Choose Your Own Giant Cookies - 24 Pack

From The Maui Cookie Lady (

These ENORMOUS fat chewy cookie will hit the spot. Each cookie is hand-rolled, and comes individually wrapped in sealed bag for ultimate freshness. Choose eight flavors for this 24 pack and allow Maui Cookie Lady to truly brighten your day and bring a little Aloha and happiness into your life.

Founded by Mitzi Toro, The Maui Cookie Lady combines the massive, thick, ooey gooey cookies of your instagram dreams with the very best island flavors. This little island bakery has gained loyal customers far and wide, from Japan to Dubai, due to Mitzi’s creative, Maui flavor combinations and use of wholesome, quality ingredients. Mitzi has been on the Cover of Maui Time Magazine, and named one of “Hawaii’s Most Successful Female Entrepreneurs.” And you know this is seriously delicious when “The Rock” Dwayne Johnson calls you his favorite cookies in the world on instagram!

All Orders to Hawaii Ship Free

More Details

  • This package includes 24 Giant Maui Cookies of your choice
  • Each cookie is approximately 4" round, 2" thick and serves 2-4 people
  • Cookies are sealed individually and arrive in beautiful tissue packaging with gold foil seal
  • Choose your favorite flavors below

Flavor Options Include

  • Da Half Baked – “The Rock” Dwayne Johnson’s posted on instagram that this was one of his favorite cookies. It’s a giant 8oz cookie with Oreo, Reese’s, Snickers, stuffed in a giant chocolate chip cookie with malt. Bigger than a Big Mac and not for the cookie weak.
  • Butter Rum Triple Chunker – The Original. White, Dark and Milk Chocolate Chip Cookie with a hint of rum
  • White Chocolate Macadamia Nut – Maui Grown Whole Macadamia Nuts, Premium White Chocolate Chunks and Bavarian Cream (Best Seller)
  • Pineapple Lychee Passion – Maui Grown Tropical Pineapple, Lychee Passion, White Tea, Rosehips, Citrus Lemon Chocolate Chunks and Sweet Fragrant Hawaiian Pineapple Chunks. The essence and aroma of the islands all wrapped into one beautiful artisan cookie
  • Kona Coffee Espresso – Mixes cold pressed Kona Coffee Beans with unprocessed, rich, velvety, French Valrhona cocoa, then stuffed with Valrhona 64% Tainori chips. The cookie is robust, dark and bold
  • Oatmeal Walnut Dark Chocolate – Extra thick rolled oats, dark chocolate wafers, raw sugar, cassia cinnamon, softstick cinnamon, sweet anise, rich mace, cool cardamom and raw sugar make this cookie experience ideal for the the traditional pallet
  • Grown Up Samoas – Did someone say Beer Cookies??? Maui Brewing Companies Coconut Hiwa Porter, Dark Exquisite Chocolate, Gooey Caramel, Flaked Coconut and topped with our homemade beer sugar makes for the ultimate utopia for every craft beer world connoisseur
  • Butterscotch Kisses – Cheat Day Cookie. Sammy Hagar’s Maui distilled Macadamia nut rum, butter toffee, butterscotch chocolate, warm vanilla caramel and raw sugar lends to a wonderland of cookie scrumptious sensations
  • Birthday Cake Cookie – Stick a Candle on top and get the best of both worlds combining cake and a cookie topped with sundae sprinkles and filled with delicious white chocolate wafers
  • Peppermint Patty Meltaway – Spearmint, wintergreen chocolate and Valrhona velvet cocoa stuffed with a peppermint patty
  • Maui Monkey – Chocolate chunkiest cookie gone bananas with Maui grown macadamia nuts, vanilla caramel, smooth gooey chocolate, Hawaiian sea salt and tropical banana
  • Grown Up POG – Maui Brewing POG IPA, Dark Chocolate, Orange ,Guava
  • Oh My Pumpkin Pie – Fall’s favorite flavor turned into a cookie. Seasonal best seller that loyal customers wait for all year.

This product is not eligible for discounts or promotions unless otherwise noted. Also, it cannot be purchased with promotional gift cards or referral credits.


Unbleached unbromated flour, raw sugar, eggs, butter, citric acid, Hawaiian sea salt

Butter Rum Triple Chunker: Milk chocolate, white chocolate, dark chocolate, bavarian cream, almond oil, vanilla
White Chocolate Macadamia Nut: white chocolate,Maui grown Mac nuts,vanilla,almond oil
Pineapple Lychee Passion: lemon chocolate, pineapple,apple, rosehips, white tea, dried lychee powder, hibiscus flower vanilla
Kona Coffee Espresso: unsweetened cocoa flour, dark chocolate chips, vanilla, kona coffee, almond oil
Oatmeal Walnut Dark Chocolate:walnuts, dark chocolate, cinnamon, anise ,mace, cardamom, vanilla, almond oil
Maui Monkey: bittersweet chocolate wafers, Maui grown Macadamia nuts, butterscotch chips, banana flavoring, molokai sea salt
Da Half Baked: reese’s, oreo, snickers, chocolate chips, vanilla, almond oil, malt
Grown Up Samoas: dark chocolate, coconut, coconut porter, caramel, malt, vanilla, almond oil
Lilikoi: white chocolate, maui grown lilikoi, vanilla,
Butterscotch Kisses: toffee, caramel, butterscotch chips, rum, vanilla, butterscotch schnapps,molokai sea salt
Birthday Cake Cookie: white chocolate, vanilla, cake mix, cake flavoring, almond oil, sundae sprinkles
Grown Up POG: Dark Chocolate, Orange Chocolate, Maui Brewing POG IPA, Guava, Hawaiian Sea Salt, Citric Acid, Potassium Sorbate and Vanilla
Oh My Pumpkin Pie Pumpkin Emulsion, Butterscotch, Orange Food Dye, White Chocolate Chips, Cassia Cinnamon, Soft Stick Cinnamon, Sweet Anise, All Spice, Cool Cardamon, Rich Mace, Freshly Ground Cardamom

Instructions / Storage

  • Cookies arrive individually sealed, ready to enjoy!
  • Upon arrival, serve or place cookies in the freezer
  • Cookies can be stored in the freezer for 2-3 months in original packaging (Do not refrigerate)
  • To serve from frozen, allow cookies to thaw. Remove packaging, wrap in a dry paper towel and microwave for 30 seconds
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Items are prepared fresh and shipped directly from the shop
  • The Maui Cookie Lady ships Monday through Friday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska will incur an additional $20 charge for 2-day shipping or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Recommended for you

More from Hawaii