St. Elmo Steak House ships its legendary shrimp cocktail nationwide on Goldbelly! St. Elmo Steak House has earned the title of not only the oldest steakhouse in Indiana but also one of the best in the world. St. Elmo’s world famous shrimp cocktail is made with 100% natural, sustainable, giant Black Tiger Shrimp, and served with house-made cocktail sauce, nothing is like this! The spicy, fiery sauce has brought tears to the eyes of even the heartiest of eaters, yet a meal at St. Elmo’s just isn’t complete without taking part in the ritual.

One of the oldest and best steakhouses in Indiana, St. Elmo Steak House is not only known for its steaks but also its legendary shrimp cocktail made with giant, sustainable Black Tiger Shrimp and served with house-made fiery cocktail sauce. Founded in 1902 by Joe Stahr, the Indianapolis steakhouse was named after the patron saint of sailors. What started as a humble tavern has grown to a beloved steakhouse that has been named an “American Classic” by the James Beard Foundation and “One of the Most Iconic Food Destinations in the U.S.” by Smithsonian Magazine.

More Details

This package serves 4 people and includes:

  • 16 Black Tiger Shrimp
  • St Elmo’s Famous Cocktail Sauce (12 oz.)


Horseradish, Sugar, Tomato Paste, Distilled Vinegar, Water, Salt, Corn Starch, Natural Flavor, Xanthan Gum, Onion Powder

Instructions / Storage

  • This package ships with ice packs, ice packs may thaw in transit
  • Shrimp ships uncooked and frozen, may thaw in transit
  • Upon arrival, refrigerate shrimp
  • Shrimp may be stored in the freezer, unless thawed upon arrival
  • Refrigerate cocktail sauce, do not freeze.
  • To Serve: instructions are included in box
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • St. Elmo Steak House ships Tuesday – Thursday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Indiana


I like that I can order things from iconic restaurants. We love St. Elmo's Steak House.
Casey S. - Tilden, TX
Loved having St. Elmos Shrimp Cocktail in Colorado!!!!
Tami M. - Kremmling, CO
It was just like If we were at the restaurant in Indy
Marti O. - Lake Worth, FL
I have been to St Elmo‘s steakhouse a number of times and always enjoyed the shrimp cocktail with that amazing hot nose rush cocktail sauce. The sauces I got from you brought me back to those times I was able to eat at St Elmo’s.
Tim S. - Burbank, CA
Delivered on time and was still frozen when it arrived! Everything was exactly as advertised!
Beth P. - Rockwall, TX
The ease of ordering and what we got was exactly what we ordered. I’ve eaten at this restaurant multiple times and the quality and taste was EXACTLY the same as being there.
Gabriel C. - La Canada Flintridge, CA
The shrimp from St. Elmo’s were absolutely the best shrimp I have ever had. My brother lives in Pittsburgh - had them when he ate at your restaurant once. He highly recommended them. We were having special friends to dinner so I ordered them. We live in Montana - do not have a fresh seafood store. It was an incredible treat! Likewise, the pies from the Grand Traverse Pie Co were excellent! We could not believe how they arrived looking like they were fresh out of the oven!
Pamela K. - Great Falls, MT
Outstanding steak and shrimp cocktail. Sauce was just like I remember.
Brad D. - Paducah, KY
So easy! Great delivery. Even better food
Roslyn L. - Chicago, IL
So darn good!
Charles K. - Naples, FL
It was wonderful. My shrimp arrived in the afternoon, I had it for dinner that night and the shrimp was really good!
Laura P. - Surprise, AZ
received yummy items quickly and well packed!
Blair G. - Los Angeles, CA
Goldbelly went above and beyond to make sure my gift deliveries happened - customer for life!
Bill J. - Philpot, KY
They loved the shrimp cocktail!
Barbara M. - Cape Coral, FL
On time and great food!!
Greg S. - Orlando, FL
Everything from the order to delivery on time
William L. - Sheldon, SC
Everything. It was a gift to someone. They loved it. My other experiences with Goldbelly have all been wonderful.
Tom T. - Union Dale, PA
The food arrived pretty quickly after ordering!
Brian H. - Tampa, FL
On time as expected
Jill R. - Bloomington, IN
On time. Great food.
Robert T. - Bloomington, IN
Had no problems at all- Easy to use and gift was delivered exactly on time. I got regular updates . I will definitely use this again.
Jack D. - Leawood, KS
Great shopping experience and fast delivery. Very pleased and I will definitely order again.
Sue C. - Maynard, MA
Everything arrived on time!
Kathy-Sue V. - Battle Creek, MI
Well packed, delivered on time. Cooking instructions included.
Christopher R. - Boyce, LA
Delivery was on time. Good as expected. Perfect!!
Wayne B. - Louisville, KY
Delivery was right on time. The shrimp were big and fresh. The instructions were clear and useful.
The C. - Villa Rica, GA
Everything! the recipients were thrilled...everything arrived in perfect condition; they said the instructions for preparation were so precise that the shrimp turned out perfectly. Cookies were also a big hit!
Stephen N. - Tucson, AZ
Delivery and item was excellent.
Jon C. - Downers Grove, IL
Delivery was right on time. Order was delicious.
Ryan W. - Burlington, CT
Everything. Easy to order. Sent on time. Arrived in great condition.
James R. - Anaheim, CA
Ordering was easy. The items arrived on time and in perfect condition.
Constance D. - Bessemer City, NC
Sarah M. - Redlands, CA
St. Elmo’s arrived on time and in great shape!
Deneen S. - Cypress, TX
It was a gift .... got exactly what I wanted from St. Elmo's in Indy. Thanks.
James M. - Moneta, VA
Food was great! Preparation was easy.
David G. - Walnut, CA
Quick, efficient, easy to navigate. I know the quality of the product is quite yummy
Kathy G. - Muncie, IN
The food from St. Elmo's was AMAZING!
Katie G. - Brookfield, WI
Steaks and shrimp were outstanding!!!!
- ,
The instructions for cooking the raw shrimps were followed precisely and the end result was the best shrimp cocktail we ever had. Absolutely FABULOUS. Hard to believe it was so succulent and delicious.
Justin S. - Kingston, NY
Easy to order. Food always delivered on time and fresh!
Rosemary E. - Rsm, CA
It was delivered on time and was exactly what I wanted!
Mr N. - Somerset, KY
Very easy ordering process. Delivery was on time and quality was very good!
Philip H. - Alliance, NE
delivered on time and food was great
David B. - Wheaton, IL