TODAY ONLY: Package of 2 Original Plain Cheesecakes for the price of 1

Named “Chicago’s Finest,” Eli’s cheesecakes are slow baked with the finest local ingredients for the best flavor and texture, then topped with hand-decorated designs. This is THE original Eli’s Cheesecake. Baked in their signature crisp all-butter shortbread cookie crust, this creamy, rich cheesecake is simply the best around!

More Details

This package includes 2 Original Plain Cheesecakes

  • Each 9" cheesecake is approximately 3 lbs. and can serve 16 people
  • Each cheesecake arrives in a branded gift box. Perfect for a gift!


Cream Cheese (Pasteurized Milk and Cream, Cheese Culture, Salt, Carob Bean Gum, Guar Gum), Sugar, Sour Cream (Cultured Nonfat Milk and Cream, Corn Starch, Whey, Guar Gum, Carrageenan, Carob Bean Gum, Enzymes), Egg, Wheat Flour, Butter (Cream, Salt), Powdered Sugar (Sugar, Corn Starch), Modified Corn Starch, Vanilla Extract, Egg Whites, Salt, Soy Lecithin. No Artificial Trans Fat. Any trans fat in this product is naturally occurring in the pure dairy products we use, such as milk, butter and cream cheese.

Instructions / Storage

  • Cheesecakes are made fresh, frozen and shipped with dry ice, which may thaw partially or fully during transit
  • Upon arrival, place in the refrigerator to thaw, or in the freezer to store
  • Cheesecakes can be stored in the fridge for 5 days or in the freezer for up to 6 months
  • To serve, place the cheesecake in the refrigerator to thaw overnight, and then at room temperature for 2 hours before serving
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Eli’s Cheesecakes ships Monday through Wednesday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Illinois


This was a surprise for my parents for their 52nd wedding anniversary.. they were shocked by the gift, lived the packaging and were especially thrilled with the cheesecake itself.. they have been raving about it!
William D. - Whitinsville, MA
Still frozen when arrived. Tasted great.
Corinne H. - Laurel, MD
My mother said the cheesecake bites were delicious.
Fatemeh S. - Lakewood, CO
The taste and presentation was superb!!
Lizzie L. - Wichita, KS
It arrived quickly, was packed well with dry ice, and tasted delicious.
Denise C. - Lansing, IL
The cheesecake was great!
Travis p. - Atlanta, GA
Purchased for my gf's Birthday. She loves it and says that it is the best cheesecake she's ever eaten.
Desiree H. - Vista, CA
Sent to a good friend across the country for his birthday..he loved it and will share with friends..very happy!
James B. - Gary, IN
The many choices that are presented for a person to order. The ease of ordering and how quick the order came.
Susan T. - Galesburg, IL
Cake arrive fast and frozen solid with plenty of dry ice. Eli’’s has always been my favorite and I love being able to get it delivered fast n fresh!
Joe B. - Johnston, IA
Variety of choices, easy order, fast delivery.
Jean A. - Finley, ND
The size of the mini pies. Also liked the selection of 4 apple and 4 cherry.. The pies were frozen /could go straight to freezer until appropriate time.
Margaret F. - Phoenicia, NY
It had good texture and taste.
Carol M. - Manteca, CA
My apple cheescakes from Goldbelly, regardless of individual shop they came from, have always come on time, been exactly as described, were packaged perfectly and securely, and were I guess reasonably priced (not knowing actually what cheescakes that feed 8-10 people should cost on average)
Keith H. - Valley Village, CA
Was very delicious and was delivered on time. Great Job.
Chloe D. - Williamsport, IN
On time delivery and sweets were great!
Gabriel V. - Miami, FL
Arrived quickly and in great condition. Person who received gift loved it.
Bella R. - Massapequa, NY
delivery on time, and the cheesecake was delicious.
Michael S. - Springfield, VA
Service was fast and the cheesecake was AMAZING!!
Melissa P. - Peoria, AZ
this DESSERT!!!! ordered it the first time because i had a gift card but it was a slippery slope because they're the best thing i've ever had and now i'm addicted.
Caroline H. - New York, NY
The vegan cheesecake squares garnered raves.
Julie-Anne F. - Darien, CT
the cheesecake was very good. I loved that it came already sliced, that was a big help!! it helped me not to cut uneven pieces.
Sagrario A. - Huntingdon Valley, PA
Everything from the moment I received my cheesecake! They are the best cheesecakes I have ever had! I have bought several of them, they are great!
Richard S. - Grants Pass, OR
The chocolate chip cheese cake that was gifted could not have been timed any better. My friends are avid cheese cake people and expressed to me that this cheese cake was even better than the pumpkin cheese cake which they truly love. It was delivered on time and this birthday gift exceeded their expectations. Thank you.
Don H. - Plant City, FL
Big hit! Plus the FedEx driver, Travis, went the extra mile and called me when having difficulty delivering to the address and made sure my daughter received her birthday cake! Beyond the call of duty ❤️
Megan B. - Mammoth Lakes, CA
Everything was packed well, arrived perfectly intact and cold! Just a great experience all around and my daughter was delighted.
Taylor C. - Zanesville, OH
I am happy to say everything about this experience went well. I had the strawberry cheesecake sent to my son for his birthday, since he couldn't spend the holidays with us because of covid. He shared it with his roommates and he told me it was a hit! He told me that it arrived on time and was packaged well. Yay! I will definitely be ordering from Goldbelly again!
Noble C. - Newcastle, WA
Easy, quick and the reports - this was a gift - are that the cake was delicious.
Maria S. - Mt Pleasant, SC
Everything! Ordering was easy, shipping was clear and predictable. Cheesecake was AMAZING!
Kelly T. - Crescent City, CA
The original cheesecake is pure heaven! I like the shortbread crust and the fact that the cheesecake is light and very creamy vs thick and almost crumbly like others. Eli’s, in my opinions is in a class all it’s own and is far superior to both Junior’s and The Cheesecake Factory.
Vicki S. - Barberton, OH
Wonderful cheesecake, delivery perfect. Still frozen. Family really enjoyed it for the 4th!!
Jacqueline B. - Middlebourne, WV
All of it! The product was excellent and the shipping info is great. I’ve ordered twice from Eli’s and will do so again. Great job!
Meghan Z. - Lansing, MI
The recipient loved the Cheesecake!!!
Jami F. - Bridgeport, WV
gobbly delicious goodness :)
Melissa A. - Edmonds, WA
Everything on Goldbelly's site and on the part of Eli's Cheesecake was perfection. It could not have been better.
Kristy B. - Lafayette, IN
While the cheesecake arrived 2 days late, that was likely an issue with the carrier. It was, however, still quite edible upon arrival and the packaging was reported to be still cold. I was very pleased with Goldbelly's quick response to me when, after seeing that it was going to be 2 days late, I emailed a question. Several employees were "right on it" and followed up promptly.
Katie E. - Midland, MI
Delivery was on the exact day and at a good time, food was fully intact. Food was great.
RICK O. - Denver, CO
Apparently once all was delivered, it was enjoyed. A gift to a hostess. So have no idea if it was good.
Dale F. - Rome, GA
Timely, fresh, fully met my expectations- thank you
Kimberly N. - Loleta, CA
Everything! Timing, packaging and quality were top notch!
Barbara H. - Vero Beach, FL
Presentation & taste were top tier!
Brittney R. - Wichita, KS
Easy to order "on-line." Quick "turn-around" time. Delivered "on schedule," as promised! Very "nicely packed" and contents arrived intact! Reasonable prices! Excellent products! The delicious cheesecake definitely took me back to my "childhood memories" of Chicago!
Laura M. - American Canyon, CA
Website is user friendly. delivery was on time. cheese cake was excellent.
Adam B. - Mishawaka, IN
Arrived on time and the recipients said it was delicious!
Suzanne J. - Grand Junction, CO
The delivery was on time, was delivery looking delicious an was loved by all
Jeremy C. - Meridian, ID
Everything.....placement of order, communication of orders in transit, arrival was on time, and I'm happy to have my Thanksgiving pumpkin cheesecake well in advance.
Christine M. - Levittown, NY
Delivered on time and was delicious!
Andrew S. - Powell, OH
Sent a carrot cake to a friend for her birthday. She and her family loved it!
Jean C. - St Petersburg, FL
It was a gift. I have ordered this before and was told that it is delicious
Jordan B. - Valencia, CA
So close to Christmas and yet you guys were able to deliver as guaranteed I appreciate it very much.
Jane D. - Weymouth, MA
Easy to order, great communication about order status, prompt delivery. The recipient loved the special treats!
Marina M. - Springfield, MO
Cake arrived intact beautiful. I have not tasted it as yet as I am waiting to serve for Christmas dinner.
Frances W. - Hiddenite, NC
Great sale. Cheesecake was received frozen and packed well.
Michael G. - Tinley Park, IL
Everything was fabulous!! Delivered right on time. We got rave reviews from each gift recipient. I even ordered for myself and again it came on time and it was delicious!!
Christina H. - Kingston, MA
The cheesecake was delivered on time and they loved it.
Mr R. - Winter Garden, FL
Delivery was as stated and the food was packaged and presented as if purchased in person at the store.
Adah S. - McDonough, GA
Delivered right on time, cakes were perfectly chilled and recipients loved them.
Constance H. - San Francisco, CA
Selection of vegan desserts is good, shipping was reasonable and reliable.
Ian H. - Coral Springs, FL
Love the cheese cake and how friendly and stand behind your products
Betsy H. - Morgantown, WV
I sent chocolate vegan cheesecake as a gift and the recipient said it was delicious. Will order again and/or try another flavor.
Randee G. - Olympia, WA
Everything, Cheesecake was great, delicious and shipped on time
Tracey V. - Carver, MN
My sister loved the cheesecake I sent her family! Excellent customer service Thank you
Brenda H. - Plainville, MA
Great cheesecake sampler. All was great and rich. Shipped on time
Tracey V. - Carver, MN
Ordering was easy and the cheesecake was DELICIOUS.
Stefania R. - Detroit, MI
The cheesecake was delicious! Great variety, well packaged, very tasty.
HARRIET G. - Oceano, CA
MaryAnn D. - Monroe Township, NJ
Everything Delivery was on time, the Aww factor Delicious as well.
Bryan M. - Tacoma, WA
Cheesecake Cuties were nicely packaged and arrived on time. I wouldn't hesitate to send these as a gift sometime!
Amy M. - St Charles, IL
It i it was shipped on time and arrived on the time you said it would. Since this was a birthday Cake it was very much appreciated that it was shipped as promised. I hear it’s delicious too.
Skye W. - Rio Rancho, NM
I just finished talking with the recipient of the cheesecake and she informed me the cheesecake was totally fantastic. They celebrated her birthday in grand fashion. Thank you so much for the excellent & timely service.
Carolyn H. - Treasure Island, FL
Delivered on time, perfectly packaged and while this was for my husband's birthday, we appreciate that proceeds support efforts in Ukraine thorugh World Central Kitchen, an organization we support! The cheesecakes themselves were delicious. The chocolate was rich and not overpowering of the cheesecake, cheesecake being my husband's favorite.
Jill S. - San Leandro, CA
By far the best cheesecake I've ever had hands down!
Lisa C. - Biddeford, ME
Delivery was on time and the cheesecake was delicious!
Martha S. - South Holland, IL
When our first cheesecake came scrunched, we called Goldbelly. They did a marvelous job. Got us our credit. We got the next cheesecake on time and in perfect condition. Great service!
Jean M. - Dallas, TX
The item arrived on the day I selected. It was packaged very nice and secure. This was a valentine gift for my wife. She loved it. I highly recommend Eli Cheesecake Company. They're going into my favorites.
Richard W. - Broken Bow, OK
Easy order. Arrived fast. Just as promised. Best of all the kids loved them Really loved them
karalyn b. - Akron, OH