Oh My Pumpkin Pie Giant Cookie

From The Maui Cookie Lady (


These ENORMOUS fat chewy cookie will hit the spot. Each cookie is hand-rolled and comes individually wrapped in a sealed bag for ultimate freshness. Fall’s favorite flavor turned into a cookie. A seasonal bestseller that loyal customers wait for all year. Imagine a warm Pumpkin Pie rolled into a cookie… this is the cookie for you. Each is made with warm vanilla caramel, brown sugar molasses, pumpkin pie, butterscotch, two types of cinnamon along with nutmeg, anise, mace, and cardamom.

Founded by Mitzi Toro, The Maui Cookie Lady combines the massive, thick, ooey-gooey cookies of your Instagram dreams with the very best island flavors. This little island bakery has gained loyal customers far and wide, from Japan to Dubai, due to Mitzi’s creative, Maui flavor combinations and use of wholesome, quality ingredients. Mitzi has been on the Cover of Maui Time Magazine, and named one of “Hawaii’s Most Successful Female Entrepreneurs.” And you know this is seriously delicious when “The Rock” Dwayne Johnson calls you his favorite cookies in the world on Instagram!

All Orders to Hawaii Ship Free

More Details

  • This package includes 4,8,12 or 24 Oh My Pumpkin Pie Maui Cookies
  • Each cookie is approximately 4" round, 2" thick and serves 2-4 people
  • Cookies are sealed individually and arrive in beautiful tissue packaging with gold foil seal

This Cookie is seasonal and available only for the fall


Unbleached unbromated flour, raw sugar, eggs, butter, citric acid, Hawaiian sea salt

Oh My Pumpkin Pie Pumpkin Emulsion, Butterscotch, Orange Food Dye, White Chocolate Chips, Cassia Cinnamon, Soft Stick Cinnamon, Sweet Anise, All Spice, Cool Cardamon, Rich Mace, Freshly Ground Cardamom

Instructions / Storage

  • Cookies arrive individually sealed, ready to enjoy!
  • Upon arrival, serve or place cookies in the freezer
  • Cookies can be stored in the freezer for 2-3 months in original packaging (Do not refrigerate)
  • To serve from frozen, allow cookies to thaw. Remove packaging, wrap in a dry paper towel and microwave for 30 seconds
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Items are prepared fresh and shipped directly from the shop
  • The Maui Cookie Lady ships Monday through Thursday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska will incur an additional $20 charge for 2-day shipping or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Recommended for you

More from Hawaii