Chicago Deep Dish Pizza - 2 Pack - Half & Half Toppings

Arrives after Father's Day

My Pi Pizza ships its famous Chicago Deep Dish Pizza nationwide on Goldbelly! Not your average deep-dish Chicago pizza, each My Pi 12" pizza is much larger than what the competitors typically ship, and they make every pizza to order! My Pi’s deep-dish dough recipe was developed by owner Rich Aronson’s father, a fourth-generation baker whose family came to the US from Bialystok, Belarus, in 1905. Made fresh daily and timed so the third “proofing” of the dough is in the oven, it has a wonderfully fresh yeast taste and a crispness that magically remains tender to the bite. My Pie’s sauce is equally special. it’s got a bright tomato taste and a touch of sweetness.

No knife or fork is needed to indulge in My Pi Pizza’s Chicago-style deep dish pizza. Opened in 1971 by a fourth-generation baker who spent years perfecting the recipe, My Pi Pizza is famous for its triple-proofed crust, tomato sauce made with vine-ripened San Marzano tomatoes, and up to four kinds of Wisconsin cheese. Today, My Pi Pizza is run by Rich Aronson, who carries on his father’s tradition of making some of the best pizza in Chicago.

More Details

  • This package includes 2 Deep Dish Pizzas
  • Each pizza is 12" and serves 3 people
  • Choose 4 of your favorite toppings!

Instructions / Storage

  • Pizzas are fully cooked, frozen and shipped with ice packs which may thaw partially or fully during transit
  • Upon arrival, place it in the freezer. Pizzas can be frozen for up to 90 days

To Serve

Method 1

  • Do Not Preheat Oven
  • Remove Pizza from its packaging
  • Place pizza on metal sheet pan or pizza stone in the middle rack of your oven
  • Turn your oven on to 400F
  • Bake your pizza for 35-45 minutes
  • Please Note: Cook time depends on two important factors: How well your oven heats, and what type of pizza you’re heating (veggie pizzas and multiple-item pizzas will take longer to cook)
  • After 30 minutes baking, check on your pizza every 5 minutes or so until it is done to your liking
  • For slow cooking ovens pizza may take up to 55 minutes

Method 2

  • Preheat oven to 400F
  • Place pizza on metal sheet pan or pizza stone in the middle rack of your oven
  • Bake for 15 minutes
  • Remove pizza from your oven and let stand on counter for 5 minutes
  • Place pizza back in the 400F oven for 20-39 minutes
  • Check on the pizza after 20 minutes of baking, then check on your pizza every 5 minutes or so until it is done to your liking

Quick Fixes

  • If your sauce is too watery, bake the pizza longer
  • If the crust is browning too quickly, move to higher shelf in the oven
  • if crust is not browned enough, move to lover shelf in oven
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • My Pi Pizza ships Monday-Wednesday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Illinois


Tasted great. Was convenient and not nearly as expensive as I thought it was going to be. I am from Chicago and MyPi was our family go to spot. It is fantastic to be able to still order. I also loved that an empty MyPi pizza box was included in the order
Alexis B. - Bloomington, IN
Was shipped to the Florida Keys and it was still frozen! Pizza was yummy!
Dianne U. - Summerland Key, FL
Food arrived on the delivery date, well packed, pizza was incredible.
Stephen B. - Springville, NY
We haven’t had My Pi in so long, and we remembered the taste immediately. It’s expensive but it was definitely worth it
Joanne S. - Bay Shore, NY
Absolutely delicious! I can't wait to place another order 😋
Christina M. - Visalia, CA
We ordered deep dish pizza. It arrived intact, frozen, with detailed instructions. We followed the instructions and the food was as good as if it had been cooked in the restaurant we ordered from, My Pi in Chicago. It was not cheap, but it was worth it because the food was perfect. Will order again.
Matthew B. - Rockville Centre, NY
Fresh and tasted as good as I remembered from back in the 70’s. Packaged great and delivered on time.
Debra B. - Tulsa, OK
It was delicious! It came still frozen and we followed the reheating directions and it came out perfect!
Julie B. - Sarcoxie, MO
They kept me up to date on where my order was and actually delivered in a day earlier. The pizza is phenomenal.
Teresa N. - Verona, WI
Easy to order. Fast delivery....Liked the "free shipping" too Packaged wonderfully!!
Roseann A. - Hicksville, NY
Delivery was exactly as promised. Good communication with the delivery date. The Pizza we ordered was FANTASTIC
Gina G. - San Antonio, TX
Shipping was surprisingly good. Product was in dry ice and arrived frozen solid despite traveling thousands of miles.
Liz K. - Everett, WA
Delivery on time and perfect. My Wife had a My Pi growing up in North Miami Beach, Florida but went out of business. 35 years later tasted exactly the same. Perfect Valentines Day.
Rodger P. - Hollywood, FL
No complaints other than the price. It was an indulgence and a surprise for a family member.
Curtis H. - Roy, WA
Pizza was perfect Just how I remember My Pi when it was in Golden Valley, MN. Even how it was packed as perfect as we were able to use the pizza boards and the foil to send every one home with a couple leftover pieces. Thanks for bringing back a great memory!
Pam N. - Maple Grove, MN
The pizza was very good. Jalapeño and pineapple flavor was the best vegan pizza we’ve ever had and plan to reorder that one, so glad we ordered 2 of that flavor! PLEASE, GOLDBELLY, PLEASE INCLUDE MORE VEGAN ENTRES PLEASE!! :) There are lots of us Vegans out there who would order great food like this pizza!
Marilyn H. - Melbourne Beach, FL
Everything went well! Food is always amazing and packaged perfectly. This is literally the absolute best discovery online I’ve had in years! You guys are killing it!!
David B. - Spokane, WA
Amazing deep dish pizza ! The crust is buttery crisp goodness! The artichokes are multitudinous! Amazing!!!! What a treat!!!!
Pat A. - Nevada City, CA
Everything was delicious. Best pizza I’ve ever had!
John C. - Taylorsville, UT
The one we have eaten reminded me of the ones I used to have with friends after high school dances at Senn in Chicago.
Donna W. - Camas, WA
This was my first time ordering from Goldbelly and I was very satisfied with my order from "My Pi Pizza"! Everything was packaged well and the pizzas were amazing! The portions were huge and the flavor is awesome. My family loved the mushrooms on their "supreme style" deep dish and we would order from here again!
Victor W. - Issaquah, WA
It is a pizza that we’ve been missing since the Minnesota locations closed over 35 years ago. Yum! What a great service.
Jennifer O. - Minneapolis, MN
Getting to have that pizza again for first time in over 20 years was one of the best things to happen to me food wise!
Andrea P. - Scranton, SC
In my opinion, the deep dish pizza from My Pi is by far the best offered. Believe me, I’ve tried them all and am a Chicago native. Packaged well and arrived still frozen two days after shipping to central Florida.
Colleen S. - Sanford, FL
My parents love pizza, but lack options in Alabama. The pizza arrived with great instructions and cooked and tasted great per my parents report. I ordered a 4 pack for them today. Great pizza from My Pi.
Paula M. - Killen, AL
the deep dish is fabulous
william b. - Pittsburgh, PA
This was a gift and the recipients said it was delicious and really appreciated it!
Ben M. - Monument, CO
Food was as always delicious and still frozen when it arrives. Some of the best food, especially pizza I have ever had.
Russ K. - Grants Pass, OR
My Pi pizza is always amazing! The crust is outstanding, the amount of artichokes so generous!! I keep rebuying!!!!
Pat A. - Nevada City, CA
So excited to find my favorite restaurant was still out there and able to ship to me. Had no issues with the ordering and delivery was actually a little earlier than anticipated! You made my day - or several days because I still have a few pizzas left to enjoy!
Melissa W. - Cockeysville, MD
Pizza arrived perfectly. Great cooking instructions, GREAT PIZZA!!!!!
Luci I. - Los Angeles, CA