Choose Your Own Rice Pudding - Epic Size - ($15 for each additional Epic)

+ Free Shipping
This product is currently sold out.

This isn’t your grandma’s rice pudding. The amazing rice pudding made by the quirky folks at Rice to Riches in NYC, uses premium ingredients (like firm short-grained rice), a dash of flair, and plenty of seemingly endless creativity. With twenty-one different handcrafted flavors to choose from, you’re going to have a nearly impossible time narrowing it down to just one. Each Epic contains 14 oz, of Rice to Riches’ world-famous, uniquely flavored rice pudding in a colorful, plastic reuseable container.

More Details

This package includes your choice of up to 7 Epic Sized Rice Puddings (each 14 oz.)

  • Choose to add on the homemade toppings of your choice (each X oz.)
  • Rice Pudding arrives in a reusable, dishwasher and microwave safe container
  • Each 14 oz. container serves 2 people

Descriptions of Flavors

  • Almond Shmalmond – Subtle, nutty flavor from real almonds
  • Be My Banana Coconut – A tropical blend of smooth coconut flavoured rice pudding with the creamy taste of banana
  • Butterscotch Boulevard – Butterscotch is made by gently cooking brown sugar with a touch of butter. This rice pudding tastes similar to the popular butterscotch on ice cream sundaes, but without the stickiness
  • Category 5 Caramel – Made with dulce de leche, this flavor tastes like the traditional brown, gooey caramel candy made of boiled sugar, milk, and butter
  • Chocolate Chip Flirt – Our classic rice pudding with chocolate chips and chocolate shavings
  • Coast to Coast Cheesecake – Made with real cheesecake so it tastes like real cheesecake
  • Coconut Coma – Smooth coconut-flavored rice pudding made with real coconut. Does not contain coconut flakes
  • Fluent in French Toast – Made with real maple, cinnamon, and brown sugar, just like the delicious breakfast treat
  • Hazelnut Chocolate Bear Hug – The flavor is similar to Nutella, made with genuine cocoa, hazelnut, and chocolate
  • I Gotta The Panna Cotta – Similar to the flavor of crème brûlée or flan
  • Man-made Mascarpone – Mascarpone is a sweet, rich Italian cream cheese. We add dried cherries
  • Old Fashioned Romance – Pure and simple, this is the traditional flavor- or unflavoured- rice pudding
  • Oreo"Gasm" – Made with real crushed Oreo cookie
  • Play it Again Butter Pecan – Like the ice cream, smooth buttery flavor with a hint of vanilla and crunchy pecans
  • Sex Drugs and Rocky Road – Rich and full-bodied dark chocolate rice pudding with mini marshmallows and crunchy toasted almond pieces
  • The Edge of Rum Raisin – Made with genuine rum flavor (no liquor), dark and golden raisins
  • Understanding Vanilla – Made with genuine vanilla, one of the most loved and simple dessert flavors in the world

Topping Add-On Options Include

  • Flourish – Toasted Buttery Pound Cake
  • Black Magic – Chocolate Brownie Crumble
  • Spirit- Oatmeal Coconut Crumble
  • Mischief – Buttery Graham Crumble
  • Unity – Cinnamon Raisin Crumble
  • Nudge- Espresso Crumble
  • Blessings – Toasted Coconut
  • Logic – Seasoned Mixed Nuts


milk, rice, sugar, eggs, and cream; plus whatever ingredients each flavor calls for

Instructions / Storage

  • Rice Pudding ships with frozen gel packs and arrived ready to enjoy. Gel packs may thaw in transit.
  • Enjoy immediately or place in the fridge covered to enjoy later
  • May be kept refrigerated for up to 5-7 days
  • Freezing is not recommended
  • To serve warm, microwave at 15-20 second intervals until rice pudding is warm enough for your taste. DO NOT overheat as rice pudding is already fully cooked

Shipping Details

  • Items are prepared fresh and shipped directly from the shop
  • Prices include overnight shipping, taxes, packaging, and handling. WOOHOO!
  • Orders ship Monday-Friday. Order by 12:00 PM EST for next day delivery. Orders placed after 12:00 PM EST on Friday will ship out the following Monday.
  • Orders shipped Friday for Saturday will incur an additional charge of $25
  • No deliveries on Sunday or Mondays
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.
Earn 10 points for every dollar you spend on Goldbelly.
Learn More

Recommended for you

More from New York