Cheesecake Sandwiches - Choose Your Own 16 Pack

Take your pick from irresistibly light, fluffy, indulgent cheesecake sandwiches in a wide variety of best-selling flavors! Each cheesecake sandwich is handcrafted in a nut-free facility, and can be enjoyed frozen or thawed!

At Grandma’s Cheesecake Sandwiches, founder Lisa Cotoggio is transforming this legendarily rich and creamy cake into a dessert that you can eat with your hands. Growing up, Lisa fell in love with her grandma Raphaella’s cheesecakes, and after a career as an actress, model, and published novelist, in 2019 she decided to open Grandma’s Cheesecake Sandwiches just a couple blocks from where Raphaella lived in the residential neighborhood of Whitestone in Queens, New York. Since opening, Grandma’s Cheesecake Sandwiches has become a huge success, with a wide variety of cheesecake flavors sandwiched between an equally dazzling array of freshly-baked cookies.

More Details

This package serves 16 people and includes your choice of 16 Cheesecake Sandwiches

  • Each sandwich measures 3.25″ × 2.25″ × 3.25″ and weighs 4 oz.
  • Cheesecake Sandwiches arrive individually wrapped in branded box.

Flavor Options Include

  • Butterscotch – A dreamy taste of yesteryear.
  • Chocolate Chip – A combination of two favorites make up the rich taste of the chocolate chip cheesecake sandwiches, giving them just the right hint of sweetness.
  • Coffee – These coffee cheesecake sandwiches taste like your favorite cup of brew.
  • Cookie Crumble – These irresistible, light, fluffy chocolate cookie crumble cheesecake sandwiches are our version of cookies and cream.
  • White Chocolate Raspberry – These are Grandma’s Favorite cheesecakes. Yes, there really is a grandma, Raphaella, whose favorite flavors were white chocolate and raspberry. These cheesecake sandwiches are dedicated to her memory and never disappoint.
  • Marble Cake – First they make the delicious chocolate cake, then break it down to small pieces and sprinkle them through the old-fashioned plain cheesecake to bring you the marble cheesecake sandwiches, another fan favorite.
  • Milk Chocolate – Smooth, luscious milk chocolate cheesecake sandwiched between two soft chocolate cookies makes this one the perfect chocolate lover’s treat.
  • Rainbow Crumble – We want to start out by telling you that this is a nut-free shop, so the rainbow crumble cheesecake sandwiches are not made with those three-layer rainbow cookies you may be thinking of because they contain almond paste. These are made with vanilla tie-dye cookies and attract both kids and adults alike.
  • Red Velvet – Like everything else, these red velvet cheesecake sandwiches are made from scratch, first the red velvet cake, which cools, and is crumbed and added to the old-fashioned plain cheesecake, a top fan favorite.
  • Salted Caramel – Start by making the salted caramel, then pour it into the old-fashioned plain cheesecake batter for a salted caramel cheesecake sandwich that explodes with flavor.
  • Strawberry Shortcake – Many people ask what is the difference between the strawberry shortcake cheesecake sandwiches, and the strawberry ones. That would be the graham cracker, and the strawberry pump in the middle.
  • Tiramisu – Tiramisu cheesecake sandwiches are undoubtedly the number one fan favorite. Rich tiramisu flavored cheesecake sandwiched between two chocolate cookies…what more could you ask for?
  • Chocolate Eclair – Think good humor bar when you bite into this chocolate éclair cheesecake sandwich all the way down to the surprise piece of chocolate you find inside.
  • Classic – The old-fashioned taste of plain cheesecake whipped to perfection between two soft golden cookies puts this choice at the top of the list.
  • Dark Chocolate – Rich, luscious, dark chocolate…need we say more?
  • White Chocolate – These cheesecake sandwiches are simply decadent, and perfect for those who dislike the raspberry filling that comes in the grandma’s favorite.
  • Blueberry – Filled with fresh blueberry filling, which compliments our old-fashioned plain cheesecake.
  • Cherry – Like the blueberry filled, they take the old-fashioned plain cheesecake and fill it with scrumptious cherries to make the cherry cheesecake sandwiches.
  • Lemonade (S) – A light, tangy lemon taste for the lemonade cheesecake sandwiches that takes you back to the lemonade stand you had as a kid.
  • Orange Creme (S) – Reminiscent of a childhood favorite, these orange crème cheesecake sandwiches are the next best thing to a real creamsicle.
  • Peach – Consists of puree peaches right into the cheesecake batter for a light summery taste that sets these peach cheesecake sandwiches apart.
  • Strawberry – Puree the strawberries to create that nice pink color for the strawberry cheesecake sandwiches.
  • Pumpkin – These Pumpkin Cheesecake sandwiches are filled with pieces of pumpkin cake giving the old-fashioned Plain Cheesecake just the right hint of flavor.
  • Candy Cane – Ho Ho Ho, Merry Christmas…a light peppermint crunch gives our Candy Cane Cheesecake Sandwiches just the right amount of flavor to ring in that holiday cheer.
  • Gingersnap Cookie Crumble – We start out with a homemade gingersnap recipe, then grind down the cookies after baking and mix them into our old-fashioned Plain Cheesecake to delight you with our Gingersnap Cookie Crumble Cheesecake Sandwiches.

Seasonal flavors are available for a limited time only

Ingredients

Made with Cage-free Eggs, Unbleached Flour, Cane Sugar – All-natural, Nut-free, single portion control snack developed from old-fashioned centuries old secret family recipe. Allergens: Egg, Milk, and Wheat.

Nut-Free Facility

Instructions / Storage

  • Cheesecake Sandwiches ships frozen with dry ice
  • Do not remove dry ice with bare hands
  • Upon arrival remove packaging and place immediately in the freezer
  • May be stored in the freezer for up to 1 year or in the refrigerator for 7-10 days.
  • Thaw times may vary by room temperature and outside climate.
  • Cheesecake Sandwiches can be enjoyed frozen or thawed!
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Grandma’s Cheesecake Sandwiches ships Monday-Wednesday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New York

REVIEWS

Products from Goldbelly have never disappointed. My daughter and her friends enjoyed her gift even though it arrived late. Good thing it was well packaged.
Melissa M. - Tuxedo Park, NY
09/12/21
The cheesecake sandwiches came quickly, frozen and tasted wonderful
Allyson W. - Chandler, AZ
09/12/21
Never had a cheesecake cookie and I am so glad I ordered them. Wonderful flavor and texture. Would order again.
John T. - Vero Beach, FL
09/12/21
Fast delivery, well packaged, great product.
Sam F. - Las Vegas, NV
09/11/21
Packed well with dry ice so even though the shipment was delayed 1 day and temperature was 90-100, they still arrived cold.
Kevin M. - Goshen, OH
08/30/21
Arrived on time and my niece and nephew said everything was delicious
Amy/Ryan D. - Glen Mills, PA
08/29/21
Fast delivery, free delivery options and delicious food!
Francesca C. - Sierra Vista, AZ
08/23/21
Food arrived on time and was the quality I expected.
Sean S. - Green Bay, WI
09/19/21
Love these have ordered multiple times. Great for a quick sweet and have them in the freezer. So many choices and all of them special.
John T. - Vero Beach, FL
01/22/22
Shipping was prompt and quality of cheesecake sandwiches was superb!
Patricia B. - Phoenixville, PA
01/01/22
Cheesecake was great! It arrived on date promised and packaging kept it frozen for serving later.
Matthew S. - Virginia Beach, VA
01/02/22
My brother said the product was delicious and it arrived on time.
Gray H. - Corpus Christi, TX
01/22/22
Delivery instructions followed. This was a Christmas Dinner Dessert Gift. The recipients loved the cheesecake sandwiches! Applause! Applause!
Wendy D. - Schwenksville, PA
12/26/21
I had a pleasant and efficient experience. Web site was easily navigated; shipping was exactly as promised; and the product was excellent. I will be ordering again!
Jonathan P. - Plano, TX
12/25/21
The cheesecake sandwiches are a hit with my husband! Thanks for a good birthday dessert. The flavors were delicious and the size was perfect. They were frozen and box was well insulated.
Cody R. - Jber, AK
12/19/21
I love the top notch selection of products available. The super fast shipping and outstanding packaging is the best!
Pamela R. - Lincoln, NE
12/10/21
My daughter LOVED the cheesecake! Fast and accurate shipping to her college campus! Thank you!
Emma S. - Grand Forks, ND
11/27/21
All of the desserts were amazing. Everything was packaged well and I received all of my items in a timely manner.
Joli F. - Lakeland, FL
12/10/21
My recipients thought the presentation was cute.
Mushfiqur R. - Woodhaven, NY
11/24/21
The order was received fresh within 36 hours of being placed and looked exactly like the photo.
Denise G. - Tucson, AZ
11/14/21
Everything was great as I had expected from the order process to the delivery and the care instructions. My first order with Grandmas Cheesecakes and I am thrilled - they are the best!
tracie m. - South Daytona, FL
10/24/21
The ordering experience, pictures and options to choose from were all great.
Carlos A. - Silver Spring, MD
10/01/21
Second time we ordered this food item - tried a few other flavors all are great. There are a few more we need to try.
john t. - Vero Beach, FL
10/09/21
Arrived on time with correct items for birthday recipient; excellent quality!
Josh B. - Bala Cynwyd, PA
10/04/21
My daughter really loved the Grandma’s Cheesecake.
Kini S. - Castle Pines, CO
12/26/21