Father's Day Black & White Cookie Dozen


For over 80 years, Kossar’s Bagels & Bialys has been serving New Yorkers their favorite traditional treats. While they’re known for their savory items, their sweets are not to be missed! This package for Dad offers Kossar’s Black & White Cookies, made with lemon-flavored, cake-like cookies, topped with half chocolate half vanilla icing. So delicious!

Kossar’s Bagels & Bialys, the oldest bialy bakery in the U.S., has been serving New Yorkers their classic traditional treats, including brick oven baked bialys and kettle boiled bagels, for decades. Isadore Mirsky and Morris Kossar founded Mirsky and Kossar’s Bakery in 1936 and Kossar bought out his partner and renamed the New York bakery Kossar’s Bialys in 1953. Bialys, named for the Jews from Bialystok, Poland, is a delightfully chewy bread that is made with everything from onions to sundried tomatoes. Perfect for breakfast or as dinner accompaniment, Kossar’s Bialys are not to be missed. Kossar’s Bagels & Bialys was declared to have the best bialys in “the entire country” by famed former New York Times food critic Mimi Sheraton.

More Details

This package serves 12 people and includes

  • 9 Mini Black & White Cookies
  • 3 Large Heart-Shaped Black & White Cookies
  • Mini Cookies measure approx. 3"
  • Heart-Shaped Cookies measure approx. 5"


Flour, Sugar, Whole Eggs, Vegetable Oil, Water, Chocolate Fudge Base, Cream Fondant, Kernel Paste, Vanilla Flavor, Salt.

Contains: Wheat, Dairy, Eggs.

Instructions / Storage

  • Cookies ship fresh and arrive ready to enjoy.
  • These cookies may be kept at room temperature in their package for up to 2 weeks.
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Kossar’s Bagels & Bialys ships Monday-Friday of each week.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii will incur an additional $35 charge. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New York


California received delicious large bagels. Fabulous food. Thank you so much.
Jessica B. - Palo Alto, CA
The selections to choose from are amazing!! I can send vegan and non vegan goodies. This year I sent to 4 different locations and everything arrived on time and in excellent condition!! I will continue to order from Goldbelly. Customer service is also efficient and super friendly!!
Sandy M. - Newark, DE
Delivered on time and product was fresh
Cindy G. - Plano, TX
It came the next day. Bialys were conveniently packaged in groups of 3. Bialys tasted amazing and brought a taste of NY to California!
Wendy R. - Fremont, CA
Packaged securely and fresh! Kossar's food was delicious.
Teresah C. - Tylertown, MS
Fresh and tasty. And the nova salmon is cut so thin you can almost see through it. Plus it taste great too!
Arthur K. - Indio, CA
The bagels were friggin delicious!
Robert S. - Temecula, CA
I ordered the Bialy assortment, they came fresh and well packaged. We are enjoying them. Thank you!!
Maria B. - Las Vegas, NV
The cream cheese and pumpernickel was the best. But everything was so yummy and fresh.
Robin M. - Lake arrowhead, CA
I've been wishing for a local high-quality bagel seller for almost two decades. I finally broke down and found goldbelly, took a chance, and ordered bagels from Kossar's Bagels & Bialys. Wow! Sooooo much better than any other bagels, ever, anywhere (though I've never sampled other New York sellers)! What a treat. They cost more, but are worth every penny!
Randall J. - Morgantown, WV
Fabulous food, and a great assortment...the whitefish salad was full of full pieces of fish! Bonus treat were the black and white cookies. Will order again soon!
linda l. - Mount Pleasant, SC
Excellent bagels and the best lox I ever had! The cream cheese was really special too!
Scott S. - New Bern, NC
My relatives said they toasted them, and they were delicious!
Toby L. - Jackson, NJ
So fresh and the taste was amazing!!
Samantha H. - Patrick Springs, VA
Order arrived on time. Recipient was thrilled beyond words and declared Kossar’s bialys “delish!”
Erica H. - Oakland, CA
I ordered on Thursday and it arrived on Friday. The quality and freshness was wonderful!
Robert C. - Fort Mill, SC
Love the bagels! Just can't get them locally.
Randall J. - Morgantown, WV
Everything was perfect! Delivered on time! Exactly what I ordered:) product was delicious!!!
Sam M. - Harrisonburg, VA
Super fast delivery and fresh, delicious bialys!
Juli C. - Mount Vernon, IN
Fast delivery. The bagels and bialys were very fresh. The bagels especially were big and tasty, just like I had when I lived in New York.
Joel S. - Prescott, AZ
Shipped quickly! Loved the bagels, especially SALT. Hard to come by in South Jersey!
Danielle C. - Vineland, NJ
Shipment received on time, expeditiously. Thank you! I love my Kosar's pumpernickel bagels!
Martha N. - Yucca Valley, CA
Everything went well. The order came on time and was perfectly packed. I had ordered the bialys before and will do so again.
carol r. - Monticello, NY
My mother in law is from Brooklyn and loved this package for her birthday. It was like going home for her!
Doris K. - Rockville, MD
I've been buying from Gold Belly for awhile now and it's so nice to be able to shop within all Stores or Restaurants that I like. The Bialys are delicious and I've been looking to purchase them for awhile now.
Lorraine M. - Natural Bridge, NY
That we were able to get a real bagel that are boiled first then baked 😊Outside of NYC bagels are just baked, a big roll with a hole in the middle🤣
Kathryn M. - Williamsport, PA
Everything went well from ordering to delivery. We were pleased with the delivery updates we received and how well all items purchased were packaged.
Karen R. - Watertown, MA
Great bagels and bialys, I loved my assortment. Great packaging and arrived on schedule.
Marc Z. - El Paso, TX
Went beautifully! We loved everything including the presentation. Great job & delish too.
Allison C. - Hilton Head Island, SC
Every thing I’m out west and everyone loved what came it was fresh and delicious!
Stephen S. - Palm Desert, CA
Everything!. Bagels and lox and cream cheese were outstanding. Order arrived when you said it would. Thank you. You are two for two with us, and we will plan for a third soon!
Barry B. - Sacramento, CA
Delivered on time and made my mom super happy to have authentic food from a city she misses getting to visit.
Beth B. - Falmouth, ME
EVERYTHING. Delivery was available for Mothers Day weekend, and it arrived right on time. The BAGELS? AMAZING!!! Thanks for the treats!
Michael B. - Mechanicsburg, PA
Delivery came when it was promised- emails kept me informed. My bialys were perfect. I have missed bialys since I left New York so many years ago. I would only get them when I visited family there. It’s nice to know Goldbelly can deliver them any time I want them!
Donna W. - Petaluma, CA
Fresh when they arrived. Individually wrapped and freezable. I was hesitant as a former New Yorker that it wouldn't taste the same. The bialys were a taste of home!
Phyllis A. - Deland, FL
Fresh when they arrived. Individually wrapped and freezable. I was hesitant as a former New Yorker that it wouldn't taste the same. The bialys were a taste of home!
Frances G. - Anaheim, CA
Last minute brunch planned for Mother’s Day. I was able to order on Friday and have next day delivery!! Brunch was a huge success thanks to Goldbelly :)
joann s. - Union, NJ
Food was great! Despite a shipping goof (UPS didn’t pick up the order), Goldbelly sent out another shipment right away so we received the box the next day.
Em A. - Claremont, CA
The whole experience was excellent! From placing a order to receiving the well packed Black and Whites was impressive and absolutely delicious!
Patricia H. - Houston, TX
Shipped on time. AMAZING Product. Just couldn't believe how well everything worked out, and the person it was meant for was thoroughly pleased!
Adyn H. - Los Angeles, CA
Had a delivery sent from New York to Nevada, where you can't get a great or even a good bialy, and it arrived the next day. Having been a New Yorker, they were so appreciative :)
Marciano M. - Henderson, NV
Freshness of product and timely delivery
BOB C. - Mesquite, TX
Order came on time and my friend said they were delicious.
Zola K. - Fort Worth, TX
Delivery on time. Product was delicious!
karen M. - Ventura, CA
Great food. Good communication about the delivery. Easy website.
Kurt K. - Irving, TX
Ordering, update on delivery and arrival of bagels in excellent condition
Lisa P. - Mahwah, NJ
Everything! The dads were thrilled to receive NY goodies on the WC!👍🏻❤️
S&J R. - Oakland, CA
Bagels are excellent. The time frame in which I could choose when they would be delivered excellent. Over all experience, excellent. Its so hard to find a great bagel such as these in Virginia. Thank you, thank you
Wendy R. - Sterling, VA
Ordering easy. Delivery on time. Well packed.
Robert G. - Wappingers Falls, NY
Everything! The food was great, packaging was perfect and delivery was right on time!
Ann M. - Williamsburg, VA
Everything was great! It came on time, was still cold and very fresh. Thanks for making our Father’s Day surprise a hit!
Terri G. - Cumming, GA
Delivery was so quick! Ordered as a Father’s Day gift and he loved it!
Katie S. - Eau Claire, WI
On time delivery and product ordered was just as I expected.
Mary C. - Kingsport, TN
Ordering was easy and delivery was fast: bagels/bialys are great as are the cheeses.
Mary K. - Acton, MA
Delivery went as promised and Bialys were fresh
Jon D. - Candler, NC
Nothing like New York bagels. And these from Kossar’s are absolutely delicious.
Lynn A. - Chicago, IL
Delivered in a timely manner, well packed and fresh.
Marilyn G. - Bear Creek, PA
Package was delivered fresh, cold, and apparently was delicious!
Olive G. - Seattle, WA
Yummy food arrived in a City that just doesn’t have challah or matzoh ball soup.
Rosalyn Z. - Spokane, WA
Food is fresh and delicious! Shipped and arrived as scheduled. Great experience with goldbelly.com.
D Y. - Albany, OR
Came on time
Sally S. - Denver, CO
Delivery took place on the day promised. The bagels were enormous and authentic!
Dennis M. - New Orleans, LA
Shipping & arrived in timely manner.
Monica F. - Fort Myers, FL
Everything went well
Diane B. - Woodland Park, CO
Delivered on time, bagels fresh, and it came to the right address.
Carol S. - Nanuet, NY
I love the bialys and lox I live in Oregon and haven't had NY food for a long time
Marta S. - McMinnville, OR
bialy were Fresh ! delectable!
Shamik s. - Sebastian, FL
Great food. Delivery on time.
William F. - North Port, FL
Arrived on time & in timely fashion.
Janice C. - Steubenville, OH
The box from Kosar’s arrived on time & it was beautifully packaged!
Beverly P. - Monticello, NY
The bagels were delicious. So happy to enjoy them with family.
Rae W. - Camarillo, CA
Awesome selection, flawless delivery of perishables!
Judy R. - Midway, KY