Italian Cookie Tray - 5 lbs
From
Ferrara Bakery
( 4.7)
With secret recipes that span three centuries, this fifth generation family-owned bakery continues to handcraft Italian desserts from the same location in NYC’s Little Italy since 1892.
Ferrara’s delicate & buttery cookies are the perfect companion with a cup of coffee. Using secret Old World recipes that are over 100 years old, Ferrara bakes perfect rainbow (tricolori), pignoli (almond-flavored cookies studded with pine nuts), fudge-swirled cookies & more.
More Details
Each package includes 5 lbs of cookies (approximately 100 cookies) in a variety of flavors and styles including:
- Rainbow Cookies
- Soft Pignoli
- Fudge
- Sandwich Cookies
- Coconut
- Half Moon
- Raspberry Drop
Instructions / Storage
The Cookie Tray can be refrigerated for up to a week or frozen for up to 6 months. Once
opened, store in an airtight container and serve at room temperature.
Shipping Details
- Items are prepared fresh and shipped directly from the shop
- Ferrara Bakery ships Monday-Thursday of each week
- No deliveries Saturday, Sunday or Monday
- Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
- Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
- Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.
Recommended for you
More from New York
( 4.7) Ferrara Bakery REVIEWS
Quality cookies and Panettone delivered in perfect shape, on time, and delicious. Have ordered these as a gift several times; they are always well received.
Eileen L. - Charlotte, NC
08/21/19
All arrived in perfect condition, with great instructions. Delicious too! Worth every penny since I cannot get these items in Florida.
Gerri R. - Vero Beach, FL
04/02/19
Gelato was delicious and packed extremely well. Survived June in Phoenix!! Can’t wait to order more!
Amy L. - Mesa, AZ
06/18/19
Sent it to my son for his birthday. His favorite dessert is tiramisu. He told me it was the best tiramisu he’d ever had!
Nancy A. - Raleigh, NC
07/01/19
The cake came on time and it was delicious! It was semi-frozen and I just needed to place it on the counter before serving.
Lisa S. - Orrs Island, ME
08/18/19
Ordered this for my bro & sis-in-law anniversary; they are chocolate lovers and raved about this cake!
Frederic S. - New Boston, NH
09/11/19
Arrived at the designated time, the product maintained its freshness… It was still frozen when it arrived. And the Cake was delicious. My daughter enjoyed it with friends for her birthday! It even came with candles!
Dolores B. - Pittsford, NY
10/04/19
I was so excited that I was able to order a dessert from my very favorite 'happy place' in Little Italy. And more that- it was a present for a very dear friend.
Jenn E. - Durham, NC
09/10/19
I ordered gelato and it was shipped during a hot spell and it arrived in perfect condition and was so delicious my guests and I thoroughly enjoyed every morsel!
Jocelyn B. - Nashua, NH
07/08/19
Easy to order & had choice of delivery dates to the west coast! Arrived exactly on time and I was notified when it was shipped and when it arrived!
Louise K. - Redlands, CA
10/17/19
Everything was fresh, shipped quickly! Everyone loved the cookies. Everything was spot on!
Sherry D. - Norwich, NY
10/17/19
It was fantastic. Arrived in great frozen condition. Everyone loved them!
Lori H. - Pickens, SC
10/16/19
I sent it to my mother for her 91st birthday. She was thrilled with the cake taste and she said the presentation was very nice.
Carole H. - Tarentum, PA
10/09/19
I love the fact that you can find items from anywhere across the country. I live in Texas and a lot of the things I love from growing up in CT and NY they just don't have here or the quality is not good. Honestly, everything was great of the things I have ordered.
Maria A. - San Antonio, TX
10/02/19
We can not find struffoli in Virginia and it is my husband’s holiday favorite. Thanks to Goldbelly, we can have the BEST struffoli and Italian cookies from Ferrara’s shipped right to our door!
Susan K. - Nellysford, VA
11/27/19
The chocolate truffle cake was to die for - excellent!
Jane M. - Thornwood, NY
11/25/19
"My husband, a native New Yorker, was delighted! Seems they just don't make those pastries right in western rural Pennsylvania! In addition, when he lived in NYC, Ferrara's was actually the bakery he used to visit! The pastries are just as he remembered, and he enjoyed them very much!"
Lori D. - Jeannette, PA
12/10/19
"It was perfect. I care for my mom she is 92 with a brain tumor. I could not get to the city for vacation to get her favorite cakes. Goldbelly came through for our last holiday with her. Thank you oh so much."
Teresa C. - Sauquoit, NY
12/24/19
A special treat for those of us who grew up with these treats, but can not find them where we live now.
Rocchina C. - Sonoma, CA
01/19/20
Easy to order. Recipient received it on time. The recipient loved it - that's the only thing that mattered! Made his birthday extra special.
Mike S. - Manalapan, NJ
01/22/20
Always delicious and decadent desserts!
Susan M. - Chambersburg, PA
12/02/19
The cheesecake was delicious. Although it arrived frozen, the taste and texture said otherwise. Would order again.
Michelle E. - Chester, NY
12/02/19
It was easy to order. The chocolate cake was packed well in ice. It was delicious and it was delivered on time.
Donna W. - Gloucester City, NJ
01/23/20
Delivered in beautiful condition. Tastes fantastic. Will definitely order again.
Michelle B. - Port Charlotte, FL
01/22/20
Everything not only tasted fabulous, it arrived right on time for Thanksgiving! Wonderful!
Kimberley H. - Dunlap, IL
12/02/19
The cheesecake, tiramisu, and chocolate cake were all spectacular - simple ingredients, done the right way. A bit pricey but it seems all of the ingredients is good stuff - and these days a lot of stuff is poor-quality. If you want a consistently excellent bakery, Ferrara Bakery is a good choice - and that’s based on a number of orders I’ve placed over a number of years.
John M. - Lisle, IL
12/19/19
I am in seventh heaven. I ordered strufoli (honey balls) and pignoli (pine nut) cookies, from Ferrara's in NYC. It's two of the desserts my mother used to make when I was a child and a taste of old times is a good experience. They both were almost exactly what she made. Good service, received them exactly when promised. They were shipped well packed, saran wrapped tightly, so no broken cookies or messy strufoli.
Terry W. - Hendersonville, NC
12/19/19
I love the ability to get excellent Ferrara Bakery cookies sent all the way from NYC to California. They were packaged well for freshness.
Kathleen C. - Campbell, CA
12/19/19
It was easy and quick. I may not be in NYC any more but I can still get goodies from Ferrara my favorite bakery.
Janet P. - Rochester, NY
12/18/19
The pastry was delivered on time and completely frozen. After thawing, the canolis and sfogliatelle were absolutely delicious.
Isabelle M. - Bartonsville, PA
12/02/19
I ordered this special cheesecake for a friend who has just had breast cancer surgery. She was overwhelmed with this particular gift! I will be using Goldbelly in the future for more gifts, it was an extreme success!!! It was delivered right when you said it would be!
Deborah R. - Ridgefield, CT
12/18/19
That Cheesecake was “the Best” I’ve ever tasted and I’ve tasted quite a few!
Robert F. - York, PA
12/04/19
Absolutely wonderful.
The cookies were delicious
The tiramasu was excellent
I will continue to order
Carol M. - Indianapolis, IN
11/30/19
Perfect the mascarpone cake is a winner . Everybody love it!
Carole Z. - Rancho Santa Fe, CA
12/07/19
My husband, a native New Yorker, was delighted. Seems they just don't make those pastries right in western rural Pennsylvania! In addition, when he lived in NYC, Ferrara's was actually the bakery he used to visit! The pastries are just as he remembered, and he enjoyed them very much.
Lori D. - Jeannette, PA
12/08/19
My stepfather said it was the best he had ever had. My mother, who usually skips pastry, could not resist and loved it as well.
Tony R. - Lawrenceville, GA
12/11/19
The cookies were so fresh and the flavor was true to what I remember from cookies buying cookies in Little Italy. They were excellent.
Yolanda R. - New York, NY
12/26/19
My daughter-in-law is Italian and for her birthday I sent some of your Italian layer cookies. They were a hit!
Mara R. - Chicago, IL
12/11/19
Last year I ordered a 4lb tray of cookies shipped to Florida and my family loved them. Cookies were delicious and fresh. This session I sent Cookies and Struffoli.
THE M. - Port St Lucie, FL
12/26/19
Having the ability to order foods that you've either had before & realllllly enjoyed, ya know.... foods that evoke great memories....OR trying something new that just looks so good, like you can almost smell the amazing aromas through your phone.... Is such an awesome treat !!!! I don't have to travel hundreds of miles to eat something that brings me back to another time in my life.... You'd be nuts not to try it out.... honestly, it's great for a fun gift or just because !!!!
Mr F. - East Longmeadow, MA
12/20/19
Loved the Rainbow cookies and order as a yearly tradition..
Sally S. - Salisbury, NC
12/28/19
The pastries were still cold all the way from New York. I will order from Goldbelly again.
Yvonne C. - Carrollton, TX
12/27/19
Arrived on time in perfect condition and was delicious ! Would definitely recommend to family and friends.
Frances C. - South Glens Falls, NY
12/22/19
I loved ordering through Goldbelly because it's so convenient and easy to send to someone for a gift. I ordered Italian cookies from Ferrara Bakery for the 1st time ever and wow they were delicious! The cookies were so fresh and packaged neatly, none of them were broken. The order arrived exactly on time, too. I will definitely buy these again.
Aimee P. - Winthrop Harbor, IL
12/26/19
Ferrara is absolutely the best. I love their baked goods absolutely amazing.
Janet P. - Rochester, NY
12/26/19
I loved being able to surprise my parents with delicious goodies that they haven't had in over 10 years!
Scott R. - Ponderay, ID
12/26/19
Ferrara's Cookies were unbelievably wonderful. Shipping was perfect and delivery was on time. My only regret is not ordering more.
Dennis I - Bellmore, NY
12/22/19
Everything arrived in perfect condition & very well packaged. The cookies delicious & fresh even after traveling all the way to the west coast. Now I won’t be so homesick this Christmas having some of the goodies we’ve grown up with.
Dolores J. - Pendleton, OR
12/24/19
Everything was fresh and arrived intact. I was concerned that there would be broken cookies. Kudos to ur company for your expertise in delivering a good product.
Joe H. - St Johns, FL
12/25/19
The cookies arrived perfect and fresh. They were so delicious just like when we lived in NY. I will definitely order again. I ordered the multiple assortment in the 4 pound box to eat and share.
Elizabeth C. - Cary, NC
12/25/19
Great assortment and all cookies were outstanding.
Gene R. - Hoover, AL
12/30/19
This is my second order from them and we enjoy the cookies very much. Much better than Carlos bakery butter cookies that we have ordered in the past.
Colleen M. - Highland Lakes, NJ
01/07/20
I have been ordering from Ferrara's for more than twenty years. Probably will never stop - getting good Italian desserts is impossible in the South....................but even when I lived in NJ, I would order since is was easier and more convenient to order than to make a trip into NYC!
Barbara A. - Ponte Vedra Beach, FL
11/26/19
Amazing, absolutely delicious. Best tiramisu I ever had.
Quiniya M. - Fort Wayne, IN
01/21/20
The cannoli cream was excellent, and the chocolate shells were tasty.
Sal P. - Lancaster, PA
11/27/19
I love panettone, and this gave me chance to mail order some.
Barbara B. - Kissimmee, FL
01/14/20
Food was delivered as fresh as if I bought it at the shop!!! Thanks for a job well done!! 😍😍😍😍
David M. - South Lyon, MI
11/25/19
Bake that home these sfoigliatelle were just as delicious as in the store.. They are very flaky and Oh that orange/ricotta flavor brings back memories!
Jim D. - New Providence, NJ
11/25/19
My rainbow cookies were fresh & homemade and delicious 😋! Didn’t feel like it came from far away. Reminds me of my childhood. Thank you ☺️
Carmela W. - Urbandale, IA
01/14/20
The cake was fantastic. I had sent it to my dad for his birthday, and he loved it. It was delivered the day before, which was perfect and ready to go when it was time to sing Happy Birthday.
Kevin H. - Lake City, FL
02/06/20
Excellent delivery and the cookies were out of this world!
Laurie H. - Senecaville, OH
02/07/20
I already have recommended Goldbelly. Everyone at our event LOVED the cookies from Ferrara's and loved that I got cookies from Ferrara's for an event in Florida.
Debbie P. - Coral Springs, FL
02/07/20
Very nice almond taste and chocolate!
Holly L. - Martinez, CA
02/09/20
Delivered right on time and delicious!
Jean M. - Manchester, NH
02/15/20
Fantastic !!!!!! I followed the heat up directions & stuffed the Lobster Tail with cream. Delicious!!!!! It's sweet but not overpowering - just right. I saw the advertisement on The Best Thing I Ever Ate. Chef Alex voted it the Best from Ferrera Bakery.
Connie C. - Gibson, LA
02/17/20
Excellent product and easy to order. Delivery was on time and the package was very well wrapped.
Deborah F. - Reedville, VA
02/17/20
The item was well packaged and the cold pack maintained the appropriate temperatures as well as the delivery was timely.
Vincent P. - Melbourne Beach, FL
02/17/20
Order and perfect delivery.
On time, nothing broken or defrosted.
Thanks
Linda W. - Jacksonville, AR
02/16/20
Perfect! Cake was beautiful, delicious, carefully packaged!
Michael A. - Brick, NJ
02/18/20
Beautiful cake. Tastes great.
Bud F. - Los Angeles, CA
02/18/20
Everything went fabulously! Shipping right on time, product frozen upon arrival product devoured following baking! Amazing! I shall return.
Lynne W. - Corolla, NC
03/02/20
Ease of ordering and prompt delivery. The product was fresh and did not disappoint.
Yvonne K. - Whitmore Lake, MI
03/05/20
I appreciate that the product arrived on time. 10* service!
Teressa c. - Cary, NC
03/04/20
Great cake that came on time love goldbelly
Lynn W. - Sandia Park, NM
03/10/20
I made a mistake with the order. Emailed Goldbelly and was responded to. immediately. Problem solved in 5 minutes. Shipment arrived on time with the correct amount of product.
Mary V. - Winchester, MA
03/09/20
Oh my gosh, these Sfogliatellas are amazing. Without a doubt, all I can say is these are probably the best I have ever had in my 86 years. After baking them for 30 to 40 minutes, they come out with a beautiful slightly crispy crust and filled with delectable filling. I wish I could take them with me when I pass from this earth.
Charles S. - New Port Richey, FL
03/17/20
Delivery was fast, product in box came perfect not crushed, and when I called for help the woman was so kind.
Misty h. - Erie, PA
03/18/20
