Killer Brownie Bites + Buckeyes Party Tray
From Killer Brownie®

(
 4.8)

Killer Brownie ships its insanely decadent brownies nationwide on Goldbelly! It’s not just a clever name—the Killer Brownie® truly is like nothing else you’ve ever tasted! In the mood for something big, rich, and chocolatey? Half of this tray is filled with buckeyes—fudge-y peanut butter balls enrobed in decadent milk chocolate—a classic treat beloved by locals. The rest is filled with assorted two-bite pieces of world-famous, rich, ooey gooey Killer Brownie. half Buckeyes, half Killer Brownie.

Over 30 years ago, Chimene Mayne Ross and her siblings came home and found a small brown bag on the kitchen counter with a special treat inside. Their dad, who ran Dorothy Lane Market, a specialty food gourmet supermarket in Dayton, Ohio, told them, “Try that; it’s a killer brownie.” And the name stuck! The “Killer Brownie®” soon became a hit at Dorothy Lane Market’s bakery and so began decades of growing affection for this huge, delicious, triple-layered treat in flavors like Salted Caramel Brownie, Cookie Dough Brownie, and Confetti Brownie.

More Details

This pack includes:

  • 18 Assorted Killer Brownie® Bites
    • 18 Buckeyes
  • Each bite measures 1.5"

Flavors may include:

  • Salted Caramel
  • Blonde Ambition
  • Confetti
  • Cookie Dough
  • Triple Chocolate
  • Peanut butter

Ingredients

Contains: Wheat, Milk, Soybeans, Egg, Pecans, Peanuts, Macadamia Nuts, Almonds

Instructions / Storage

Bites can be left at room temperature for 7 days, refrigerated for about 14 days, or frozen for 30 days.

Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Orders placed by 10am Monday-Friday will ship same day.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

  •  
     
     
  •  
     
     
  •  
     
     
  •  
     
     

More from Ohio

  •  
     
     
  •  
     
     
  •  
     
     
  •  
     
     

(
 4.8) REVIEWS

OMG !! The brownies were FANTASTIC!!! Moist and fresh. Arrived cool and quickly. I could not be happier !!!!!
John T. - Huntington Beach, CA
12/12/19
My son said the brownies were “earth shattering!” Can’t get better than that, can you?
Adam H. - Cedar Park, TX
08/21/19
Killer is the appropriate descriptor! These brownies are the best! They are rich and chocolatey and the caramel filling layer is awesome. They arrived fresh and very well packed. My faves!
Susan G. - Westminster, CO
08/27/19
These are just sinful wrapped in chocolate and other assorted flavors! These arrived in a holiday tin just as you would use if you were giving it as a gift - which I purchased these as a gift. Some specialty bakers wrap each item before packing and honestly, it makes them appear no different than buying them from your grocer’s shelf. These decadent brownies were nestled tightly side by side in a beautiful tin, looking as if they’d been baked in your kitchen which added a nice touch. The hardest decision in purchasing was deciding which brownies - all were drool-worthy and there isn’t a bad decision in the bunch. Life is short; eat your killer brownie desserts first.
Susan S. - Marathon, FL
12/26/19
AWESOME, Excellent Brownies. The best brownies I have ever had. Nothing compares.
Anthony B. - Coeur D Alene, ID
11/13/19
The brownies were so good, that I had to put them down! I haven't ever, ever, ever, ever, ever had a brownie this good!
Melissa W. - Wright City, MO
12/13/19
It was convenient and delivery was fast. I received my brownies in excellent condition!
Connie H. - Sacramento, CA
11/11/19
Fabulous brownies! Wonderful flavors and very, very rich! In fact, so rich that I served them in halves with ice cream. They freeze well too! They also came in a great tin, perfect for art supplies, etc.
Carole W. - Chicago, IL
12/24/19
Loved the freshness of brownies and the combination of flavors.
Nancy K. - Meriden, CT
12/29/19
The convenience, the ease and the quality were very good! They were packaged very nice as well! I already have plans to send a few as Christmas gifts to friends!
Diane G. - Pensacola, FL
11/14/19
It was a gift to my cousins in Florida. They loved the killer brownies!
Karen N. - Ruskin, FL
12/30/19
The service was great and the brownies were outstanding!
Mary G. - Childress, TX
11/09/19
AWESOME, Excellent Brownies. The best brownies I have ever had. Nothing compares.
Anthony B. - Coeur D Alene, ID
11/27/19
The brownies were incredibly fresh and delicious. I highly recommend the Chocolate Peanut Butter ! Sinfully rich and perfect balance of peanut butter and chocolate !
Brian R. - Dorchester, MA
11/07/19
The brownies were incredibly fresh and delicious. I highly recommend the Chocolate Peanut Butter ! Sinfully rich and perfect balance of peanut butter and chocolate !
Brian R. - Dorchester, MA
11/20/19
Third time we have ordered these for different family members and friends, they all have gushed about how amazing they are!
Shane T. - Mount Vernon, OH
11/01/19
The brownies are fabulous! I often will microwave one for 20 seconds for the caramel to melt a bit.
Debora L. - Augusta, ME
01/21/20
At my age, I have made and eaten many brownies, but none compare to this. I first bought some to have shipped to my brother for his bday. He was very impressed w/ the shipping, presentation and the actual product. Next I had some sent to my Mom for Christmas. In both instances I got the create-your-own 8 pack. They arrived in a lovely reusable tin. I cannot recommend these highly enough. Worth the money for any brownie lover in your life, including yourself. Great gift to a client as well. I can't wait to give these to my best friend for her next birthday. She loves chocolate so I know she will enjoy these.
Jill T. - Los Alamitos, CA
12/20/19
Brownies were AMAZING! Tasted delicious and packaged very nice. Did I mention they tasted amazing!
Elizabeth H. - Colebrook, NH
01/16/20
Sent this to our son-in-law for his birthday, and the response we got was "Ah. Ma. Zing."
Kevin L. - Loganville, GA
01/13/20
Brownies fresh and delicious !
Tracy C. - Forney, TX
11/20/19
Veeeerrrryyyy chocolatey!!
Cathy K. - Westerville, OH
01/13/20
I ordered this a couple months ago and set the delivery date in advance, and the shipment arrived as scheduled! The packaging wasn't overdone; it was compact, and also very cute and functional!
Christine O. - Cambridge, MA
01/27/20
The Killer Brownies were very rich and everything i hoped for.
Quinton R. - Milledgeville, GA
02/07/20
The brownies are fantastic. Delivered as promised.
Tim S. - Pomona, CA
12/19/19
The brownies are excellent. Well-packaged. Promptly received. Very moist and sweet.
Kathryn C. - Indio, CA
01/23/20
Quick delivery, fresh product, amazing item!
Ron C. - Long Beach, CA
02/17/20
Order came a day early. Very delicious!
Mitzi F. - Hollister, CA
12/10/19
Delivery and trying a new product s always dicey but your reviews/rating was spot on!
Andrew L. - Jackson, MS
02/18/20
The brownies from Killer Brownie Co were amazing. Possibly the best brownies I've ever had. Shipment arrived as scheduled and was well packed.
Chase L. - Fisherville, KY
12/11/19
Brownies were delicious and would recommend them to friends and family.
Chassity P. - Knoxville, TN
03/03/20
These brownies were SERIOUSLY UNBELIEVABLE.
Catherine T. - Los Alamitos, CA
12/26/19
I purchase a dozen of your famous brownies (German Chocolate, Peanut Butter and Oreo Cookies). They arrived a day early, packaged securely and my daughter said they are delicious. I will be ordering some for me now.
Melinda M. - Cayce, SC
03/09/20
Everything-- the brownies were delicious-- thank you
Ellen G. - New York, NY
03/09/20
Great service great food
Stephanie G. - Carlsbad, CA
03/09/20
I ordered Killer Brownies for someone as a birthday gift. They raved about the brownies- how large and fresh they were! They loved each flavor in the variety pack. I had a question with the ordered that was shipped and was assisted by Vanessa in their customer support department. Her assistance and concern with my question was so amazing. She responded to my emails quickly and always courteously. Vanessa took care of my concern and went above and beyond what I even expected. Based on the Killer Brownies and the customer support they offer, I would definitely order from Goldbelly again and my friend who received the brownies said she will order these for herself as well as gifts. This was my first order from Goldbelly and you never know what will arrive from an online site, but I was more than satisfied with my experience and will definitely order from them again in the near future. Great job!
Wendy W. - Longboat Key, FL
03/16/20
Brownies were yummy and delivered as promised at a reasonable price
Mary W. - Manlius, NY
03/16/20
Fast delivery, food was fresh and delicious
Amy T. - Oakdale, CA
03/26/21
I love this site because it allows me to give and receive some of the food items I can’t get to in person.
Jo T. - Portland, OR
03/15/21
Great product- on time
Matthew L. - Essex Junction, VT
03/26/21
My sister received for her birthday and loved the packaging and the salted caramel brownies were out of this world she said :)
Kipleigh B. - Glendale, CA
06/07/21
Killer Brownies are awesome!
Lauri H. - Pagosa Springs, CO
06/07/21
The killer brownies are perfect for my grandson who had a birthday! He loves German chocolate cake! He’s off at college but will be home soon to get his big birthday bag full of goodies and Cash!
Patricia P. - Alexandria, LA
05/23/21
Everything was great. The brownies are so big. I gave a couple of them away, and they loved them. I am going to order more very soon! Thank you for making such great brownies!
Kathleen M. - South Plainfield, NJ
05/19/21
Products delivered on time and my daughter-in-law said the brownies that she tried were amazing
Michelle G. - Warwick, RI
05/16/21
We sent brownies to both our kids at 2 different addresses. What could go wrong? Nothing! It was perfect! Goldbelly notifies you through out the process, so you're never wondering.
Brenda M. - Ramona, CA
05/10/21
I was amazed at all the restaurant and food options available for shipping! My item was shipped quick and super fresh! Will definitely order again for unique gifts!!
Lauren W. - Madisonville, KY
05/10/21
They were huge! To die for! Best salted Caramel I ever tasted. Most of all I loved the tin! Yummy. Thanks
Kathleen F. - Coconut Creek, FL
05/09/21
It was delicious the birthday boy really enjoyed it
JoAnn S. - Georgetown, MA
07/28/21
Order was packaged well, delivered on time and was in excellent condition. I also like that I was able to see current location and estimated arrival time.
Alex L - Milwaukee, WI
07/20/21
After getting my package and opening it up I was so impressed on the taste and size of the brownies! Very good, the best I have ever eaten!!
Pamela S. - Suquamish, WA
07/19/21
Delivered expeditiously in beautiful packaging!
Vicki D. - Leonardtown, MD
07/15/21
It was easy to choose what I wanted, no problems entering voucher info, and my order came when it was supposed and was enjoyed by the people with whom it was shared.
Gabriela I. - Albuquerque, NM
07/06/21
Everything was amazing!! My son bought me my first Killer Brownies and I am hooked!!
Debbie S. - Dodge City, KS
07/03/21
Easy ordering, on time delivery, and the person receiving it said it was delicious
Parker W. - New York, NY
06/28/21
Everything. My daughter-in-law loved the Killer Brownies from Dorothy Lane Market. I liked how they were packaged. Again, thank you and I will use you again.
Jean G. - Blanchester, OH
06/25/21
Everything…delivered on time and the brownies were thoroughly enjoyed!!
Howie A. - Chicago, IL
06/22/21
Excellent food product; ordering easy & delivered on time in perfect condition!
Galen C. - Columbus, KS
06/20/21
Quality, flavor and all around goodness. You can't go wrong purchasing these brownies. Very well worth them. Enjoy!
Kathy H. - Wisconsin Dells, WI
06/20/21
Everything went well from having a wide variety of options from which to choose to the prompt delivery. I've already recommended Goldbelly to friends and intend to order again.
Margo F. - Linthicum Heights, MD
09/20/21
Already recommended to my family and friends! The brownies were AWESOME! Definitely will ordering another batch soon😋
Tyler B. - Harker Heights, TX
09/18/21
Sent them as a gift and she absolutely loved them! She said they were the best brownies she's ever had (German chocolate) and couldn't believe how big they were. They were packed great and she loved the tin.
Patty J. - Bronson, MI
09/14/21
Every part of this process, was perfect. From ordering to free shipping, and delivery on time AND GREAT BROWNIES... a perfect experience.
Philip J. - Goodrich, MI
09/04/21
My Stepfather loved his killer brownies! Said he couldn’t stay away from them till they were gone!
Marc K. - Plano, TX
09/02/21
Quality product my grandkids at college enjoyed them.
Grif L. - Starkville, MS
09/01/21
The Killer Brownies are Excellent! Tastes more like fudge than a brownie! Would order again and again! Great packaging for shipping. Do Not hesitate to try the Killer Brownies! 😍
Lisa B. - Thorndike, MA
08/23/21
Sent these to my 93 year old mother with a sweet tooth who had no idea these delectables existed. She was overjoyed. Goldbelly always delivers the goods in a quick and easy way.
Hilda Z. - Flushing, NY
08/21/21
The customer service is excellent! I'd placed a perishable order that was delayed by the delivery service and I was afraid it would have gone bad by the time it arrived. I called, the order was placed again for overnight delivery. The original packaged eventually arrived, but was hot and had turned so it was thrown out, but the 2nd order arrived perfect!
Pamela R. - Palestine, TX
08/16/21
Everything!! Couldn't ask for better. The Killer Brownies are the Best we have ever eaten and will definately be ordering more!!
Pamela S. - Suquamish, WA
08/10/21
Food, shipping, packing
Riley W. - Seminole, FL
01/24/22
Everything. The brownies tasted great!
Rachel W. - Tucker, GA
01/24/22
Killer brownie remains a reliable shop and delightful gift!
Katherine M. - Reston, VA
01/24/22
Super fast shipping. Great product.
Mercedes B. - The Dalles, OR
01/21/22
Killer Brownies are delicious.
Joan P. - Myrtle Beach, SC
01/18/22
Fast delivery. The BEST brownies I have ever eaten
julia s. - Courtdale, PA
01/18/22
Food was really good
Ryan H. - Lincolnshire, IL
01/14/22
Excellent product, delivered on time!
William M. - Medina, NY
01/11/22
Arrived in excellent condition. Brownies are wonderful.
Justine S. - Ord, NE
01/16/22
Everything went smoothly as far as ordering and notifications.
Susan W. - Canton, SD
01/11/22
They are the most decadent brownies. Packaging is excellent. I had them shipped at a later date and the shipment was exactly when they said it would be.
Justine S. - Ord, NE
01/23/22
Delivered when promised, sent ad gift and recipient was very happy.
Spiller F. - Langhorne, PA
01/11/22
Quick delivery and yummy treats
Danyelle D. - Ecru, MS
01/09/22
The fast delivery and good quality and the good food
Janis S. - Roosevelt, NY
01/16/22
Very good and fresh for my daughter’s birthday. She loved them.
Rosemary D. - Brookings, OR
01/11/22
These are so so so delicious!!
Kimberly D. - Mohave Valley, AZ
04/04/22
Everything shipped on schedule and arrived here on time. The brownies were excellent and very attractively packaged as well. Plan to send a batch soon for someone’s birthday.
Richard M. - Fairfax Station, VA
03/26/22