Toasted Nutmeg Ice Cream Cookie Pie

Pre-Order for Thanksgiving Now! Available only 11/1/20 – 11/25/20

Ring in the holiday season with ice cream and cookies in one! Try a Toasted Nutmeg Ice Cream Cookie Pie with an Orange Scented Shortbread Crust! It has all the cozy holiday flavors, with a pop of citrus to finish. Perfect for the holidays.

Pooja Bavishi, Malai’s founder, develops her aromatic flavors based on the spicy cooking in her parents’ kitchen growing up. Pooja uses ice cream as the perfect blank slate to showcase the familiar flavors of her childhood – warm spices like ginger, nutmeg, cardamom, and saffron. Now, Pooja crafts all the ice cream by hand for these totally unique and satisfying flavors.

More Details

This package serves 7-10 people and includes a 9" Toasted Nutmeg Ice Cream Pie

Ingredients

whole milk, cream, cane sugar, non-fat milk, cream cheese (pasteurized milk and cream, whey protein concentrate, salt, carob bean gum, xanthan gum, cheese culture), inverted sugar syrup, orange scented shortbread (flour, sugar, butter (cream, natural flavoring), orange extract, salt), salt, nutmeg, tapioca starch

Instructions / Storage

Pie is carefully packed in an insulated shipping box with enough dry ice to keep the contents perfectly frozen. Don’t worry, it’s colder inside that box than it is in your freezer. Upon receipt, please place your pints in your freezer to store up to 6 months.

If you are looking to serve your pie right away but it arrived rock hard, simply place it on a counter or tabletop and let them rest for 10 minutes.

Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Malai ships Monday and Wednesday of each week.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New York

REVIEWS

Ice cream arrived totally cold and appropriately frozen.
Purvi B. - Hilton Head, SC
04/09/21
Delicious and prompt.
Anne C. - Middleburg, VA
02/18/21
Ordering was simple and the ice cream arrived in perfect condition right on time.
William F. - Palm Springs, CA
04/13/21
Malai Ice Cream arrived right on time; perfectly frozen!
Debbie P. - Naples, FL
01/31/21
The six pints I ordered from Malai ice cream arrived still icy cold and frozen solid. That's awesome coming from New York to Western North Carolina! The flavors were absolutely delicious and I will be ordering from Malai again soon. I would highly recommend Malai's product to anyone who enjoys quality ice cream.
Mary W. - Cherokee, NC
01/16/21
Great experience. Good product.
Ridhima G. - Astoria, NY
01/16/21
Malai ice cream arrived quickly, and was completely frozen. Perfect!
Susan D. - Edgartown, MA
11/20/20
Diwali ice cream was “The best ice cream we have ever tasted!” said my ice cream aficionado daughter
Elan V. - South Burlington, VT
11/16/20
Yummy ice cream. Easy ordering system.
Andrea M. - Stephentown, NY
10/12/20
The best ice cream I’ve ever had. It is ice butter with ingredients I wonder why no one thought of before. It’s ecstasy on a spoon.
Jennifer C. - Albion, ME
09/22/20
Everything was terrific! LOVED the ice cream...wouldn’t have known about it if it weren’t for you.
Lisa D. - Northport, NY
09/01/20
Everything! Item was delivered on time and in great condition. Packaging was perfect for the cold item.
Mehvish A. - Aldie, VA
05/03/21
The website is super easy to use, packaging is amazing, just a great way to try great food that is readily not accessible..
Monica A. - Livingston, NJ
04/09/21
Everything! The malai ice cream was outstanding in flavor and quality. It arrived frozen and well packed. The whole process of ordering and receiving was quick and easy.
Michele R. - Pittsford, NY
07/03/21
My ice cream arrived from New York to Western North Carolina. it was icy cold and still frozen solid! And the Malai ice cream was delicious as always!
Mary W. - Cherokee, NC
06/27/21
This ice cream was delicious! It arrived perfectly frozen. I’ve made several purchases on gold belly, this has been the best so far.
Denise B. - Beaumont, TX
06/07/21
Timely delivery. Ice cream arrived perfectly frozen
Girish S. - Overland Park, KS
05/16/21
Great ice cream, delivered perfectly and tasted delicious
Mom H. - Chadds Ford, PA
05/09/21
The food came when expected and the tracking was easy. It was nicely packaged and brought back memories of home!
Laurie P. - Richmond, VA
10/08/21
The ice cream arrived frozen and on the exact date it stated. The flavors of ice cream were very unique, which I wanted, and I loved all but one.
Kathy P. - Willowick, OH
08/21/21
Taste was good.
Reeya S. - Germantown, TN
08/31/21
They loved it!
- ,
08/01/21
Good quality ice cream.
ESTERA T. - Johns Creek, GA
07/24/21
Flavor and taste was good.
Rashmi J. - McLean, VA
06/21/21
Everything was tasty!
Natalie T. - Murfreesboro, TN
05/28/21
It was a gift and she loved it!
Cristina A. - Pembroke Pines, FL
04/26/21
I'm amazed that the ice cream arrived still solid.
Jessica F. - Poplar Bluff, MO
08/01/21