Famous Key West Key Lime Pie - 2 Pack

Key West Key Lime Pie Co. ships its famous Key lime pie nationwide on Goldbelly! The old and the new, the sweet and the tart—that’s Key West Key Lime Pie Co. Each Key lime pie is made with real Key lime juice and a handmade graham cracker crust and topped with whipped cream.

Key Lime Pie gurus Jim Brush and Alison Sloat are a culinary rags-to-riches story. From their humble beginnings selling their signature Key lime pie on the side of the road, to having their Key lime pie named America’s Best Pie by the American Pie Council, the whirlwind ascent of Key West Key Lime Pie Company is a delicious story. The Key West bakery makes each pie by hand with a tried-and-true, 100-year-old recipe featuring real Key lime juice and a handmade graham cracker crust. Everything at Key West Key Lime Pie Co. is made fresh in-house using all-natural ingredients sourced right in Key West, Florida.

More Details

This package serves 16 people and includes two 9" Key Lime Pie topped with whipped cream

  • Each pie serves 8 people
  • Pies arrive in branded packaging. Perfect for a gift!


Sweetened Condensed Milk, Whipped Cream, Graham Crumbs (Wheat Flour, Brown Sugar, Soy Bean Oil, Whole Wheat Flour, Water, Honey, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Salt, Butter, Vanilla) Key Lime Juice From Concentrate, Brown Sugar, Granulated Sugar, Butter, Confectioners Sugar, Honey, Stabilizer (Blend Of Pure Vegetable Gum, Dextrose, Salt) Vanilla

Instructions / Storage

  • Pies are made fresh and shipped with dry ice
  • Upon arrival, place the pie in the freezer. Pies can be kept frozen for up to 6 months
  • To serve, set on the counter for 5 minutes. Slice and serve like an ice cream cake
  • Pies can be stored in the fridge for up to 1 hour
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Key West Key Lime Pie Co. ships Monday through Thursday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Florida


First of all, the pies arrived thoroughly frozen, all the way to Hawaii...just as promised!!! These are the authentic Key Lime Pies, refreshing, slightly creamy with the clearly identifiable flavor of freshly-picked limes. The graham cracker crust provided an ideal compliment to the tangy flavor...the perfect summertime dessert!
Valerie H. - Kalaheo, HI
My roomie who NEVER had KEY LIME pie loved it.... he said it was excellent!
Ernest B. - Hermiston, OR
The person I sent the Key Lime Pie to said it was the best they've ever had...And they lived in Key West!
Brian W. - Pebble Beach, CA
It was amazing! One of the best Key lime pies I’ve ever had!
Walter L. - Fargo, ND
My friend grew up in Key West and said the pie was a slice of her childhood! She hated sharing it with her husband!
Jamie S. - Syracuse, NY
Arrived across the country still frozen ! I was so worried it would be a mushy mess but the recipients loved it and said the key lime pie was perfect.
Jessica M. - San Diego, CA
I ordered a Key Lime Pie from Key West FL. It was transported to Tucson, AZ. the pie arrived frozen and the packing around it was secure.. The pie was great- Thank you Goldbelly for bringing us food that we would not be able to get!!
Susan A. - Tucson, AZ
My friend grew up in Key West and said the pie was a slice of her childhood! She hated sharing it with her husband!
Candace J. - Syracuse, NY
The pies are truly delicious and they came shipped in a little cooler which was really nice.
Yolanda K. - Chicago, IL
Sent to a friend in Cincinnati Ohio while visiting KeyWest Florida. She loved it! Not only did it come earlier than expected, but the friend raved how good the Key Lime pie tasted. Thanks !
Pam S. - Cincinnati, OH
Best I ever had
Michael M. - Chicago, IL
The frozen key lime and covered bars were great. They were exactly has I remembered the last time I was in Key West Florida.
Sheri N. - Santa Cruz, CA
The pies arrived before the estimated delivery date and were excellent. They got two thumbs up from my ultra fussy boyfriend who was certain that I couldn't get pies that were as good as the ones he ate as a child in Miami. Thanks so much.
Diane M. - Puyallup, WA
Delicious key lime pies- arrived frozen, perfectly packed!!!
Pat A. - Nevada City, CA
The product came even a little early, was in excellent shape, and tasted great.
Rick F. - Paradise Valley, AZ
Delivery was on time and products were delicious
FERN F. - Pikesville, MD
Everything was delicious. Arrived on time. Packed very well. Love the products
Judie P. - Brackenridge, PA
I sent a Key Lime Pie to best friend in Wisconsin for his Birthday 20 years ago he lived here, and when ever went out to eat, he always order the Key Lime, moved away and missed it, and you surprised him with pie.
Howard H. - Lannon, WI
The entire process starting with the ordering to the delivery. Perfect pie which my husband loved. Will order again. Thank you.
Stephen J. - Austin, TX
Goldbelly was perfect. We got notifications all along the way for the order. Order arrived earlier than expected and in perfect condition. No complaints whatsoever. Would use again.
William B. - Taylor, PA
It was delivered fresh. It was on the porch for a while but it stayed wonderful. It was delicious. I like this company
David C. - Salisbury, MD
The order arrived on time and was still frozen. In fact it arrive a day earlier than expected. The pie was fantastic.
Arlene D. - Bothell, WA
The entire order and delivery process went very well. I had the pie shipped for a birthday gift to another address. She was surprised and thrilled to receive it. I will use your business again. Thanks
Cathy C. - Bennington, NE
I have had trouble this year with getting deliveries, especially with FedEx. The packaging here was outstanding. It handled the three days in transit very well. It was delivered in great condition and the taste was outstanding. Will order this one again.
John M. - Dallas, TX
My daughter & her boyfriend loved the Key Lime Pie. They go to Key West often so I thought this was a great idea!! I love making her happy!!
Jess F. - Hypoluxo, FL
My husband and sister loved the Key Lime Pies from Key West Lime Pie Company. I loved the Goldbelly shopping experience, as always. It’s easy to find and order delicious offerings from vendors galore on Goldbelly.
John M. - Benton, AR
This is my 2nd order w/this Company & that order was good because of the contents of the package, we were worried about it thawing that order was an 8 out of 10. This order was 10! across the board! It's our brother's favorite!
John M. - Phoenix, AZ
Everything. Delivery on time & the Key Lime was the star of the event.
Scott H. - Woodbine, MD
The delivery was very accurate and the pie arrived in very good condition 
Hector M. - Bradenton, FL
Timely, professional and friendly service.
Mary M. - Northport, NY
The food was delicious of course but the ability to do this at all for my husband's birthday?....Awesome! Ty!
Cheyne O. - Garland, TX