Cookie & Cream Ice Cream - 6 Pints

Graeter’s ships its legendary ice cream nationwide on Goldbelly! This cookie and cream ice cream will transport you straight back to childhood. Generous chunks of America’s favorite sandwich cookies are dunked into Graeter’s sweet ice cream, making this classic flavor even more delicious than you remember. A must try!

150 years and four generations later and Graeter’s is still making ice cream as they did in 1870, and it’s some of Cincinnati’s best and most beloved ice cream. Home to the world’s only French Pot Freezer, Graeter’s uses this old-school machinery to churn out their custard-like ice cream 2 gallons at a time. Every flavor starts with a French-style ice cream base made with eggs and fresh local dairy with 18% butterfat – that’s nearly double standard ice cream! While Bob Graeter admits that the French Pot process is “not the most efficient way to make ice cream" it’s worth it because it makes superb ice cream with a dense, flavorful, and unique creamy texture. Talk about artisanal!

More Details

This package includes 6 pints of Cookie & Cream Ice Cream


  • Cookie & Cream – Cream, milk, cane sugar, Oreo® cookies (sugar, unbleached enriched flour (wheat flour, niacin, reduced iron, thiamine mononitrate {vitamin B1}, riboflavin {vitamin B2}, folic acid), high oleic canola oil and/or palm oil and/or canola oil, cocoa (processed with alkali), high fructose corn syrup, baking soda and/or calcium phosphate, cornstarch, salt, soy lecithin, vanillin, chocolate), skim milk, eggs, natural flavor, carob bean gum, guar gum.

Instructions / Storage

  • Graeter’s Ice Cream ships frozen with Dry Ice
  • Do not remove dry ice with bare hands
  • Place ice cream in the freezer immediately upon arrival
  • For the best experience, allow the ice cream to temper for 24 hours in the freezer before enjoying
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

Graeter’s ships Monday-Friday of each week

  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Ohio


Shipment arrived great, absolutely frozen solid. Flavors have all been enjoyed. Some of the best Ice cream ever.
Gregg B. - Westminster, CO
The variety and quality of the ice cream was great! We can’t wait to see what we receive on our next shipment.
Jack M. - Chapmanville, WV
Ice cream was delicious- great quality. Packaging and labeling was neat, eye catching and tempted you to consider other options.
Kerri S. - Middleton, MA
Sending ice cream in a package seemed like a dicey proposition, but it came completely frozen with no problems at all.
Gregory G. - Boerne, TX
Troubleshooting happened quickly when my ice cream order was accidentally routed the wrong way. Packed well, too, so it got here still frozen after a 24 hour delay.
Anna B. - Indio, CA
everything...Megan in customer service was an angel....the delivery was date expected....most important.....they absolutely loved the ice cream and the kids did science experiments with the dry ice....home run 🍦
Carolyn D. - Dallas, TX
Oh my gosh! This is the best ice cream! Will absolutely order again and give as a gift!
Jason M. - Hingham, MA
items packed well. most items were awesome. customer service was EXCELLENT!
griffin e. - Marlin, WA
The quality of each flavor in the sampler pack is outstanding. The chocolate pieces in some of the flavors is very high quality.
Sherry N. - Katy, TX
Delivered frozen and timely! This ice cream is soo creamy and delicious!
Joy L. - Hillsboro, OR
The ice cream was packaged so well that it hadn't even started to soften while in transit! Also, your communication regarding the delivery was stellar. Thank you!
April V. - Au Gres, MI
Products were very good and customer service was excellent.
Karl P. - Port Washington, WA
Customer service was super friendly and efficient. They were open to solving the problem and getting my order back on track.
Valerie I. - Montebello, CA
The ice cream was still frozen when I received it. (in this ninety degree heat). The ice cream is outstanding!
michelle g. - Coudersport, PA
Everything!!!! Graeters ice cream was a bit hit and well received by birthday grandkids!!!!!!
Wy/Hunt R. - Dana Point, CA
quality of the food and packaging....fantastic variety and selection of items to purchase.
JF F. - Del Mar, CA
My daughter and her family got the ice cream in a timely manner. It was still hard, and packaged very well.
Ally/Jon D. - Del Rio, TX
Ice cream delivered very solid……..tasty. Pleased with the order process online.
Tom R. - Wayzata, MN
I chose a future delivery date and my gift was delivered on time and in good condition. My father was thrilled.
John G. - Monrovia, MD
Father-In-Law loved his birthday gift of ice cream. Order process was very easy. Thanks.
Don K. - Killen, AL
Greeters was delivered right on time and frozen solid on dry ice. I’m an ice cream addict and this is the best ever!!
William F. - Palm Springs, CA
The ice cream is absolutely delicious!!! We would love to place an order for friends as a new parent gift!
Christina W. - Sherborn, MA
The ice cream was still solid in Florida heat after having been on the truck all day! I was so happy...thank you! It is helping my Mom's recovery ;)
Les M. - North Port, FL
Arrived right on time, packaging was perfect, and icecream was delicious !!! What more could I ask for?? This was a surprise for my husbands Birthday, and he WAS surprised !!! Most likely I will do this again !!
Phil J. - Baldwinsville, NY
Delivered on the day I chose. And the packaging was incredible, I ordered ice cream and it unfortunately sat in the Az heat for 2 hrs, but was still frozen solid! My dad said the ice cream was great!
Henry T. - Tucson, AZ
Everything was fantastic! From the ordering, to the shipping, to the packaging and delivery and of course, the most important thing, the taste, it was a great experience.
Linda A. - Morristown, NJ
Arrived in time and wonderfully packaged. Was very much enjoyed by a cancer patient.
Joseph P. - Columbus, OH
This was a gift. Delivery to friends with a western exposure front steps. But ice cream was still frozen solid. They raved over each selection. I asked if that were really true because I have not had this ice cream before. Definitely loved it all. So I just ordered some for myself.
The A. - Nyssa, OR
Everything. Best ice cream we have ever tasted.
Thomas G. - Sacramento, CA
Delivery on time for my birthdate today. Brings back part of my childhood, growing up on the Lower eastside
Yvonne C. - Somerset, NJ