Sea-Salted Caramel Swirl Cheesecake

Arrives after Memorial Day🇺🇸

Cotton Blues Cheesecake Company ships its famous cheesecakes nationwide on Goldbelly! These cheesecakes are rich and luscious on their own, but even better when swirled with sea-salted caramel.

Cotton Blues is a beloved Hattiesburg, Mississippi, restaurant, a family-owned destination renowned for its Southern hospitality and its menu of down-home Southern goodness. Pastry chef Shaun Davis’ magnificent cheesecakes, however, are what put it on the map. Cotton Blues’ cheesecakes are handmade with only seven ingredients (including Philadelphia cream cheese and pure vanilla extract), and they clock in at four pounds each. They’re rich and luscious on their own, but even better when swirled with blueberry, strawberry, or sea-salted caramel.

More Details

This package serves 8-10 people and includes a 10" Sea-Salted Caramel Swirl Cheesecake

  • Each Cheesecake weighs 4 lbs.

Ingredients

Philadelphia Cream Cheese, Sour Cream, Fresh Whole Eggs, Graham Cracker Crumbs, Sugar, Unsalted Butter, Pure Vanilla Extract. Scratch-made swirling sauces, if applicable.

Instructions / Storage

  • Cheesecakes ship frozen with dry ice
  • Do Not remove dry ice with bare hands
  • Upon arrival, place in the freezer
  • May be kept frozen for up to a year
  • Refreezing after thawing is not recommended

To Serve

  • Thaw in the refrigerator, unwrapped, for about 5 hours or until fully thawed.
  • Serve chilled for best results!
  • Refrigerate unused portions for up to 5 days
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Cotton Blues Cheesecake Company ships Monday – Thursday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Mississippi

REVIEWS

Came perfectly in 116 degree weather. Was packed in a fitted foam cooler with dry ice. It was simply delicious. And shipped on time both times we ordered. Absolutely delicious.
Lee B. - Lake Havasu City, AZ
07/30/20
The shipping was on time. The food was excellent. My friends thought it was the best cheesecake ever. It was well packed and still very cold or frozen.
Byron H. - Hot Springs, SD
08/19/20
Fast delivery! Cheesecake was FABULOUS AND DELICIOUS & WILL ORDER AGAIN!
Virginia L. - Hutto, TX
02/21/21
Great communication. Great packaging. Great delivery service. Extraordinary cheesecake!
Gregory M. - Corolla, NC
03/14/21
Delivery was on-time but I wish it was overnight like Amazon! Sea salt cheesecake is AMAZING!!!
Susan G. - Woodbury, NY
03/05/21
It was delicious and the way it was packed was super. This town has a complicated mail delivery system. I was worried that the cheesecake would be ruined by 2 overnights in the PO, but it was perfect. Nice job.
Janice H. - Jackson, WY
02/15/21
Ease of site to use; fantastic variety of foods; bucket list offerings; tried and true vendors; on time; safe and sure packing; best cheesecake I''ve ever tasted; 2nd order; will order again!
Rebecca G. - Lanett, AL
02/06/21
Perfection! From the ease of shopping. Updating me on the order shipping, tracking the order, and then its arrival. Not a crumb out of place! And talk about fresh!!! It was so special to make a birthday wish come true with a bakery order that was shipped from over 5,000 miles away. It’s my go-to order-place for gifts!
Barbara L. - Bellevue, WA
02/06/21
Cheesecake was in excellent condition. Box inside of a bigger box... really protected it. Dry ice kept it frozen. The blueberry swirl made it even better (gasp) than my mom's cheesecakes.
Annette B. - Cottage Grove, TN
01/29/21
It arrived on time. The packaging was wonderful and my son said it was the BEST Cheesecake he ever had!!
justin S. - Lakewood, CO
01/25/21
The cheesecake arrived on time and was FAST!! Also...the cheesecake was FABULOUS!! Best cheesecake I’ve ever had!! Thank you 😊
Mary P. - Laurel, MS
01/16/21
I have sent two cheesecakes to family members, who said that they were the best ever!
Sheila D. - Westwood, MA
01/07/21
From ordering to shipping to taste - worth every penny! As recommended in the details of the cheesecake I ordered 3 days before I wanted it delivered and it showed up on time. This cheesecake was a birthday cake for my boyfriend and although I'm not a cheesecake-lover like him, I LOVED this cake. The flavor was perfectly balanced and it was so rich that a small piece was all you needed. 10/10 would order again.
Marryssa P. - Victorville, CA
01/22/21
Totally happy with the whole order and delivery process. And the cheesecake is the best I've ever ordered.
Kirk C. - Titusville, FL
04/26/21
Fast delivery of Cotton Blues cheesecake. The best cheesecake I've had in a long while. Arrived frozen and perfect!
Luanne F. - Prescott, AZ
05/03/21
The delivery and cheesecake were on time. The cheesecake was outstanding.
Bryan H. - Mishawaka, IN
07/25/21
On time, and was delicious
Colt S. - Sallisaw, OK
07/25/21
Easy to order. Delivered on time and in perfect condition.
Vannessa I. - Glasgow, KY
07/18/21
There were so many different varieties and quality products. The delivery was on time and the cakes were in perfect conditions.
Mr./Mrs. K. - Hattiesburg, MS
07/19/21
Cheesecakes delivered frozen and exactly when promised.
Barry B. - Boca Raton, FL
06/20/21
Everything, on time shipping, great quality product.
Richard K. - Farmington, CT
06/18/21
Delivered on time and is delicious according the person I sent it to,
Dottie H. - Deland, FL
05/17/21
Fast shipping, arrived on the eta date. Wrapped well, no damage !
Chelsia Z. - Palmdale, CA
05/17/21
Delivery was perfect and everyone loved the cheesecake
Tanya W. - Middleburg, FL
05/12/21
Packaged well and cheesecake was delicious!
Cindy C. - Los Angeles, CA
06/13/21
Delivery was exactly on time and packaging perfect. My Cotton Blues Cheesecake was solid frozen and packaged very well. The cheesecake is excellent.
Vici E. - Fayetteville, GA
09/07/21
Excellent! Family absolutely LOVES the Strawberry Swirl Cheesecake. This is my 3rd order. I HIGHLY recommend it.
RAYMOND B. - Parkville, MD
08/30/21
Delivery of product was efficient and packaging was perfect which resulted in the cheesecake being received frozen. Overall wonderful experience.
Joann F. - Southfield, MI
08/17/21
The delivery was a day later than expected, but still well in advance of the holiday. And the cheesecake of course was good.
Helen J. - Fairfield, CA
07/07/21
Couldn’t be more pleased! Your service made a special day even more special!
Robin V. - Virginia Beach, VA
11/01/21
Arrived on time & Was SO TASTY & FRESH!
Angela c. - Wasilla, AK
10/31/21
Delivered on time. I am 80 years old and my husband 77. Both agree best cheesecake we have ever had and we have had a lot of cheesecake. Even our cat loves it.
Karen G. - Crescent City, CA
10/24/21
Delivered on the day it was supposed to! And all was amazing❤️
Bela R. - Glenwood Springs, CO
10/23/21
Great cheesecake, perfect delivery!
Jackie M. - Cornelius, NC
10/30/21
Cheesecakes arrived timely, still with a little dry ice.
Sycile M. - Corpus Christi, TX
10/14/21
The cheesecake arrived solidly frozen and shipped with two dry ice packs for added protection. Great Sweet Potato Cheesecake for fans of the traditional Southern pie!
Diane S. - Fort Bragg, CA
10/09/21
Delivered when scheduled.The cheesecake is huge! I forgot how NY is..lol I’ve already recommended Goldbelly..
Ali F. - San Leandro, CA
10/05/21
Great cheesecake and delivery.
Winsett C. - Feasterville Trevose, PA
10/24/21
Shipping exactly on time; good were very well wrapped; I had a question and the online chat worked well and answered my question quickly.
Kerstin F. - Rancho Cordova, CA
09/21/21
On time as always and packed well to prevent spoiled food.
Jason S. - Syracuse, UT
09/20/21
The Goldbelly site is Amazing! Very easy to navigate, many options and if you have a problem the Customer Service is off the chain! They go above and beyond for your satisfaction and resolving of any issues!! Yummy site!!
Paul D. - Pittsburgh, PA
09/17/21
The delivery and my cheesecake was wonderful as always.
Linda C. - Colorado Springs, CO
09/05/21
All went well. Delivered on Time. Cheesecake best ever.
Debbie B. - Pelahatchie, MS
11/22/21
The cheesecake arrived very quickly and perfectly frozen!
Stephen M. - Biloxi, MS
11/21/21
Easy to order, easy to choose delivery and excellent product!!!
John L. - Galt, CA
11/15/21
It was delivered on time for my sons Birthday and he and his friends loved it !
Zayan A. - Storrs, CT
11/11/21
ordering was quick and delivery was ahead of schedule. Arrived beautiful and frozen with dry ice still in box
Teresa D. - West Monroe, LA
11/06/21
Everything was great. Shipped on time and even customer service reached out when there was an issue but it was quickly resolved.
La P. - Chicago, IL
11/08/21
Absolutely delicious cheesecake
Vicki B. - Tuckerton, NJ
12/05/21
What didn't , everything was delicious. Best cheesecake I've had hands down you offer a lifetime membership? I kid i kid, thanks for creating such a great cheesecake.
Patrick C. - Fort Calhoun, NE
11/30/21
Packaging was primo but cheesecake was more than primo!!!
Colleen M. - Salt Lake City, UT
11/28/21
My order was delivered on time and the cheesecake was creamy and Carmel saltiness as described
Chris B. - Sunbury, PA
11/28/21
Food was very very delicious! Definitely ordering again!!!
Cadisha A. - Brooklyn, NY
11/27/21
Cake was delicious and arrived in a timely and well packed way.
Beth M. - Newland, NC
11/27/21
The ordering process was simple. Shipping was quick and excellent! Pies arrived frozen. Great service! Fabulous cheesecakes!!
Katie J. - Lafayette, LA
11/23/21
The whole process was great I have already recommended to some of my family and friends
Kimra J. - Tucson, AZ
11/22/21
Informed me of delivery delays - they were slight and delivery remained prompt.
John C. - New York, NY
11/02/21
Best cheesecake ever!! Always incredible.
Richard W. - Garland, TX
11/22/21
Cotton Blues never disappoints. Awesome service, awesome cheesecakes!
Hortense N. - Wilmington, NC
11/22/21
The product was very high quality will definitely use gold belly again
Vianne R. - Pflugerville, TX
11/24/21
The cake was awesome. The entire family loved it.
Kim E. - Martinsburg, WV
11/26/21
The desserts I have ordered are always fresh & delicious, I have told my family and friends to try Gold Belly they won't be disappointed!
Cynthia N. - Rochester, NY
11/28/21
The shipping and packing were excellent. The cake arrived in a sturdy inner box. Delivery was on time. The cake itself was the best tasting cheesecake I ever had.
Chloe V. - New York, NY
12/05/21
Recipient really enjoyed what I sent to her. Order was very delicious and whole family enjoyed it. Quality product Received in a timely manner. Communication was great.
Mary Y. - Big Cove Tannery, PA
12/07/21
Order arrived when expected, and everything was good according to people who received it.
Mark L. - Peoria, AZ
12/11/21
Description of items, delivery. And yeah, the feedback was really good because several people said they ordered it again and I would totally order it again. Plus, wow, this is a lot of cheesecake for the $$.
Tana T. - Chatham, IL
12/12/21
The whole process went very well. It was easy to navigate your website, and find what I was looking for. Then, the payment/delivery date process was equally easy and efficient. The cheesecake was delivered on time, packed very well in dry ice, and was absolutely fantastic.
Karen W. - Greeley, CO
12/14/21
I have purchased twice from Goldbelly and both times have had excellent products and great delivery of products. I will definitely continue to be a customer!
Barbara H. - Elkton, FL
12/20/21
Everything arrived on time and it was easy to select a delivery date. Oh and the food was great
Susan M. - Brewton, AL
12/20/21
Arrived well packed..on time and frozen solid..popped right into our freezer for a delicious Christmas dessert
Marsha I. - New Orleans, LA
12/20/21
On time. Recipients were delighted.
Heath J. - Cherryville, NC
12/23/21
The item was received when expected and process went smoothly. The cake itself is very good.
James B. - Culver City, CA
12/22/21
Cheesecake was excellent
alexa g. - Marlton, NJ
12/21/21
THE BEST CHEESE CAKE I HAVE EVER TASTED. I WILL ORDER AGAIN WHEN AVAILABLE. MERRY CHRISTMAS TO ALL.
Bruce L. - Indianapolis, IN
12/21/21
Product the best and service unbeatable
Betsy H. - Morgantown, WV
12/20/21
Easy to order and good to think that I'm supporting small businesses.
- ,
12/20/21
Delivery as expected. Product is exceptional. Arrived cold.
Darlene W. - Burbank, CA
12/19/21
The order process through Goldbelly was good, and the Cheesecake was delicious!
Benavides F. - Elkins, WV
01/11/22
Made it all the way to Hawaii, on time, as scheduled! And the recipient said the cheesecake was outstanding! Thank you!
Steve M. - Honolulu, HI
01/09/22
Shipment sent in timely manner. Customer service quick to respond. Food was delicious.
Jeanette C. - Visalia, CA
01/07/22
Loved that the cakes were well packed and still frozen
Monica M. - Chandler, AZ
01/03/22
Delivery and the cake were excellent
Matthew P. - Burbank, CA
01/02/22
Terrific selection of cheesecakes. Good prices. Appreciate the shipping notifications.
Jake G. - San Diego, CA
01/02/22
My brother in law was thrilled with the blueberry cheesecake!! Came right on time for his birthday!!
Tony P. - Hackettstown, NJ
01/01/22
Every time I order something from you guys, I have to say the experience is good. Going to different restaurants without leaving home is awesome. I have not ordered anything I didn't like.
Sandra D. - Englewood, OH
12/31/21
delivery communication and the gift was a wow.
mary g. - Raleigh, NC
12/28/21
The BEST cheesecake ever! Well packaged and shipped on time. Thank you.
Ryan W. - Waterford, MI
12/27/21
Cheesecake came on time for son’s birthday!
Aaron S. - Houston, TX
01/26/22
OMG, everything went beautifully!!! My order was so inexpensive, shipping free and it arrived exactly on time. I will use Goldbelly OFTEN from now on!
Cindy S. - West Chester, PA
01/19/22
Cheesecake was still frozen and delicious.
Jim R. - Canyon Lake, TX
01/17/22
Cheesecake was delicious, possibly the best I've ever had! It arrived quickly and was packaged well to avoid damage.
Max B. - Boise, ID
01/17/22
The cheesecake is absolutely delicious! Possibly the best I have ever had. It arrived quickly and it was packaged very well to avoid damage.
Max B. - Boise, ID
01/17/22
Delivered on time, no damage, excellent flavor quality.
John R. - Ellington, CT
01/16/22
Cheesecake was delicious!
Al/Teresa F. - Fredericksburg, VA
01/10/22
The item arrived in a timely manner and was still frozen!
Kalicia B. - Rayville, LA
01/02/22
Arrived on time and was packed well
Katie C. - Newport News, VA
04/20/22
Quality, packaging, taste - it was excellent in every way.
Trish W. - Pittsboro, NC
04/18/22
Delivery and the cake is delicious
Tracy H. - Newport News, VA
04/18/22
Both orders delivered on time for Easter Holiday. Well packed, email alerts on shipment and delivery. Cotton Blues Caramel Swirl Cheesecake was excellent - well packaged, high-quality ingredients. Highly recommend.
Kirk M. - Santa Cruz, CA
04/18/22
From ordering to delivery, outstanding!
Isaiah M. - Notre Dame, IN
04/18/22
Everything went well. Kept me up to date when it would be delivered and how to store it. Delicious cheese cake. A big hit for the family!!!!
Chris m. - Saugus, MA
04/18/22
Everything came on time. Cheesecakes were both good. And the cupcakes. Wonderful
Rosie P. - Tappahannock, VA
04/17/22
Easy ordering and excellent product
By G. - Milton, PA
04/17/22
Cotton Blues makes the best cheesecake I've ever had, hands down. I would have never had this delicious food experience (for lack of a less pretentious phrase) without Goldbelly.
Carlin K. - Pflugerville, TX
04/16/22
All went as planned, no problems.
Pamela F. - The Villages, FL
04/17/22
Everything from ordering to payment to shipping tracking. The multiple options of food is great.
Isabel A. - National City, CA
04/12/22
That cheesecake was the best ever!
Karen M. - Winston Salem, NC
04/05/22
Even though delivery was delayed a day, after sitting outside all day, my cheesecakes were still cold when I arrived home that evening. These cheesecakes are the bomb! I won't eat any other brand.
Sycile M. - Corpus Christi, TX
04/04/22
It was delivered as you stated on line & my friend enjoyed it for his birthday
JOE Hu - Kailua, HI
03/29/22
Great customer service and prompt shipping and delivery. Thank you.
Renee K. - Chandler, AZ
03/28/22
Customer service phone call and the packaging of the product
John V. - Bullhead City, AZ
03/28/22
Everybody liked the cheesecake. I'll have to buy another for myself.
Carmen G. - Cincinnati, OH
03/21/22
Perfect
Fred W. - Ridgecrest, CA
03/21/22
Delivery is excellent! The pies are frozen and packed very well. The cheesecake from Blue Cotton was divine.
Michele C. - Inver Grove Heights, MN
03/13/22
BEST CHEESECAKE EVER, PACKAGED PERFECTLY, ALREADY SLICED WITH WRAPPING BETWEEN EACH SLICE, EXPECTED TO WORK TO SLICE IT, WISH EVERYONE WOULD SEND PIES OUT THIS WAY AND DELIVERED ON TIME, NOW IF THEY COULD MAKE A DIET VERSION I WOULD BE IN SEVENTH HEAVEN (KIDDING :-)...JONI
Joni R. - New York, NY
03/11/22
Cheesecake was outstanding
vicki a. - Seville, FL
03/07/22