Thumbprint Cookies - 9 Pack

+ Free Shipping

Prantl’s Bakery has been churning out the goods using traditional German methods, but it’s their slightly more singed creation that has locals obsessed. Their Thumbprint cookies are Round Cookie Sprinkles on the side Topped with a Buttercream.

More Details

Each package includes 9 Thumbprint cookies

  • Each cookie is 2"


Sugar, Butter, Eggs, Flour (Wheat), Salt, Milk, Water

Contains: eggs milk nuts soybeans, wheat

Instructions / Storage

  • Keep at room temperature for 1 week
  • Can be refrigerated for up to 3 weeks
  • Keep frozen for up to 6 weeks
  • Best Served at room temperature

Detailed storage instructions are included in the box.

Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • This product ships free via 2-day shipping to most states.
  • Prantl’s Bakery ships Monday- Friday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Pennsylvania


This cake is my friend's FAVORITE cake. She is from Pittsburgh, now living on our little island in South Carolina. She was so surprised and happy to receive this cake.
Vicki N. - Daufuskie Island, SC
It's the most delicious ever!
Fran G. - Winston Salem, NC
The cake/torte arrived in perfect condition and it was absolutely delicious!
Kimblyn B. - Manteca, CA
The cake/torte we get is as close as it comes to the cake we get when I was growing up. It's a special occasion when this cake is ordered.
Rachel S. - Central Point, OR
Perfect condition & yummy!
Marjorie M. - Atherton, CA
The Burnt Almond Torte was incredible and delivery was perfect.
James F. - Stevens, PA
What a great service! My favorite cake was delivered to my brother in L.A. so easily!
John V. - West Hollywood, CA
The whole package; delivery, deliciousness and pure satisfaction on my daughter in laws face when she received it. Beyond happy!
Jennifer P. - Mebane, NC
Wonderful frosting and nuts on the Burnt Almond Torte
sydney z. - Santa Cruz, CA
Arrived in timely fashion and well-packed so the torte was in good shape and everything I'd hoped for.
Mark K. - Forest Park, IL
Torte was fresh and delivered on time!
Ginger Y. - Oak Park, IL
Fast delivery. Cake was like fresh and made such a great impression.
Heather Z. - Chicago, IL
I love Prantl’s bakery and their burnt almond torte!
Debra F. - Grand Rapids, MI
It showed up in perfect shape, still partially frozen, on the date promised. And it's so delicious. Brings back memories of 'home'.
MARY L. - Rio Rancho, NM
I loved the cake! It is probably in my top 3 cake experiences ever, and it will move up because I’m in love and will need to order more. It was so fluffy and light. The contrast of textures made every bite a perfect bite. I’m having another piece for breakfast tomorrow!
Shanna B. - Katy, TX
The almond torte was made with the lightest cake. It was such a wonderful taste with the almond crunch. The filling is smooth with just a hint of flavor. This was a perfect dessert for a heavy dinner. We had it after the holiday dinner and as a snack. It was really great. The packaging was well done so the cake box had not been damaged.
Dudley T. - Lewisville, TX
Love Prantl's torte -- Lived in Pittsburgh and very familiar with the bakery in Shadyside. Would love if they could ship lady locks pastries via your service.
Amy L. - Hopkinton, MA
The staff at Goldbelly are very helpful, knowledgeable and efficient. The cakes are always packaged very well and arrive in perfect shape. The Burnt Almond Torte is beautiful to the eye and very very tasty! Very fresh! The serving instructions are very helpful as well. The accolades pouring out from the cake imbibers are amazing. The Burnt Almond Torte always wins Celebrity Status! This particular cake happens to be the favorite of the lady being honored on her 89th Birthday! Thank you!
Elizabeth T. - Ebensburg, PA
The cake/torte arrived in perfect condition and it was absolutely delicious!
Kimblyn B. - Manteca, CA
This is the second time I have ordered the burnt almond cake and both times the cake was excellent. The best one of its kind I have ever ordered. I would not hesitate to order again in the future. Good service too and reasonable price. Thank you.
Lucille C. - San Jose, CA
This really is a wonderful cake. The various components combine for a spectacularly satisfying treat!
Joseph S. - Hampton Bays, NY
It arrived a day ahead of schedule & was absolutely delicious!!! My daughter said it tasted exactly like she remembered!
Mabry B. - Pittsburgh, PA
This cake lives up to the hype. It’s delicious and fresh and delivered in pristine condition. You can preserve leftovers in the freezer, but chances are high that it will all be gone in a blink.
Linda M. - Stryker, OH
Fabulous to ship a Prantls almonds torte to Texas and introduce our friends here to that delicious cake!
Deborah (. - San Antonio, TX
The ability to order my favorite cake in the world from back home.
Richard Jr - Litchfield Park, AZ
02/09/20 delivery
Kelly M. - West Lafayette, OH
The cake arrived in perfect condition and as delicious as I remembered it to be.
Jeanine W. - Santa Rosa, CA
Wonderful taste
Mary S. - Hartsville, SC
Easy to order, item arrived exactly when promised and in pristine condition!
Derek S. - Sea Island, GA
Arrived right in time & in excellent shape! Very well packaged!
Barbara S. - Grafton, WI
Everything - the order process, the expedient delivery, and of course, the product. I sent the Burnt Almond Torte to my sister as a surprise - she opened up the box, grabbed a fork, and dug in - needless to say, she was speechless. I have a feeling she ate the whole torte by herself! THANKS so much for offering such special items. Can't wait to find an occasion to order again!
Anne H. - Strongsville, OH
Easy ordering, prompt delivery, food arrived great and was perfect for our special event! What a great service you offer connecting people with great food from different places!
Katharine H. - Indianapolis, IN
It's been over 20 years since I've had a taste of the Burnt Almond Torte from Prantl's. It was exactly as I remembered it! The entire process, from ordering, to the packaging and precise time of delivery made my 65th Valentine's birthday the best it could have been. It all went well! Thank you.
Kathy C. - Punxsutawney, PA
The cake from Prantl's Bakery was both delicious and packed extremely well.
Shannon L. - Minneapolis, MN
Ordering was easy and delivery as promised. The burnt almond torte arrived in excellent condition although no longer frozen. It was very tasty and enjoyed by everyone. Moist cake and crunchy glazed almond topping.
Ruel C. - Tucson, AZ
Cake was amazing I would have never known about the bakery without Goldbelly!
SarAh F. - Wakefield, MA
Everything about this was perfect!! It was delivered on time, it looked exactly as we remembered and it tasted exactly as we remembered. Sheer perfection!
Kelly S. - Sherman Oaks, CA