Cereal Killer Pie

Product not eligible for additional discounts or promotions

The Pie Hole ships its famous pies nationwide on Goldbelly! Should you eat pie for breakfast? The Pie Hole thinks you should, and we couldn’t agree more, especially if the pie in question is the smash hit Cereal Killer Pie. The Cereal Killer Pie has a cereal crust, and a filling made with a cream cheese base packed with Fruity Pebbles and then topped with Froot Loops. Can you hear your inner child cheering?

Becky Grasley, otherwise known as the “Pie Mom,” had always dreamed of owning her own pie shop. So, when she retired, her son Matt made it his mission to make his mom’s dream come true. Founded in 2011, The Pie Hole makes pies by hand and from scratch using recipes that have been passed down over more than five generations, from traditional Mom’s Apple Crumble, to unique creations like the Cereal Killer Pie, to creative ‘Pie Holes,’ two-bite mini pie treats.

More Details

This package serves 8 people and includes a 9" Cereal Killer Pie

  • Froot Loops come packaged separately

Ingredients

ALL PURPOSE FLOUR, CORN STARCH, WHITE CHOCOLATE, CREAM CHEESE, HEAVY CREAM, SUGAR, WHOLE MILK, BUTTER, LEMON JUICE, SALT, KOSHER, VANILLA EXTRACT "

Instructions / Storage

  • Pies are shipped frozen with ice packs, ice packs may thaw in transit
  • Refrigerate or Freeze upon arrival
  • Pies may be kept frozen for up to 6 months
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • The Pie Hole ships Monday-Friday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from California

REVIEWS

The pie was amazing and super delicious but the price was a little too high.
Deborah H. - Soddy Daisy, TN
12/01/19
The Pie Hole products were the perfect after-dinner treat for a party. The flavors were amazing and everything was well packed and on time.
Barbara C. - Fairfield, NJ
12/10/19
The packaging insured that the product was fresh and not harmed in anyway! It arrived on time and was exactly what I expected. It tasted better than I could have imagined and my mother in law was over the moon for it! A non traditional way to celebrate and I am hooked! I will use Goldbelly often!
Dale S. - Sarasota, FL
12/26/19
The pecan and blueberry pie was delicious but the apple pie not so great.
Bridget O. - Manhattan, KS
01/08/20
The pies were cute and delicious,and they shipped quickly.
Zaquette E. - Cherry Hill, NJ
11/17/19
Ease of ordering. Delivery on time. Recipient stated order arrived in great condition and the product was AWESOME.
Tim P. - Los Angeles, CA
03/28/21
The pie was a success for my son's birthday.
Jason G. - Maryville, TN
03/24/21
Delivery was in good shape and delicious!
joe h. - Dallas, TX
01/15/21
Arrived in a timely fashion. Great taste. My best friend loved the gift!
Louise H. - Watertown, CT
01/14/21
Sent the product as a Christmas present and it arrived on time! It was well received and the review of the product was overwhelming positive!
Adam C. - Spartanburg, SC
01/02/21
Pie Hole's packaging was OUTSTANDING! Food was delivered in a timely manner and everything was delicious! Would absolutely order again! Thanks, Pie Mom!
Scott R. - Aldie, VA
12/22/20
Arrived on time and were amazingly delicious.
Nicholas P. - San Ramon, CA
04/01/21
Arrived well packaged and fast
- ,
03/20/21
Ease in ordering. Great offerings. Very tempting.
Susan A. - Round Lake, IL
05/23/21
Gift for my son, and he is very happy.. Therefore I am delighted!
Stuart H. - Altamonte Springs, FL
04/23/21
The pie was delivered safely and well packed. It was fresh and delicious.
Tabitha B. - Ankeny, IA
04/18/21
My friend loved the gift!!
Kris D. - Bothell, WA
04/06/21
Delivered on time and in a pretty purple box. Everyone enjoyed them.
Ethel W. - Laguna Beach, CA
04/05/21
Goldbelly is always easy to order from and I really love being able to use reward points! The little pie holes were very cute - at least the ones that arrived intact.
Laurie V. - Fresh Meadows, NY
03/04/21
Requested arrival date was almost spot on; product was unique and delicious.
Audrey C. - Flagstaff, AZ
03/06/21
Gift for family in another state. Loved the items from the PIe Hole and packed well.
Robb W. - Holliston, MA
02/19/21
Large variety of choices and price points. Very easy to use and navigate. Great communication from company regarding orders. Will definitely use again.
Ignacio F. - Long Beach, CA
12/23/20
Love GOLDBELLY..Always good and always a great surprise for the recipients. THANKS!!!
ALLEN Z. - Los Angeles, CA
07/06/21
Delivered on time. Arrived safely, well packaged. …and the recipient LOVED them.
Gabriella G. - Philadelphia, PA
06/20/21
Excellent selection of products, I found exactly what I wanted to buy from the get go! I like supporting local businesses nationally! :)
Corey R. - El Campo, TX
06/05/21
Found the perfect items and they were delivered quickly and in beautiful condition. So many choices!
Debra O. - Derby, KS
04/17/21
Sent to my son and family for Father’s Day. They loved it!!
Jack L. - Saint Cloud, MN
06/20/21