Gluten-Free Carrot Cheesecake

(Customer Reviews)

Our decadent gluten-free carrot cake made with fresh carrots and hints of warm spices layered with our creamy vanilla cheese cake.

Since 1947, Montilio’s Baking Company has been baking up some of the Boston area’s most beloved cakes. This third-generation family-owned-and-operated bakery and cake shop has four locations near Boston. At each location, Montilio’s Baking Company still makes their French and Italian pastries and wedding cakes the old-fashioned way, by hand, using only simple ingredients. Many of these recipes haven’t changed in more than 70 years, and you can taste the decades of tradition in every bite.

More Details

This package serves 10-12 people and includes 1 Gluten-Free Carrot Cheesecake

  • This Cake measures 8" in diameter

Please note cake decorations may vary


Sugar, Rice Flour, Corn Starch, Egg Whites, Soy Flour, Salt, Citric Acid, Xanthum Gum, Carrots, Oil, Pumpkin, Eggs, Raisins, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Salt

Vanilla Cheesecake – Cream Cheese, Heavy Cream, Sugar, Eggs, Whole Milk, Vanilla Extract, Salt

Made in a Facility that processes Gluten

Instructions / Storage

  • This cake ships frozen with dry ice, dry ice may dissipate in transit
  • Delicately remove the cake from packaging and carefully remove the plastic wrap and cardboard border surrounding the cheesecake.
  • If serving immediately, place it on your counter to thaw out, otherwise store it in your fridge
  • This cheesecake will last at room temperature for 6 hours
  • This cheesecake will last up to 7 days in the fridge
  • This cheesecake will last up to 1 year in the freezer
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Montilio’s Baking Company ships Monday-Friday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Massachusetts


I ordered this for my daughter's 25th birthday because she is in the Air Force and stationed in Alaska. She said the cake looked beautiful and was absolutely delicious.
Debbi E. - North Pole, AK
Delivery time was excellent. Packaging was excellent. Box stayed out on porch for over 3 hours and was still frozen hard! Amazing.
Maxine P. - Columbia, MD
Packaging to protect the cake was great and the cake was awesome. Fire all the way!
Eric C. - Phoenix, AZ
Shipping was great and cake came perfect:) Used it for our wedding! Thank You!!
Elizabeth S. - Columbus Grove, OH
Beautiful cake, arrived as pictured. A couple of the rosette icing got a bit pressed, still pretty. The cake is beautiful and delicious! It’s a wonderful opportunity to experience a bit of history. Thank you!
Teri G. - Orange, CA
Excellent service. Food arrived quickly, beautiful, delicious & exactly how described.
Sarah C. - Seymour, CT
cake arrived still frozen after the dry ice had dissipated, all the way to Florida! My husband loved the cake!!
Karla C. - High Springs, FL
The JFK wedding cake was absolutely fantastic! It was beautiful, delicious and impressive! We used it to celebrate my dad's 86th birthday and it was perfect in every way!
Vickie T. - Cedar Falls, IA
Everything went according to me planning my delivery and the was the best rum cake my husband has had since moving to Tennessee in 28 years. 😉
Nancy I. - Spring Hill, TN
The cake was delivered in perfect condition and on time for my parents’ anniversary. They were thrilled with the cake, so I am very pleased with my overall experience.
Linda P. - Hackensack, MN
Shipping was on time but the cake was definitely great my brother in law is a chef and he said this is what other cakes aspire to be! Couldn't have been better thank you!
Janine D. - Ozark, MO
The Montilio's Bakery Company rum/custard birthday cake was a big hit for my best friend in the Chicago suburbs! She lived it, saying, “It was to die for!” I am in Japan, but wanted this to be an extra special birthday for her. It certainly achieved that! Thank you so much!
Kathleen H. - Vernon Hills, IL
I ordered this cake for my father's 91st birthday and he loved it. The cake was perfect. It was delivered on the day that was promised. I would definitely be doing this again. Thank you so much, it made my dad very happy and surprised!
Anthony B. - Ridgefield, CT
The cake arrived safely in durable packaging with dry ice. Many said I’d was the best cake they ever eaten. Bravo!
Antoinette M. - Sewell, NJ
The whole experience was positive. Ordering was easy, delivery was on time, the cake was delicious! Will definitely order through Goldbelly again. Thank you for helping make my moms 90th Birthday even better!
Millicent R. - North Dartmouth, MA
This cake arrived like it was straight from the local bakery. My family was very happy with my decision to order this cake and my 13-year old son asked how long until I could order another one.
KRISTIN R. - Harrison Twp, MI
The cake showed up right on my wife's birthday, in the morning, in great condition. Thanks! The delivery person put the cake on its side, despite the numerous labels. Thankfully it was packed securely enough that this did not adversely affect the cake. It was nice to have the information sheet explaining the cake's history.
Cara B. - Burbank, CA
Surprised the cake was on time. I live in the mountains of WV and expected a delay in service. The cake was slightly melted which would be no fault in delivery everything was still cold it was 90 degrees out. I wanted my daughter to be surprised as a going away gift after a small wedding. Perfect and Presidential!
Annette D. - Robson, WV
The cake was on time and in perfect condition due to dry ice and packing. The cake was true to description as advertised and absolutely one of the most delicious cakes ever. It was very impressive to my guests and a cake I will order over and over again. The cake was the JFK cake from Montilio’s Baking Co.
Karen B. - Clarksville, TN
I sent a cake to my sister for her Birthday and boy was she crazy about it and remarked how well it was packaged for shipment. I will definitely order again and soon!
Susan D. - Norwalk, CT
Easy ordering, shipped and received as promised in perfect condition. Cake was delish!
cynthia s. - Biloxi, MS
The cake arrived when you said it would and the packaging was amazing. We served the cake for our 25th wedding anniversary and everyone loved it.
Beth S. - Gallipolis, OH
Lovely cake and it came exactly when expected. Easy to order. Great web site. This cake is for my Mom’s 90th birthday. She grew up in Quincy, MA and the Italian rum cake from Montilio’s has always been her favorite. Great it can be ordered and sent to Florida.
Joyce R. - Lakeland, FL
Cake was beautiful and tasted fantastic and fresh
Debra L. - Lagrange, KY
I was very impressed with the packing and timely delivery. The JFK cake was in perfect condition, fresh, and delicious. I will definitely be ordering from GoldBelly again. Thank you.
Gordon L. - Mechanic Falls, ME
I'm honored to have eaten this cake ......Was the best cake ever ..cant wait to get another one
kelly o. - Bloomington, IL
The JFK wedding cake from Montilio’s bakery was the best cake we have ever tasted! In addition, it was so well-packed that it could have easily survived any shipping problems. Truly exquisite, inside and outside.
Margaret V. - Augusta, ME
It was easy to place the order and it arrived at the perfect time. The cake was beautiful and tasted great. I would highly recommend it!
Donna K. - Mount Pleasant, SC
The cake was delightful! Best cake I’ve ever had.
Stacy R. - Peculiar, MO
When I was a child this was my birthday cake. As an adult I’ve never been able to have it as there are no authentic Italian bakeries in my local area or state for that matter. It was a complete taste of joy after 30+ years
Patricia M. - Orlando, FL
The JFK wedding cake was delicious!! Couldn't have been better!! Loved it!!
Vanessa D. - Douglasville, GA
The cake was delicious & arrived even with snow delays! Which was great as it was for a birthday gathering! Communication was excellent! Could not have asked for a better experience!
Rachel S. - Brooklyn, NY
Timely delivery, great options, and the recipient of the cake that we ordered LOVED it!!
Leota T. - Sterling, CO
The item was delivered on time. I liked that we can track the delivery of the item at any time. The item arrived in great condition, it was very well packed and the cake itself was superb! Everyone enjoyed it!
Bettina S. - West Covina, CA
montillio bakery did not disappoint!...the jfk wedding cake!...oh lala!
Rick D. - Bradenton, FL
The cake was delicious as remembered. Love Montilio’s and so happy to find it available to ship nationwide.
Mike A. - Estero, FL
The cakes were amazing!!! Tasted melt in your mouth good! The delivery was right on time..
emilia b. - Beaverton, OR
The cake was delicious and was perfect for a special birthday treat. It was sent from NYC to LA and was packed perfectly. The delivery company tossed it onto the porch on its side but it was packed so well that when it was opened everything was beautiful and intact!
BETH G. - Sherman Oaks, CA
The cake was delicious! Arrived on perfect condition so it looked as beautiful as it tasted.
Kara S. - Orange, CT
You delighted my family with your JFK wedding cake! It was the grandest cake I've experienced for a formal birthday 🍰. This cake reminded me that indeed "Camelot still reigns in our hearts". Because of your creation you now have a customer for life!
Mollie C. - Lockport, NY
This Kennedy wedding/birthday cake was the MOST delicious cake that I personally haven't baked. I will be ordering these for Special gifts. This was a true DELIGHT for my 65th birthday. It arrived Perfectly. The cake photographs beautifully.
Ann I. - Dallas, TX
The cake arrived in a very timely manner. It was perfect. Three days later it is still fresh and moist!
Sandy T. - Myerstown, PA
The cake arrived in perfect condition and on time! Montilio’s is my favorite bakery in the Boston area. And a Montilio’s birthday cake was our choice for everyone’s birthday growing up. Now that I live in another state, I don’t get one! So finding Goldbelly and the Montilio’s cake on the site was terrific? Thanks so much for your excellent service! And the Presidential Inaugural Ball cake was wonderful! I highly recommend it.
Kathleen O. - Bath, ME
GREAT!! The muffins are just as I remember when I was a child! Shipped on time, packaged correctly, perfect instructions, a wonderful experience. Will certainly purchase from this merchant, and this service again. Many thanks!
ONeill F. - Cotuit, MA
Received within a day of each other the new bride and groom were extremely happy...have been eating from their gift since they received it. Will definitely do this for future gifts. Thank you!!
Mr.&Mrs. D. - Bluffton, SC
Montilio’s JFK cake was absolutely delicious and delivery was swift and problem-free! The white cake was very light and moist. The white frosting was modest and also very tasty. The bottom layer of the cake has raspberry preserves and this is what makes this cake so delicious. The whole cake is sweet but not overly so. And the frosting is not overdone. I highly recommend it!
Now, I was most surprised by the fact that I could order the cake Wednesday and see it delivered to my house Friday before 10am! It was packed inside a styrofoam cooler with ice packs, and the cake itself was wrapped in cardboard and shrink-wrapped. Perfect! The result was a perfect cake that you would never guess was shipped from the bakery.
Overall, a 5* cake and experience! Highly recommend!
Monica S - Leesburg, VS
The whole experience with Goldbelly was amazing! From ordering, to quick shipping, to the arrival of my item packaged with dry ice, and finally to the absolutely delicious cake I received! I followed the included unthawing instructions and it tasted just like I ate it at the bakery the same day! It was a huge hit among family and friends and some said it was the best cake they ever tasted. I'm so thankful Goldbelly was created so that we may enjoy food from great places everywhere!
Julie K. - Morgantown, WV
Everything! Delicious cake!! Will order this cake for all of my special occasions!!!
Frank C. - Aliquippa, PA
We ordered a Rum cake and it tasted fantastic. I think this will be the Bakery I buy from now on!
marcia k. - Toledo, OH
This particular cake had loads of positive reviews, and they were accurate (now that we have eaten it). The cake was available for immediate delivery (which I was looking for) and it arrived on the day it was expected before 10am!! Really awesome service and product. The cake was still nearly frozen and it thawed nicely for that evening. Bravo!
Monica S. - Leesburg, VA
Cake was delivered on time in perfect condition and it was delicious!!
Kay L. - Huntsville, AL
Delivered on time. One cake was perfect - Montillios- other had slight damage but easily fixed. I will deinitely order again!
Norah G. - Plymouth, MA
Everything from shipping to delivery and the food was excellent! Very good experience!
Mara M. - Gig Harbor, WA
The cake was exactly as it looked on the pictures, and arrived exactly when originally estimated!
Cindy S. - Grafton, WI
Everything was perfect… The cake was absolutely delicious and the delivery was exactly on time. Highly recommended!
Judith M. - Hamilton, NJ
Ordering was easy and introduced me to other outlets for awesome food and the cake I ordered was beyond awesome!
jane d. - Saline, MI
Ordered Montilio's Italian Rum Cream Cake for my husband for Father's day. He loved it. I was worried about how well the cake would hope up on a 100 degree day. It arrived and the ice packets were still cold. The cake was perfect :D
Gina C. - Belleville, IL
Quick easy to find quality gluten free food!
tamara b. - Covina, CA
The cake I ordered was delivered in perfect condition, packed in dry ice. It’s the second time I’ve ordered the Italian rum cake and it is absolutely delicious, similar to the one my family ordered for birthdays and special occasions when we lived in Manhattan during my childhood until we relocated to another state.
Karen B. - Jacksonville, FL
The tracking information. The damn cake is delicious, and loved the History letter about JFK!
Joanne D. - Dayton, OH