Meatball Sauce Variety Pack

All 3 flavors of our sauce – perfect for your family dinners!

Classic Tomato

Since The Meatball Shop opened in the Lower East Side in 2010, our Classic Tomato Sauce has been our best seller. We keep it simple with a high-quality, eight-ingredient recipe. Just California whole peeled tomatoes, fresh onions, olive oil, salt, garlic, bay leaves, oregano, and chili flakes. Fresh and classic. Now when you can’t get to The Meatball Shop, you can bring a little bit of the Shop into your home— it’s the exact same recipe we serve in our Shops.

Creamy Tomato Basil

We keep it simple with high quality ingredients. This rich and creamy tomato sauce with California whole peeled tomatoes, fresh basil, herbs and Parmesan cheese makes the perfect partner to fresh pasta and some crusty bread. Fresh and classic.

Spicy-ish Arrabbiata

Our Classic Tomato Sauce with a kick. Whole California peeled tomatoes, fresh onions, garlic and herbs, made spicy-ish with dried red pepper flakes sauteed in olive oil. Classic kicked up a notch.

More Details

Each package includes 3 Jars of Tomato Sauce

  • Each jar includes 24 oz. of sauce

Flavors include:

  • Classic Tomato
  • Spicy-ish Arrabbiata
  • Creamy Tomato Basil


Classic Tomato Sauce – California whole peeled tomatoes, fresh onions, olive oil, salt, garlic, oregano, bay leaves and red pepper.

Creamy Tomato Basil Sauce – California whole peeled tomatoes, water, tomato paste, onions, organic Grade A cream (milk), pure olive oil, basil, garlic, salt, organic parmesan cheese ((pasteurized organic milk, cultures, salt, enzymes), water, sea salt), oregano, red pepper, bay leaves. Contains milk.

Spicy-ish Arrabbiata – California whole peeled tomatoes, water, tomato paste, onions, pure olive oil, garlic, salt, organic asiago cheese ((pasteurized organic milk, cultures, salt, enzymes), water, sea salt, sodium citrate), red pepper, oregano, basil, bay leaves. Contains milk.

Instructions / Storage

  • Shelf Stable
  • Refrigerate after opening

Shipping Details

  • The Meatball Shop ships Tuesday-Friday of each week.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via overnight will incur an additional $20 charge for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New York


Food was excellent.
Rosaline T. - Henderson, NV
Everything, food excellent and packing was excellent. Will definitely order again. 😁👍
Diane C. - Derby, CT
Everything!! Ordering was easy. The food ordered well frozen. Preparation instructions were easy to understand and the food was AMAZING!!
Howard E. - Prattville, AL
The Meatball Shop beef meatballs were so good!
Thomas A. - San Pedro, CA
Those meatballs were the best I've ever had!
Nancy T. - Olympia, WA
Meatball shop! Hands down amazing! I ordered another batch cause everyone was crazy over them.
Andrea A. - Santa Ynez, CA
The whole experience was delightful.
Elena F. - Tulsa, OK
The order came well packaged.
Eric F. - Milton, GA
Love Goldbelly! These meatballs are delicious and Goldbelly’s delivery, tracking and customer service make this form of food delivery and gift giving a no brainer! Order and relax!!
Gary K. - New Canaan, CT
Had never used the site before - all the food was better than expected. Using Goldbelly made it very easy.
Kathryn D. - Brookfield, CT
The meatballs from the meatball shop were excellent.
Joe G. - Foley, AL
Ordering was easy, the delivery was fast, and the meatballs were delicious!
Michael G. - Santa Clara, CA
There is a huge and impressive selection, ordering was easy, delivery date was prompt, delivery was accomplished without a single glitch. Very satisfied.
Nate G. - Stoneham, MA
The process from start to end was perfect!
Mark K. - Tacoma, WA
Meatballs so good
Jane N. - Verona, WI
Fast shipping. Our food was delivered well packaged and still cold.
Gerard E. - Grand Prairie, TX
Fast friendly service.
James B. - Whitinsville, MA