Fall Collection Ice Cream Sandwiches - 16 Pack

Just because it’s fall and a little chillier doesn’t mean you can’t enjoy ice cream sandwiches! Instead of going for another coffee run to fulfill your next pumpkin spice craving, run to the freezer and grab one of these amazing new fall flavors! Each cookie is filled with hand-scooped ice cream and is assembled, wrapped, and packaged by hand at Nye’s.

Since 2010, chef Christian Nye has been pairing artisan ice cream and handmade cookies to create whimsical, elevated ice cream sandwiches in Wilmington, North Carolina. Nye’s Cream Sandwiches include flavor combinations like Coconut Chocolate (toasted coconut ice cream and chocolate ganache cookies), Strawberry Shortcake (strawberry ice cream and sugar cookies), and Key Lime Pie (Key lime ice cream and chewy graham cookies. Nye’s Cream Sandwiches has been featured on O, The Oprah Magazine’s The O List.

More Details

This package includes 16 Ice Cream Sandwiches (3.5 oz. each)

  • Sandwiches are individually wrapped, labeled and placed in Nye’s Signature box. Perfect for a gift!

Flavors Include

  • 4 Caramel Latte: Caramel Ice Cream & Coffee Cookies
  • 4 Pumpkin Cranberry Spice: Pumpkin Ice Cream and Cranberry Orange Spice Cookies
  • 4 Blackberry Cobbler: Blackberry Ice Cream and Oat Cookies
  • 4 Caramel Apple Pie a la Mode: Caramel Apple Pie Ice Cream & Cinnamon Cookies


Contains: Dairy and Gluten

May contain nuts

Instructions / Storage

Storage & Care:

  • Ice Cream Sandwiches ship frozen with dry ice
  • Do not remove dry ice with bare hands
  • Nye’s Cream Sandwiches can be kept frozen for up to 3 months, but are freshest when enjoyed within 3 weeks.
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Nye’s ships Monday-Thursday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via overnight will incur an additional $35 charge. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from North Carolina


These ice cream sandwiches were so good that I hid them from my family so I could keep them for myself.
Peg K. - Bedford, OH
The strawberry ice cream sandwich was amazing! They were all great but the strawberry- OMG!!
Jessica C. - Bronx, NY
Amazing variety of unique flavors!
Barbara C. - Brighton, UT
The ordering process was easy. I ordered several of the same item to be delivered to multiple addresses and it was a breeze to do. They were shipped the next day. The product, Nye’s Ice Cream sandwiches, was amazing!
kathi g. - Nashville, TN
Delicious assortment of quality ice cream.
Fran J. - Wayne, NJ
The ice cream sandwiches arrived in perfect condition. The family loved the different flavors.
John H. - Naperville, IL
My parents loved the ice cream sandwiches. They had yummy ready-made dessert for a week!
Ronald T. - Suffolk, VA
Ice cream came beautifully wrapped. It stayed totally frozen. And my family loved all of he different flavors. The cookies were delicious too. Overall we were very pleased with the packaging, delivery service and quality of product. Would highly recommend your company to my friends and family.
Susan N. - Spring, TX
The timely order and the great taste - best ice cream sandwich ever
Tracy L. - Lexington, TX
DEELISH Nye's was awesome! Especially loved the lemon and peppermint ones. Happy to try it across the country. So good, I sent to our son who raved!
M.A. G. - San Diego, CA
Everything arrived in perfect condition. I’ll admit I was sceptical about sending ice cream to Southeast Florida in 80 degree weather but it arrived in excellent condition. We were very impressed!
Dorothy B. - Lake Worth, FL
Shipment, quality, taste , & website were all excellent !!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️🌟 The entire experience was 1st class with an A + rating & we will be using your services in the future for sure !!! ;)
Travis M. - Neptune Beach, FL
Everyone absolutely loved the ice cream sandwiches. My cousin Katie said they were so good she was saving Nye’s ice cream on her goldbelly account as a gift idea for the future. Well done!!
- ,
I ordered am ice cream subscription for my father. It was so much fun. The ice cream was delicious and he really enjoyed it. I highly recommend.
Ted H. - Miami, FL
everything was perfect just like the first time i tried these. packaging was great, shipping and delivery were on godspeed, and the sándwiches themselves were delicious!
Ruu M. - San Francisco, CA
Ice cream lovers loved the flavors
Chris S. - Wake Forest, NC
the ice cream sandwich was awesome
Reno R. - Lantana, TX
Everything we've ordered has been delicious, unique, and a way to explore foods from around the country.
Arlene W. - Fond du Lac, WI
Everything went smooth. Order was delivered on the day as requested. My brother in law loved his 12 days of ice cream sandwiches.
Angel T. - Hollywood, FL
The Nye’s Ice Cream Sandwiches were delivered on the date I choose and were in perfect condition. A very fun gift to send someone on their birthday!
Becky L. - Ruskin, FL
Ice cream sandwiches were a gift. The recipient was so thrilled and raved about them!!
jessica b. - Cranford, NJ
Speedy delivery, 2days. Delicious ice cream sandwiches shipped from South Carolina to Pacific Palisades California.
Doreen M. - Pacific Palisades, CA
NYE ice cream came to me ROCK FROZEN on the hottest day of the year GREAT packing and delivery Thanks!
joan J. - Mount Vernon, NY
Nye’s cream sandwiches are fabulous. Packaging outstanding. Sandwiches arrived on time and frozen solid. Delish!!!
M/M E. - San Antonio, TX
We love the quality of foods available from top chefs, it arrives swiftly and has made Covid-19 lockdown less daunting. We have experience new experiences in food because of Goldbelly. AAA+++
Eric R. - Gardnerville, NV
It was great. Ice cream sandwiches arrived on time, well packed and frozen solid. They were delicious!
Paul M. - Raleigh, NC