Choose Your Own Olives - 4 Quarts

The Pickle Guys ships its famous olives nationwide on Goldbelly! Choose your favorite olives in this pack: Greek olives, Kalamata olives, whole green olives, pimento olives, garlic stuffed olives, and jalapeño stuffed olives. The Pickle Guys pickles are kosher-certified, vegan, and gluten-free.

Founded by Alan Kaufman on New York’s Lower East Side, The Pickle Guys have been making sweet and sour pickles with an old Eastern European recipe “just the way mom used to make them” since 2000. Pickles are cured in a barrel with a salt brine with garlic and spices for as long as six months. The Pickle Guys’ pickles are kosher and have the perfect snap. If you’re ever in a pickle for pickles, you know where to get them!

More Details

  • This package includes 4 quarts of olives of your choosing
  • Olives come in 1-quart glass jars
  • Kosher-certified, Vegan & Gluten Free

Pickle Options Include

  • Greek Olives – With a distinctively fruity, these greek olives give a wine-like flavor. Adding a unique addition to your pantry. They have a subtle touch when it comes to flavor, yet can easily stand out in any dish.
  • Kalamata Olives – The secret mix ensures that each kalamata olive is packed with a fruity and wine-like flavor. This means you can easily add these olives in drinks, or foods of your choice. Adding a refreshing touch that takes you away from the daily flavors, adding a more exotic feel and flavor to your dish. No matter if you add these olives to a salad or just top off your pizza, you are in for a real treat.
  • Whole Green Olives – Currently, the whole green olives are one of our best and refreshing treats we have to offer. With their one-of-a-kind taste and endless benefits, the green olives are a great addition to any meal.
  • Pimento Olives – As pimento is a slightly sweeter and aromatic addition, it takes on a different taste journey when compared with other red peppers. These delicious pimento olives are a delicious snack on their own, or you can use them to add flavor and texture to your martini’s, snacks, or appetizers. As they hold such a refreshing taste that will add to your pallet.
  • Garlic Stuffed Olives – As they offer a unique and refreshing taste that grows with every bite. A wonderful treat to have around the house, as it can be consumed in many different ways. Start by pairing our stuffed garlic olives with savory dishes, and enjoy the beautiful taste they bring to the dish.
  • Jalapeno Stuffed Olives – These olives possess the perfect body, with a taste that stands out from the rest. You can use the jalapeno stuffed olives to add anything from cocktails, to your appetizer and main courses. Each bite is a celebration between the taste of olive and jalapeno, combined with any flavors of your choice.


Greek Olives
Kalamata Olives – Olives, Water, Salt, (May Contain Vinegar).
Whole Green Olives – Olives, Water, Salt, (If Stuffed: May Contain Pimento, Garlic, Jalapeno, Sun-Dried Tomato or Almond).
Pimento Olives
Garlic Stuffed Olives
Jalapeno Stuffed Olives

Instructions / Storage

  • Pickles arrive ready to serve
  • Upon arrival, remove packaging and place the pickles in the refrigerator
  • Pickles can be stored in the refrigerator for up to 1 month
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • The Pickle Guys ships Monday – Wednesday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New York


I am addicted to these pickles. Just like from my childhood in NYC.
B F. - San Jose, CA
The Pickle Guys need to give classes on how to wrap food for delivery! It took me 20 minutes to "break-in" to the packed container of pickles, lol. This was NOT an annoying experience due to my receipt of damaged shipping containers from another vendor. Rather, I very much appreciated the care with which the container was secured to ensure it survived the shipping process. The pickles are excellent! I am tickled with the purchase.
Patricia B. - Cheverly, MD
The pickles arrived on the date promised - all the way to the west coast-and were perfectly”half-sour”. I was able to track the order and was contacted when it was delivered. It couldn’t have gone better!
Andrew B. - San Diego, CA
The second time I’ve ordered from gold belly through the pickle guys everything came perfectly wrapped came on time. What could be better?
Sandi S. - Jupiter, FL
The Horseradish pickles are phenomenal!
Frank C. - Coral Gables, FL
All of the pickles we got from The Pickle Guys were absolutely superb! Well, not "were," because we're still enjoying them. We're making them last for as long as we can. Good, good, good!!!
Steven H. - Eastsound, WA
Excellent pickles with simple, quick delivery.
Michael H. - Vero Beach, FL
The pickles are great, they were packaged really well in environmentally friendly packaging.
Carli M. - Flagstaff, AZ
the pickles from the pickle guy were fabulous! I ordered the new pickles
jorge d. - Glendale, CA
The marinated peppers, celery and pepper rings were amazing! Best ever! Fresh, gorgeous produce. Packaged beautifully.
sc b. - Sedona, AZ
Awesome tasting half sours and tomatoes!
Brian D. - Omaha, NE
Pickles are amazing best pickles I’ve had outside of an actual deli. The Pickle Guys take care in their packing and the pickles arrive sealed and on time. I have bought the 4 quarts in the past and found the sour and sour hot are amazing. This time I got the gallon of sour and they are delicious. I will be back!
Bradford A. - Culver City, CA
the best pickles in the world
jorge d. - Glendale, CA
Great product. Fast delivery.
Keith S. - Lake Elsinore, CA
On time,packaged well and love the pickles!!!!!
Allen G. - Liberty, TX
Everything went smoothly. Got my items on time - all good!
Tony F. - Evanston, IL
Delivery, notification, and product was outstanding!
Monica L. - Flower Mound, TX
Delivery was on time. Food was in perfect condition. I was well notified of status every step of the way.
Daniel S. - Pineville, NC
My jars of pickles arrived very well packed and in a timely manner!
Gayle S. - Vineyard Haven, MA
The pickle guys were amazing and sealed well.
Michael B. - Houston, TX
Everything was great, as always pickles were right on time and well packed. These are by far the best pickles available outside of a true deli. Very satisfied with another purchase.
Brad a. - Culver City, CA
The pickles are really good!
Joy L. - Hillsboro, OR
Everything tastes very fresh & gets delivered exactly on time & the ordering is super easy
Christine P. - Glendale, AZ
Delicious pickles!
Karen T. - Carmichael, CA