again for sure!"
Doreen P. - Somers, CT
11/21/19
"The cake looked beautiful and the taste was phenomenal! I couldn’t tell it was gluten free! I will definitely be ordering again! Thanks from all us celiac public!!!♥️"
Rita S. - Memphis, TN
12/03/19
Cake arrived on time which was hard to believe in the short notice that I ordered the cake to the time of the birthday party. I didn't believe it would arrive on time but to my surprise it arrived hours ahead of the party!
Everyone was impressed by the cake- quality and taste of the strawberry!
Ali D. - Lees Summit, MO
01/20/20
Delivered on time and delicious!
Laurie G. - Brentwood, TN
01/19/20
Cake was absolutely delicious!
Joy S. - Englewood, FL
12/01/19
VERY FRESH, GREAT TASTE, FAST DELIVERY
Alicia G. - Tampa, FL
12/01/19
The cake looked beautiful and the taste was phenomenal! I couldn’t tell it was gluten-free! I will definitely be ordering again! Thanks from all us celiac public!!!♥️
Rita S. - Memphis, TN
12/01/19
Delicious inside and out!
Carolyn L. - Los Angeles, CA
12/02/19
Arrived on time with clear instructions. Delicious cake
Margaret B. - Hopkinton, NH
12/02/19
The Cake from We Take the Cake, was the hit of the party! Delicious!
Denise S. - Morro Bay, CA
12/18/19
Ordered it as a gift and the cake was well received!
Carol R. - Beach Haven, NJ
12/18/19
We take the Cake is the superb cake maker!
Regina P. - Blackstone, VA
12/08/19
We Take the Cake was reasonably priced. They also taste very good.
JANET K. - Germantown Hills, IL
12/27/19
My dad loved his birthday cake. Chocolate, chocolate and chocolate.
Robert E. - Wilkes Barre, PA
12/26/19
The chocolate cake was delicious, very moist, the chocolate frosting was good and not over powering the cake. I will definitely be ordering from them again
Terry D. - Brooklyn, NY
12/17/19
Best tasting red velvet cake gluten free or regular that we have ever had. Even our guest were shocked that it was gluten free.
Delivered quickly and packed perfectly with great instructions on how to thaw.
Luann P. - West Palm Beach, FL
12/28/19
The cake was delicious and I will be reordering. It’s unlike anything I could find where I live. It arrived frozen and we just followed the thawing/serving directions.
Karen G. - Oceanside, CA
12/28/19
Very rich cake texture, rich cream filling and coconut overall. Would be easier to serve if you made the cake larger and not so tall.
Joseph M. - Leland, NC
12/22/19
Love the salty yummy finish to the rich chocolate vegan cake! Would order again. :)
Smith A. - Carlisle, PA
12/24/19
My wife was thrilled with the gift of a red velvet cake without gluten. When we began dating 44 years ago, a red velvet cake played a big role. And the cake was moist and delicioius.
Glenn W. - Newport News, VA
12/25/19
everything about the order the cake delivery and the cake was excellent.... first time to use goldbelly but will again.... the cake is delicious and the instructions perfect.... will surley recommend...…
Nancy A. - Keller, TX
12/26/19
It was deliver in a timely manner and arrived earlier than expected. The cake was delicious and moist.
Mary V. - Wyncote, PA
12/26/19
Great cake! Thank you, you made the celebration a success!
Michelle T. - Albuquerque, NM
12/30/19
The gluten free chocolate cake was moist and delicious!
Robin F. - Woodinville, WA
12/29/19
Fresh. No added chemicals for preservation, fresh cake, fresh ingredients, very good. Somewhat pricey, but you get a awesome product that will please. Well worth the higher price.
MARK K. - Hazleton, PA
12/30/19
FABULOUS G.F. CAKE !!!!!
I want to order another immediately.
Spot on delivery
Kate S. - Duluth, MN
01/06/20
The cakes were moist, flavorful and delicious! Love the key lime!
Joshua G. - Middletown, PA
02/11/20
We loved the cake! Very moist and key lime flavor was perfect. I would definitely recommend this cake and will be ordering again.
Regina W. - Abilene, TX
11/19/19
I have boy/girl twins. My daughter is a vegan and my son loves chocolate so the Vegan Chocolate 4-Layer Cake was the perfect birthday cake. They've already asked for one for next year!!
Erica M. - Brookhaven, NY
01/20/20
I ordered it for my sister's birthday to send to her in Philly. It arrived on time, she loved the box and candles inside. It's a small cake but I am really pleased with it as a fun surprise for someone you can't share a birthday with in person.
Julie W. - Philadelphia, PA
11/25/19
Delivery on time, cake was wonderful!
Brian S. - Chicago, IL
11/20/19
Presentation was terrific, taste was delightful!
Sherryl D. - Americus, GA
11/20/19
The cake presentation was beautiful. My gluten free family members were shocked at how long the cake can be kept frozen and the taste was amazing! I'll be ordering again for sure.
Doreen P. - Somers, CT
11/21/19
Shipping is fast and cake arrived in perfect condition!! I will definitely order again!!
Alicia O. - Clarksville, TN
11/22/19
I don’t *love* cake, so I was skeptical about this month’s subscription box. But, WOW! Thanks for curating a spectacular collection, Goodbelly!
Joshua S. - Gainesville, FL
01/28/20
This was a beautiful chocolate cake. I think it was the best chocolate cake I ever had
Lili S. - Saint Louis, MO
01/29/20
Best best cake possible
Mark N. - Santa Fe, NM
02/06/20
Per my daughter - "this is the best cake I have ever had in my life." Sent for her 21st birthday.
Alison R. - East Lansing, MI
02/07/20
Beautiful cake
Shipping was great!
T W. - Cornelius, NC
02/08/20
My family loved it. It was well made. Thank you.
Michael K. - Snow Camp, NC
02/09/20
I sent the cake to my son in college in California (I'm based in Hong Kong). THE CAKE WAS HELLA DELICIOUS. Last year I spent almost 3 days looking for a chocolate cake without fruit (he recoils at the sight of fruit, silly boy) in the Berkeley area plus finding someone/a company to pick it up and deliver it as the only option available did not offer delivery. All in all, pretty stressful. THIS TOOK 20 minutes and I LOVE IT. Will definitely use it again. THANK YOU and thank you to the bakery that we got it from in Florida.
Alexander L. - Berkeley, CA
02/10/20
Arrived beautifully!
Casey O. - San Clemente, CA
02/10/20
Delivery was on time and cake arrived still cold. Excellent flavor
Kaytlyn R. - Wellington, FL
02/14/20
My cake arrived on time & it was exactly as pictured . Plus it was delicious!
Robin L. - Sarasota, FL
02/14/20
The cupcakes were not only beautiful but they tasted great and came in beautiful condition. Everyone that received your package was totally impressed and enthralled
Coco B. - Southport, CT
02/16/20
Beautiful and delicious cupcakes!
Denise L. - Orchard Lake, MI
02/17/20
Condition that the cake came in was perfect
Barbara M. - Sarasota, FL
02/17/20
Everything. The promised delivery time to the incredible cupcakes!
Andrea T. - Bethesda, MD
02/17/20
The cake was absolutely wonderful! All notifications, tracking and delivery were excellent. Great job, thanks!
Barbara G. - Weaverville, NC
02/17/20
Everything. Ordered a week in advance, set a delivery date and it arrived in tact and on time.
Don H. - Oklahoma City, OK
02/17/20
The cake was beautiful. It arrived a day early for a birthday surprise but when eaten, it was delicious!
Heidi L. - Sarasota, FL
02/18/20
The best cake I ever had! Soooo delicious and moist, it was hit for our family gathering.
Rezina W. - Vernon, AL
11/13/19
Perfect taste and totally untouched by being shipped
Lee R. - Fairview, NC
02/18/20
The cake arrived on time and in good condition. We enjoyed it very much.
Butch R. - Vancouver, WA
02/19/20
Delivery was on time! Cake was delicious!
Melissa A. - Chippewa Falls, WI
02/18/20
Not only were the cupcakes beautiful, the cake texture was soft and delicious. Even the frosting was soft and delicious Will definitely order from them again!
Devan V. - Nashville, TN
02/19/20
Those cupcakes were almost too beautiful to eat. I sent them to my Mom and her caregivers. They were so thrilled. They also tasted great.
Martha M. - Detroit, OR
02/20/20
Display was great, cup cakes tasted awesome, and the frosting was perfect. Really enjoyed this gift for my wife.
John H. - Salt Lake City, UT
02/20/20
Everything went well from ease of making the selection and placing the order online to delivery and condition of cake upon arrival when it was scheduled. Nothing more to ask for....an "A+" !!
Marilyn L. - Jacksonville, FL
02/27/20
The cakes were delivered on time and were still cold! When we followed the serving directions they were delicious!. The birthday recipient loved them!
Josie S. - San Antonio, TX
02/28/20
I loved everything! From decisions to delivery to delicious! Thank you Goldbelly for making our daughter’s 13th birthday perfect with an amazing vegan cake!!
Lisa I. - Birmingham, AL
03/03/20
Delicious
Madison W. - Providence, RI
03/05/20
Everything was perfect. The cake was moist and the rose frosting was untouched by the shipping!
Mary T. - Houston, TX
03/04/20
Chocolate birthday cake was said to be delicious. It was a gift.
It arrived when promised.
They enjoyed having candles included.
JR V. - Watertown, CT
03/10/20
Wonderful, tasty cake! Absoleutly beautiful!
No shipping or breakage. Cake arrived perfect!
Teresa D. - Crossville, TN
03/10/20
Fast shipping time and item arrived in excellent condition. Explicit instructions for consumption and storage on the outside packaging.
Jacqueline S. - Merritt Island, FL
03/16/20
Food arrived beautifully, even with it's delicate, intricate frosting bouncing around a Brooklyn delivery truck!
Amanda L. - Brooklyn, NY
04/20/21
Everything.- The birthday cake reached my daughter on the date stated. The cake I ordered was gluten-free, and they said it was so delicious and moist; and tasted like a normal cake.
SOFIA C. - Park City, UT
04/18/21
Delivered exactly when promised. Excellent packaging. Looked exactly as pictured even after traveling so far. An excellent gift!
Patricia E. - Efland, NC
04/17/21
The timing of Delivery
The cake was delicious. My daughter turned 16 and she absolutely loved it!!
Angel J. - Ewing, NJ
04/12/21
ordered carrot cake for my wife's birthday. i rarely eat cake (maybe a slice a year) and am not a fan of carrot cake. i ate 2 slices at one sitting, absolutely great!
Gregg B. - Cincinnati, OH
04/06/21
Cake arrived in perfect condition and was shipped on time. The cake was beautiful and very delicious.
Nancy H. - North Little Rock, AR
04/06/21
The cake was super delicious and moist! It came packaged on dry ice and I let it unthaw to room temperature. My family raved about it! I will definitely order again.
Bernice M. - Allenhurst, GA
04/05/21
We sent a cake to our friends for their anniversary and they said it was seriously the best they’ve ever had...and they are major foodies. I now want to order one for me and my hubs to try 😋
Andy S. - Orlando, FL
04/01/21
Cake was delicious and looked perfect at delivery. Not one sprinkle was out of place!
Amber P. - Issaquah, WA
03/20/21
Cake arrived on time in mint condition. After 2 days in the fridge, placed on the counter for 2 hours prior to serving. The cake was rich, moist and decadent! The frosting and decorative finish were creamy and delicious!
Jeff S. - Newport News, VA
02/27/21
Everything went well! I ordered a cake for my brother’s graduation event at the last minute. I got it on time! The ordering process is always easy.
APRIL G. - Atoka, TN
05/25/21
It was so easy and tremendous selection.
Robert K. - Mobile, AL
05/25/21
Absolutely incredible cupcakes! They looked perfect, were incredibly moist and flavorful, and arrived right on time.
Jim D. - Tacoma, WA
05/25/21
Ordering and delivery were great. My daughter in law said they were beautiful and tasted great. I liked the fact that the cupcakes could be continue to be frozen, or eaten right away. That was one of my big decisions in this product.
Jacqueline O. - Portland, OR
05/24/21
Everything!!!! Packaging, Tracking & Delivery was EXCELLENT!!!!
Golden C. - Lewisville, TX
05/24/21
Everything went well, both items were exactly as their description, neatly packaged, and arrived well/on time
Evelyn R. - Metairie, LA
05/24/21
Cake was delicious, moist and beautifull
Leigh C. - Frisco, TX
05/24/21
Came when it was supposed to. They were absolutely beautiful as described
catherine h. - West Roxbury, MA
05/19/21
Site is wonderful. User friendly. Variety and options are great. Ordering was easy. Shipping and delivery status was great. Boxes are very nice.
Maria C. - Santa Fe, NM
05/18/21
The ordering process was very easy and the items ordered were delivered on time. I was very pleased that the cupcakes arrived intact. The handlers obviously took a lot of care with this package!
Linda B. - Atlanta, GA
05/17/21
Everything ordered from Goldbelly was great. The food arrived exactly as described and pictured. I'll be using them again.
Kay C. - Oakland, TN
05/16/21
We got a lovely gluten-free birthday cake for our sister who lives on the other side of the country. It was easy to find, order, and the delivery went well.
Susan F. - Washington, DC
05/15/21
Presentation was beautiful! The candles were an unexpected surprise.
The cake was delicious! The carnivores in the family were SHOCKED that it was vegan.
Melinda J. - Dallas, TX
05/15/21
I sent the cupcakes to my sister for Mother’s Day. They were beautiful, and everyone said they were really tasty. They didn’t last long!
Laurie S. - West Chester, PA
05/13/21
Everything! Delivery was great and the product was fantastic! So glad to help keep small businesses afloat!
David F. - San Diego, CA
05/12/21
It arrived on the day I had selected. It looked just like the photo, which I had used to make my selection and it tasted fabulous! Thank you!
Gretchen S. - Bryn Mawr, PA
05/12/21
The cupcakes arrived perfectly packaged and they were beautiful and delicious!! As an afterthought they became the centerpiece of the the dining table for Mother’s Day.
Kelly B. - Youngstown, OH
05/12/21
Cupcakes arrived when stated. They were delicious and as beautiful as pictured. I would definitely order again,
Liz H. - Salem, OR
05/12/21
They ABSOLUTELY NEVER DISAPPOINT!! From customer satisfaction to prompt delivery! ‘ WE TAKE THE CAKE’ was a WONDERFUL selection as all the others I have experimented with! Thank you ever so much!
Pamela G. - Huntsville, AL
08/08/21
Tracking was great. Arrived in beautiful condition.
Sara Y - Seattle, WA
08/08/21
Delivery on time. Tasted amazing!
Lora S. - Moses Lake, WA
08/08/21
Delicious, beautiful cake! Everyone raved about it.
Mark D. - Moreland Hills, OH
08/07/21
Everything went well everyone enjoyed both of the cakes very much!!!!
Doug B. - Osyka, MS
08/06/21
Thé cake was fresh and very well packaged to protect the contents.
Shelia M. - Atlantic City, NJ
08/06/21
THE BEST CAKE EVER!!!!
Shelley J. - Ash Flat, AR
08/03/21
The cake arrived on time. It was packaged beautifully and even in the hot summer weather it was perfect. The cake was also moist and delicious which isn’t easy with gluten free! I would recommend it to others.
Laura F. - Ship Bottom, NJ
08/03/21
Shipped & delivered on time, absolutely delicious!
Tara M. - Asbury Park, NJ
08/02/21
Delivered on time in excellent condition. Cake was delicious.
Terry G. - Kenoza Lake, NY
08/02/21
The birthday cake gift was delivered on time, well packaged, and most importantly, thoroughly enjoyed by all. The recipient(s) reported that the cake was magnificent.
Rhonda W. - Tallahassee, FL
08/02/21
Packages were received still frozen and in perfect condition!!! Very happy with my experience!
Sonia B. - Becket, MA
08/01/21
Delivery was on time and cupcakes were delicious! Looked beautiful, just like the picture!
Lindsey R. - West Jefferson, OH
08/01/21
Everything was great! Easy to order, delivery as promised and excellent quality!
Anthony R. - Hudson, MA
08/01/21
The cake arrived on time and was well wrapped and protected. The cake looked and tasted great!
James S. - Portland, OR
08/01/21
Great website with excellent variety. Delivery was A++!
Angela K. - Maitland, FL
08/01/21
Beautiful cupcakes delivered on time!!
Nanette B. - Naples, FL
07/31/21
Wonderful! My niece loved her cake. It was beautiful. Very pleased!
Tamara C. - Middlebourne, WV
07/30/21
The cake was delivered when it was supposed to be. The box and cake were beautiful. It was so easy.
Erin M. - St Petersburg, FL
07/28/21
Delivery was when expected. My daughter said that the cake was as beautiful as pictured on the site and that it was delicious.
Jade T. - Lunenburg, MA
07/27/21
Best chocolate cake ever
Adriano G. - San Antonio, TX
07/26/21
Cake was devine. Perfect delivery!
CAROL S. - La Jolla, CA
07/25/21
Delivery, Beautifully Decorated, Delicious! Thank you! A Birthday Surprise for family member. She loved it!
MARY F. - Las Vegas, NV
07/26/21
I needed a birthday cake at the "last minute" and Goldbelly came through. The cake was delivered on time and, while I didn't get a chance to sample it, the birthday girl and guests said it was fantastic. I always look to Goldbelly when I need something different and I know I can rely on the fact that it will be delivered intact and on time.
Christine A. - Pittsburgh, PA
09/27/21
I am in love with this website! All of my gifts to my loved ones have been food gifts since I found Goldbelly and the recipients have been estatic with everything so far. Everything has arrived on time and been delicious. A special thank you to "We Take the Cake".
Annette S. - Jeffersonville, GA
09/26/21
The entire product, price point, ordering and delivery were excellent.
Vicky W. - Longwood, FL
09/25/21
You guys are amazing - cake delivered on time in amazing condition and looked totally gorgeous not to mention absolutely delicious. We Take the Cake really does take the cake!
Erika O. - Wimberley, TX
09/19/21
The ordering process was easy & easy to understand. The product arrived when it was supposed to. Product is as packed exceptionally well & it was fabulous! One of the best chocolate cakes I’ve ever had!
Christopher A. - Manchester, CT
09/19/21
Delicious Gluten Free cake! Read the reviews and they were 100% correct, best gluten free cake we have ever had.
Stephen H. - New York, NY
09/14/21