Signature Pizzas - Choose Your Own 2 Pack

Create your own 2-pack! Nicoletta’s pizzas start with the highest-quality ingredients, and a three-day crust that’s thick and crisp enough to hold up to the ample amount of cheese and toppings. The Classica is topped with flavorful tomato sauce, mozzarella, and parmesan, the mushroom with oven-roasted marinated mushrooms and mozzarella, and the top-selling Calabrese is loaded with thick-cut pepperoni, homemade fennel sausage, red onion, and fresh mozzarella!

Chef Michael White is the man behind Marea, one of New York City’s most acclaimed Italian restaurants, so you know that when he turns his attention to pizza, the end result is bound to be good. When Nicoletta opened in New York’s East Village in 2012, wait times regularly exceeded 90 minutes for a table. Today it’s expanded to New Jersey and Washington, D.C., and now these acclaimed pizzas ship nationwide.

More Details

This package serves 4-6 people and includes your choice of 2 Pizzas (each 14").

  • Choose to add more!

Pizza Options Include:

  • Classica – a fresh combination of aromatic herbs, mozzerella, and parmesan
  • Calabrese – an elevated take on a meat lover’s pizza with Fennel Sausage, Pepperoni, and Red Onion
  • Mushroom – a savory pie with flavorful tomato sauce, mozzarella, parmesan, and oven-roasted mushrooms

Add On Options Include:

  • 12 Morini Meatballs and Pomodoro Sauce (1.5 lbs. Total)
  • 25 Calabrian Chili Hot Wings

Ingredients

Classica – Flour, Yeast, EVOO, Tomatoes, Dried herbs (Oregano and Basil), Garlic and Onion powder, Mozzarella Cheese, Parmesan, Basil.
Calabrese – Flour, Yeast, EVOO, Tomatoes, Dried Herbs (Oregano and Basil), Garlic and Onion Powder, Mozzarella cheese, Parmesan, Basil, Fennel Sausage, Pepperoni, Red Onion
Mushroom – Flour, Yeast, EVOO, Tomatoes, Oregano, Basil, Garlic Powder, Onion Powder, Mozzarella Cheese, Parmesan, Basil, Mushrooms, Garlic
Calabrian Chili Hot Wings – Chicken Wings, Parmigiano Cheese, Honey, Red Wine Vinegar, Franks Red Hot, Herb Oil, Calabrian Chili Peppers

Instructions / Storage

  • This package ships frozen with ice packs
  • Ice packs may thaw in transit
  • Upon arrival, place pizzas immediately in the freezer
  • May be kept frozen for up to 30 days

To Serve

  • 1. Preheat oven to 400 degrees
  • 2. Remove pizzas from vacuum sealed pouch and allow to thaw for 10-12 minutes
  • 3. Line the bottom oven rack with foil or use a pan for drippings.
  • 4. Place pizza directly on oven rack or pre-heated pizza stone for 25-27 minutes
  • 5. Allow pizza to cool for 3-5 minutes before cutting and serving
    Watch closely as oven temperatures may vary.
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Nicoletta Pizza ships Monday-Friday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New York

REVIEWS

Incredible Pizza - great flavors and tastes as delicious as eating it in NYC! Well done, team, and happy to be on Goldbelly.
Jenny Li - Sugar Land, TX
09/02/20
easy to order!
Francis S. - Basking Ridge, NJ
09/02/20
Quick service, fresh and enjoyed sharing the food.
Elizabeth E. - Litchfield Park, AZ
02/22/21
Everything that was delivered was exactly what I expected. Great pizza! Thank you!
John P. - Fremont, CA
02/14/21
The wings flavor was unique
Edward C. - Southampton, PA
02/13/21
Nicoletta Pizza looks and tastes as amazing as it looks on the pics!!! I will definitely be ordering from them again.
Erin L. - North Bergen, NJ
11/23/20
Deliver was very quick, product was kept cold. Thank you very much it was delicious!!! Great experience!
Paige B. - Honolulu, HI
09/22/20
Fast delivery. Wonderful food. You helped make my husband's birthday very special.
Shannon H. - Del Rey Oaks, CA
09/21/20
Amazing pizza!! And in the warmer temperature on Wednesday in Los Angeles, the package came, as promised on ice and ready to go back into the freezer. We baked both pizzas on Thursday and they were outstanding!!! Best pizza in a very long time.
KAREN M. - Los Angeles, CA
04/18/21
It arrived on time and I was well informed of delivery timeline with UPS. It was nicely paced and had good instructions.
Carole B. - Agoura, CA
04/17/21
Ordered some goodies to be delivered to my kids in 2 different states, using a gift card I received for Christmas...transactions went well, gift arrived timely and in good condition.
Brian L. - Mishawaka, IN
03/19/21
It was so easy to search and order what we wanted. So happy to find out about you guys!
Favian H. - Laramie, WY
03/12/21
Fabulous Pizza, superb value, I love Nicoletta Pizza and will buy again! THANK YOU Goldbelly!!!
Craig H. - Senoia, GA
05/07/21
Very well preserved for delivery! Pizza was delicious!
Melodi D. - Antioch, CA
08/02/21
So many good choices and if ordering in advance, free shipping in time for the holiday. All packed really well and festive too.
Thomas K. - Pass Christian, MS
06/20/21
Well packaged, good food, great choices
Justin F. - Baton Rouge, LA
05/24/21
Product in perfect condition, great delivery
Lauren B. - New York, NY
05/04/21
Goldbellys Customer Service and correction of a mistake from the vendor was exceptional
Cameron E. - Austin, TX
05/01/21
Ordered for a future celebration date and everything arrived as expected, without a worry. Still cold and on time.
Scott S. - Sarasota, FL
04/26/21
The pizza was excellent. Crust was perfect. I love this website.
Justine S. - Ord, NE
04/25/21
Everything! The pizza was SO good! Thanks GB!
Laura R. - Charlotte, NC
04/24/21
The pizzas from Nicolletta were amazing and since they were on sale, the price was definitely right.
Victoria L. - Canton, NC
04/24/21
Easy to order and pizzas are awesome!
Susan P. - Shreveport, LA
04/24/21
Arrived on time and was delicious!
Beth C. - Bainbridge Island, WA
04/24/21
Quickly delivery and delicious pizza.
Greg R. - Kansas City, MO
04/20/21
Excellent food, excellent packaging and arrived on time!!!
Ruth S. - Harrison, MI
04/17/21
Nicoletta Pizza gift received amazing reviews.
Beatrice F. - Allston, MA
03/03/21
Originally, my gift shipment was lost. i reached out to let customer support know of the problem and I was contacted immediately, my case was reviewed, and a favorable resolution was negotiated between myself and the support rep. I am not kidding when I say this was the best online customer support I have ever received. Thank you for prioritizing the personal experience of your customers. thank you thank you thank you.
Rebecca R. - Vienna, VA
04/13/21
Delivered right on time in perfect condition
Judy M. - Chattanooga, TN
08/31/21
The pizza arrived on time and was delicious!!!
Lisa P. - Vashon, WA
08/28/21
Very tasty!
WILLIAM C. - Mooresville, NC
08/16/21