Signature Overloaded Bagel Dozen

The Bagel Nook set out to offer more than just the usual bagel fare. With their range of offerings, we think it’s safe to say “Mission Accomplished.” Bagel Nook’s Overloaded Bagels are their signature creation and unlike anything you’re going to find anywhere else. These are the headline grabbing bagels that were featured in Glamour, Buzzfeed, The Today Show, and basically every American’s Instagram feed. This pack includes one dozen of their overloaded bagels and 3 lbs of cream cheese to create the Overstuffed Oreo Bagel, the Overstuffed Cocoa Puff Bagel and the Overstuffed Fruity Pebble Bagel.

More Details

This package includes:

  • 4 Oreo Bagels + Oreo Cookies + 1 lb of Oreo Cream Cheese
  • 4 Cocoa Puff Bagels + 1 lb of Nutella Cream Cheese
  • 4 Fruity Pebble Bagels + 1 lb of Birthday Cake Cream Cheese

Instructions / Storage

Each box includes everything you need to create the Overstuffed Oreo Bagel. To really overload your Overstuffed Cocoa Puff Bagel, we recommend adding several slices of banana to the cream cheese. To really overload your Fruity Pebble Bagel, we recommend adding several slices of strawberries and/or bananas to the cream cheese.

Shipping Details

  • The Bagel Nook ships Monday-Thursday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New Jersey


Easily the best bagels I've ever eaten, and they were a seasonal "novelty" item (candy cane shaped and dyed bagels). The quality couldn't have been better. I will order from the Bagel Nook again.
Elizabeth H. - Fairfax, VA
Easy to order; shipment on time; product extraordinary.
Suzanne B. - Longview, TX
Everything was great, sent heart shaped bagels and cream cheese to both my girls away at school, they were thrilled, and said they were delicious!
Isabella M. - Danbury, CT
The Mardi Gras bagels were perfect!
Tammy F. - Moreland Hills, OH
The bagels were fresh and the St Patrick’s Day presentation was excellent. The cream cheese was very tasty
Carole M. - Diamond Bar, CA
The items I ordered was exactly what it looked like online. It was also delicious.
Deniece K. - Lancaster, CA
The concept of the four leaf clovers in a green bagel was a huge hit.
Melanie K. - Moodus, CT
We thought it would be fun to order the st patty bagels as giveaways for our LIVE fb shows we do. Perfect timing as it came right before everything went crazy with the virus. It was a perfect treat, great distraction and enjoyed by many who forgot about their stress momentarily thru yummy food! Order on my end couldn't have been easier - I tell everyone about Goldbelly!
janelle e. - Tacoma, WA
The bagels were a bday gift for my family in Iindiwna who moved from Jersey and miss their bagels. These were really loved for their uniqueness and the cream cheese combos are amazing. Very impressive gift
Richard& B. - Crown Point, IN
Delivery service was on time. Bagels were delicious and arrived fresh and well packed.
Hannah F. - Fairfield, CT
Great customer service-product well packaged and delicious
Nolan P. - Miami, FL
My daughter loved the heart shaped bagels she received for Valentine’s Day!
Nicole C. - Newark, DE
Providing opportunity for regional specialties that almost anyone can enjoy! Easy ordering, communication on shipment, transport, and delivery. I have ordered from Goldbelly for the past 3 Valentine's Days in a row. Always a great experience!
Suzanne B. - Longview, TX
Delivered on time....perfect bagels....taste was outstanding!!!
Linda T. - Conneautville, PA
Easy, fun and arrived on time! Birthday cake cream cheese was delicious and fun!
Maiya L. - Troy, AL
Everything packaged well and arrived fresh and cold. The cream cheese mixes were off the chart and went very well with the bagels. I had the holiday assortment , I highly recommend it!
Deborah B. - Fleming Island, FL
The bagels arrived individually wrapped, on time, fresh, and delicious! They were such a fun surprise for Christmas morning, my kids loved them. Would definitely order again!
Amanda P. - Decatur, GA
Everything I have sent has been great quality and delivered on time. Recipients were thrilled!
Ebersole F. - Enfield, NH
Everything was fresh and tasted great!
Kelly I. - Rosamond, CA
Delivered on time & the Tie-Dye bagels were delish & hit with everyone!! Thanks
Lisa M. - Ottumwa, IA
Coffees were delicious and arrived quickly!
Karen S. - San Diego, CA
Beautifully packaged. Greatest bagels ever.
Heather H. - Indio, CA
It was easy to look through their wide selection, read the descriptions, and choose what I wanted. The communication was great, and the tracking was easy to follow. I loved that it allowed me to choose my delivery date so that it could be a surprise too! I LOVE Goldbelly!
- ,
Loved being able to buy a little sampler of bagels. It was such a nice option to send as a gift.
Natalie H. - Morristown, NJ
Packaged well and arrived as promised. Tasted delicious of course!
Robert M. - Minneapolis, MN
Perfect delivery and delicious!
Gloria K. - Bronx, NY
Delicious! Recipients loved their gifts!
Diana W. - Denver, CO
The bagels were fresh and very tasty.
Paula E. - Johns Creek, GA
JEN D. - Cardiff by the Sea, CA
Delivery was super quick, packed well and items were exactly as advertised
Thomas H. - Southern Pines, NC
Everything was perfect, from the order process to the delivery of the product. The product was delivered as promised (received the very next day from when it was shipped). The quality of the product was excellent. I would highly recommend this product. It meet all my expectations.
Dennis K. - Rancho Santa Margarita, CA
Bagels were fresh! Cream cheese cold! Perfect.
Keith S. - Chicago, IL