A classic creamy pie just like your grandmother used to make. Everyone surely will enjoy this family favorite brought back by popular demand.

More Details

This package serves 8 people and includes a 9" Buttermilk Pie in a branded gift box.

Ingredients

Wheat Flour (Unenriched, Unbleached), Lard, Water, Salt, Dextrose, Baking Soda) (Wheat), White Granulated Sugar, Buttermilk, Eggs, Canola Oil, Flour, King Arthur, Unsalted Butter, Vanilla Flavor, Salt

Produced in a facility that uses peanuts, tree nuts, eggs, soy, milk & wheat.

Instructions / Storage

  • Refrigerate or freeze upon arrival
  • Pie may be refrigerated for up to 3 days or frozen for up to 2 months
  • Take out of the freezer 1 to 2 hours before reheating

To Serve

  • Preheat oven to 350 degrees and heat for 15 – 20 minutes
  • Let cool before serving
  • Apply garnish of your choice and enjoy!
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Eilenberger’s Bakery ships Monday – Thursday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Texas

REVIEWS

The best pecan cake ever....
Mary P. - Pensacola, FL
01/21/20
The fruit cake was loaded with nuts and fruit - great tasting - we really enjoyed it!
Dorothy S. - Saint Leonard, MD
12/19/19
I have ordered from Eilenbergers for years, but my eyes are opened to many different foods now that I can order, thanks!
Jennifer W. - Tulsa, OK
12/07/19
Our fruitcake is very good.
Richard W. - Columbus, OH
12/08/19
The fruitcake was sweet and packed to the gills with pecans. Just barely enough batter to hold the fruitcake perfectly together. The fruitcake was delivered right on time as promised- in perfect condition.
kenneth w. - Ramsey, NJ
01/26/20
This is the best fruitcake in the world.
Lucy N. - Chama, NM
12/11/19
Delivered on time and tasted and looked great!
Jason R. - Greensboro, NC
12/11/19
Arrived ahead of time, was fresh and absolutely delicious.
Peggy M. - Maryville, TN
12/26/19
The fruit were not stale at all. Along with the nuts, it added a really satisfying crunch. I originally bought it for my husband because I don't really care for fruit cakes, but I am now a believer!
Charlotte J. - Custer, SD
12/27/19
Very positive experience with delivery. We love Eilenbergers and are a repeat customer. BEST pecan cakes ever!!!
Jennifer A. - Tomball, TX
12/25/19
Definitely the best fruitcake I’ve ever had.
Sharon C. - Garland, TX
11/16/19
The cakes were loaded with nuts and fruit. Very delicious.
Carolyn G. - Columbia, MS
01/12/20
Beautiful fruitcake, the fruit and nuts were very very generous. The cake was more dry than I would’ve liked.
Victoriana G. - Susanville, CA
01/12/20
Best fruitcake I have ever tasted, and it was packaged beautifully so it arrived in perfect condition
Charlotte R. - Modesto, CA
02/04/20
I ordered a Texas pecan fruit cake as a gift for my aunt. She loves it!
Janet D. - Hemet, CA
02/16/20
Quick delivery and delicious product
Barbara C. - Ballwin, MO
02/14/20
It is SO easy to order food and it comes on time.The fruit cake was a Birthday cake for my husband, and it was delicious.It was packed full of fruit and pecans.
Dennis N. - Johnstown, CO
02/24/20
Ordering process was easy and quick. Item arrived quickly. Fruitcake is wonderful
Christine K. - Hampstead, NH
03/09/21
The fruitcake was for my mom. She is 94 years old and has been wanting one for a long time. I surprised her with your fruitcake and she loved it !
Ann E. - Fairmont, WV
02/21/21
The fruitcake arrived days before I expected and is delicious! Whoopie pies arrived on day they were expected. Also fresh, and delicious. Will definitely order both again. Tamales will be my next order. Thank you.
Sammie T. - Haltom City, TX
02/12/21
The cake was the best I’ve had, fresh and just perfect.
Jacqueline C. - Charlestown, IN
02/07/21
I tried fruitcakes from 2 different bakeries, both were excellent. One took me back to my years stationed in Bavaria! I emailed them directly to let them know how thrilled I was. Shipping was as expected but, on the other hand, your tracking system was great! I will be using Goldbelly again. Maybe crab cakes from DC & Baltimore? Too many choices!
Mike K. - El Reno, OK
01/19/21
The candy was wonderful. I have never had such extravagant chocolates. Fast delivery.
Diane S. - Centre Hall, PA
01/09/21
Everything! I’m so happy with your company I can find places I’ve only dreamt of and you’ve made it possible! Thank you💝
Deborah P. - Storrs Mansfield, CT
01/03/21
Delivery was on time as expected. I purchased the fruit cake for my mom. The fruit cake is delicious. My mom is enjoying it.
Regina P. - Canal Winchester, OH
01/01/21
First time ordering for the holidays; food was excellent, would definitely recommend.
Sonya H. - Red Oak, VA
12/30/20
The item I ordered was delicious and I would definitely order from that shop and Goldbelly again. Shipping was extremely fast, actually a few days early.
Jessica J. - Moroni, UT
12/27/20
The items I ordered were DELICIOUS!
Kathleen G. - Alamogordo, NM
05/16/21
Prompt delivery of Eilenberger's fruitcake. Fresh and delicious! My friend was thrilled.
Jane J. - Amesbury, MA
05/02/21
Terrific pecan tasked and wonderful pecan pie!
Ginger M. - Houston, TX
04/17/21
Everything, from the order to receiving. Them there was the tasting PERFECT and DELICIOUS.
Barbara S. - Lehigh Acres, FL
03/31/21