Valentine's Day "Be Mine" Cookie Pie

This adorable cookie pie adorned with “Be Mine” lettering is perfect for that sweet someone in your life!

As James Beard Award-winning Chicago chef Stephanie Izard’s newest concept, Sugargoat is your new go-to bakery and special occasion sweets shop, and is a place where Izard’s team carries out Goatland’s tradition of showcasing their love of fun flavor combinations. Enjoy your fondest food memories turned into tasty dessert experiences and continue to make more memories enjoying sweets with friends and family!

Cookie designs and colors may vary

More Details

This package serves 8-10 people and includes 1 Cookie Pie

  • Each cookie pie measures 9″ × 1.5″ and weighs approximately 1 lb. 11 oz.


Butter, Sugar, Brown Sugar, Eggs, Egg Yolks, Vanilla Extract, Ap Flour, Salt, Baking Soda, Milk Chocolate, Dark Chocolate, Food Coloring.

Instructions / Storage

  • This package ships fresh with ice packs, may thaw in transit
  • Upon arrival, remove cookie pie from packaging and place on the counter
  • Cookie pie can be kept at room temperature for up to 3 days
  • Do not refrigerate or freeze cookie pie
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Sugargoat ships Tuesday through Friday each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Illinois


Everything! A great experience! The communication, the on-time delivery (on a holiday weekend) , and, of course, the product. Keep up the great work!
Mary F. - Bull Valley, IL
Food was delivered perfectly intact and delicious. Packing was great. Delivery was Right on time
Rachel P. - Long Beach, NY
The Pancake Cake was packed very well and arrived still frozen. The cake itself was so excellent! Even without the frosting, the sourdough pancakes were some of the best pancakes we’ve ever eaten. The maple caramel sauce elevated the dessert even more. It’s very rich and should be enjoyed in small slices. We highly recommend this to anyone who is looking for a dessert that’s a little different from the norm.
Richard S. - Katy, TX
The Cheez-it cake from Sugargoat is hands down one of the best cakes I have ever tasted. Everything was delicious and so balanced! I can’t wait to try the other cakes she offers
Gina L. - Brentwood, CA
Great Timing, shipping was incredibly on time! Package well wrapped and cold.
Virginia B. - Belle Mead, NJ
Everything went well from the ordering to delivery. And the pie was beyond amazing!
Dani W. - Denver, CO
The cake was AMAZING! Was packaged well and we received delivery on time.
Julie T. - Elgin, IL
Everything went well! Delivery, communication, the actual product. All in all, a great experience!
Mary F. - Bull Valley, IL
It was shipped well and tasted amazing. It was a super easy and pleasurable experience.
Courtney B. - St Louis Park, MN
Everything! Easy site navigation, plenty of great choices, customer reviews, quick and efficient shipping
Amanda L. - Brooklyn, NY
We loved the Tie-Dye Surprise from Stephanie Izard. Two of my children want it for their birthdays, so we will be back!
Marjorie M. - Vernon Hills, IL
The cake from Sugarcoat was well packaged and delicious. Smaller than expected, but very high quality.
kerilyn d. - Hanover, PA
The Fireworks Cake by Sugargoat was delicious, and it arrived on time.
Natalie P. - Hamden, CT
Everything was perfect! The cake was out of this world!
Joella J. - Woodbury, NY
All went perfect as usual I am a big fan of Stephanie‘s go to her restaurant every time I’m in Chicago
Caron W. - Ocean View, DE
The cake arrived in perfect condition and on time as promised. Every expectation was met, if not exceeded. Thank you!
Judy R. - North Mankato, MN
Well packages, great shape and tasted great.
James D. - Moorpark, CA
The ordering process through the delivery was smooth and on time. The cake was lovely and delicious.
Alice B. - Santa Paula, CA
The selection and the quality was very high.
Helen B. - Howell, NJ