Pumpkin Whoopie Pies

(Customer Reviews)

McClure’s Bakery ships its famous Whoopie Pies nationwide on Goldbelly! Whoopie pies originated in Lancaster County and are one of Pennsylvania Dutch Country’s best known and most loved comfort foods for locals and visitors alike. Whoopie pies were created by Lancaster’s Amish and Pennsylvania German communities and have been handed down for years in home kitchens and small bakeries, from generation to generation. It’s believed that whoopie pies were first made from leftover cake batter, and Amish legend has it that, when children and even farmers would find the delicious treat in their lunch pail, they’d yell out “Whoopie!,” hence the name. Whoopie pies are actually more like a sandwich, made of two cake-like cookies with a cream center.

Nestled in the heart of Amish Country in Gap, Pennsylvania, McClure’s Bakery has been turning out flawless renditions of Amish classics like Shoofly Pie and other goodies since 1974. This Amish bakery produces what many believe is the country’s best Shoofly Pie, based on an old family recipe. Their whoopie pies are amazing too.

More Details

This package serves 12 people and includes 12 Pumpkin Whoopie Pies

  • Each Whoopie Pie measures approx. 3.5″ × 2″


Sugar, Bleached Wheat Flour, Partially Hydrogenated Soybean Oil (Contains: Propylene Glycol, Mono & Diesters Of Fats Fatty Acids, Mono & Diglycerides, Soy Lecithin, Bht Added To Protect Flavor), Modified Food Starch, Eggs, Vegetable Oil (Soybean, Palm, Cottonseed), Pumpkin, Water, Salt, Leavening (Baking Soda, Sodium Aluminum Phosphate), Vanilla, Natural & Artificial Flavors, Artificial Colors F, D, & C, Yellow #5, Corn Syrup, Polysorbate 60

Instructions / Storage

  • Whoopie pies arrive ready to enjoy!
  • Upon arrival, place whoopie pies in the refrigerator or in the freezer.
  • Whoopie pies last up to 2 weeks in the refrigerator or up to 9 months in the freezer.
  • Serve pie at room temperature.
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • McClure’s Bakery ships Monday-Thursday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Pennsylvania


Well packaged and showed up when it was supposed to, despite the busy Thanksgiving season. Product was very good.
Leslie D. - Cary, NC
Love whoopie pies gave them as gifts and everyone loved loved!!!!
Jody B. - Orlando, FL
I shipped the pie to my brother for Christmas and it got there fresh and on time.
Robin K. - Telford, PA
Arrived in time and packaged well. Delicious and always a hit!!!
Tabitha B. - Rock Hill, SC
Everything!! Smooth ordering, no hassle payment, quick delivery AND an amazing product!
TINA K. - San Antonio, TX
Gobs (Whoppie Pies) were excellent and Very Very FRESH!,,
Renee S. - Round Rock, TX
THE whoopie pies were very good but much to small, They looked a lot bigger in the pictures
DEBORAH K. - Melrose, MA
Delivered on time still cold and delicious
Cheryl B. - Scotts Valley, CA
I was able to find my boss’s favorite dessert on gold belly. She couldn’t believe the surprise when I gave it to her for her birthday. With the world in chaos, this brought a smile to everyone’s face. Thank you.
Amy B. - Beachwood, OH
These items were sent as a xmas gift and everything was delivered exactly as promised. Nothing was late or delayed. The recipients especially loved the whoopie pies .. I'm told they 'disappeared in minutes'
Kelly S. - Wolcott, VT
Ease of ordering. Food packaging is top notch and choice of products. Chocolate Whoopies were a hit.
Lisa M. - Murray, UT
Product is high quality and delicious. The care taken with packaging was amazing and the item arrived in perfect condition!
Linda M. - North Olmsted, OH
Delivery tracking was great and the pies were perfect when they arrived.
Marsha H. - Council Bluffs, IA
Customer service is fantastic, I love the Whoopie Pies, will order again soon
Christina G. - Ruskin, FL
Received exactly what I ordered. Fresh and decadent and wrapped for safe delivery.
Thana C. - Battle Ground, WA
Loved the Whoopie pies!! We hadn’t ordered them before but we will definitely order them again!
Barbara D. - Sanford, FL
Most excellent food! Quick shipping, nice packaging.
David A. - Harlem, GA
Efficient and prompt delivery with updates. Items arrived on time and in excellent condition.
Craig J. - Winter Park, FL
It was so delicious and carefully packaged. Just as I remembered whoopie pies tasted from my childhood!
Peggy E. - Deland, FL
Super yummy Whoopie pies!
Amy F. - Burke, VA
Bought the whoopie pies for a birthday party for family member. It was an oldie but definitely goodie dessert and surprise.
Patricia H. - Hernando, FL
Everybody raved over the whoopie pies, and I really appreciated your tracking the shipments for me! That was a real bonus.
- ,
Everything arrived as it should be. And the flavor was fantastic. Loving everything so far.
Karen M. - Marlow, OK
Received my whoopie pies on time to 4 different people and all of them loved them
David S. - Richmond, NH
Everything from the easy order to the easy delivery to the excellent food. Just so you all know,I have recommended so many friends and family to Gold Belly.
Dale O. - Bakersfield, CA
This is my 3rd order from McClure’s Bakery. It is always perfection!
Roberta H. - Brant Lake, NY
the selection and availability is outstanding. visibility into the shipping and tracking was also fun, as this was a surprise delivery for my mom.
Deane B. - Melbourne, FL
The ordering process was hassle free. Delivery was timely and without issue. The item I ordered was fresh and delicious as promised.
Jane F. - Ridgefield Park, NJ
The web site was easy to use, the tracking was fantastic, the product arrived on time and was PERFECT! The cake was my Mother’s favorite and for her 80th birthday. Thank you so much!
Kathryn M. - Bradenton, FL
Everything was perfect. The deliveries were made on the date stated during the purchase and the food was amazing. The Chocolate Shoo Fly Pie and the Amish Cinnamon Buns were authentic and reminded us of home. We will be experimenting with other options from other areas of the US in the future. Thank you.
Robert A. - Avondale, AZ
The shoofly pie was amazing! It was delivered on schedule and was well-packaged.
Barbara T. - Pittsburgh, PA
The delivery to my daughter in Florida. She had no complaint's. Also, thank you for keeping me informed of the delivery problems. Your tracking info took all the stress out of late delivery by Fedex.
SHANNON W. - Jacksonville, FL
Goldbelly makes it pleasurable to spend your money 🤗 ! Everything looks so yummy and pleasing!! Great job of searching out the best that’s out there! Congrats Goldbelly !!!
Terri S. - Silver Spring, MD
Everything went perfect! Easy ordering and scheduling the date. My friend loved the food!!
Ann T. - New Bern, NC
Ordering was easy and product was as described. Person receiving was thrilled. Will definitely order again.
Sharon R. - Phoenix, AZ
Loved everything so delicious and fresh
Mary N. - Paterson, NJ
As always, everything arrived in perfect condition and did not disappoint!
Cynthia E. - East Branch, NY
Food was fantastic! Website does a spectacular job highlighting our nation's food wares! Love the histories provided for each purveyor; by far the best collection of specialty and comfort foods on the web!
Courtney A. - Berkeley, CA
Fast delivery and tasty food!
Julie L. - Eden Prairie, MN
Prompt delivery and baked items were fresh. Packed and packaged well.
Robert E. - North Bergen, NJ
Great communications from order through delivery and the Whoopie Pies were a HUGE HIT!
Cris B. - Torrance, CA
The packing, the pie, all was perfect!
William M. - Alexandria, VA
Delivered fresh and delicious The Shoo-Fly pie was larger than expected!!! Our Texas Family really enjoyed it and the Whoopi pies!!
Rob W. - Early, TX
Ease of ordering Delivered when promised Excellent tracking service
Georgia S. - Fredericksburg, VA
Fast shipping and fresh items
Bob E. - Chula Vista, CA
Came on time and delicious 😋
Brenda M. - Leesburg, FL
Delivered on time to a very happy girl!
Rachel F. - Rochester, NY
Everything was perfect. Couldn't ask for better product or service.
Rick M. - Phoenix, AZ
Sent to a friend, your Whoopie pies and she said they are the best she’s every had!
Becca D. - Fullerton, CA
gift received in perfect condition
Sharon S. - Edison, NJ
Great product.
Tracy Z. - Beaver Falls, PA
The chocolate were very moist and the filling was perfect.
Marylynn V. - Fords, NJ
Great taste. Enjoyed by all.
Amanda B. - Golden Oak, FL
Whoopie pies were delicious!!!!
Kristen B. - San Marcos, CA
The Dozen Red Velvet Whoopie Pies were awesome and the Chocolate Shoofly Pie is excellent! Brought back happy memories of visiting Pennsylvania Dutch and Amish communities in the 70's!
William M. - Decatur, TN
Delivery was on time and the Whoopie Pies were the BEST I HAVE EVER HAD!
Kathy R. - Surprise, AZ
Delicious Whoopie Pies. I ordered the chocolate, pumpkin, and red velvet. Sooo good. Packaged well. Very pleased.
K A. - Santa Barbara, CA
It was fun finding food that reminded me of my childhood.
Diane J. - Phoenix, AZ
It’s a delicious cake, and we thought the cinnamon was of a very good quality.
Melissa L. - Purcellville, VA
Ordered from Mcclure's Bakery. Ordered whoopie pies..loved the packaging. Whoopie pies were absolutely delicious.
Lisa K. - Agawam, MA
Good product, arrival as posted.
Mary S. - Lima, OH
The order arrived in time for Easter and the Whoopie Pies were great
Brenda F. - Brooksville, FL
Order arrived in perfect condition and was delicious! Well packed.
Susan G. - Denver, CO
Great shopping experience!
Dianne Z. - Thompson Falls, MT
Product as described. Timely delivery.
Elizabeth F. - Fairfax, VA
Product arrive on time and was perfect! Fresh and yummy!
Cynthia M. - Watsonville, CA
The ordering: easy The delivery: prompt The whoopie pies: delicious
Claire B. - Sandy Spring, MD
Everything was excellent and fresh
Kathleen L. - Palm Harbor, FL
Delivered on the correct day. Food was correct.
Marcel M. - Farmington, NM
The order process was easy and delivery was scheduled and received on time as indicated from McClure bakery.
Simone G. - Oakland, CA
Everything arrived as promised!
Betty S. - West Palm Beach, FL
The order was a gift. Friends were thrilled to receive it. As far as I know, it tasted delicious.
Joe H. - New York, NY
Easy order , quick delivery
Leonard M. - Gretna, NE
Whoopee pies were delicious!
Linda P. - Clifton Park, NY
Food items were per description
Kathye R. - Fernandina Beach, FL