Cookies - Choose Your Own 12 Pack

(Customer Reviews)

Choose your favorites from America’s favorite Chocolate Chip Cookie master!

After a successful career on Wall Street, Gina Celli decided to get into the cookie business, setting up shop near the heart of Colonial Williamsburg. Gina has been perfecting her cookie recipe for more than 20 years, and since opening in 2019 they’ve already attracted legions of fans. With her husband Anthony and daughter Kacie on board, it’s a true family business. Celli doesn’t cut any corners in her cookie recipes; she makes all of her cookies in small batches using high-end, organic ingredients like triple-milled French flour, Madagascar vanilla beans, super-premium chocolate and European butter.

More Details

This package includes your choice of 12 Cookies

  • Each cookie measures 4"
  • Italian Wedding Cookies measure 3"

Cookie Options Include

  • Chocolate Pecan – A favorite here down south, these chocolate chip cookies include pecans and chocolate chips.
  • Chocolate Chip – Celli’s iconic chocolate chip cookie infused with a ton of semisweet chocolate.
  • Chocolate Sugar – Featuring a rich cocoa flavor and melt-in-your-mouth texture dusted with sugar.
  • White Chocolate Cranberry Sea Salt – White chocolate and cranberry cookies with sea salt are perfect for the non-chocolate lover in your life.
  • Dark Chocolate Walnut – Dark chocolate chip cookie with walnuts.
  • Dark Chocolate Coconut – Dark chocolate cookies infused with coconut.
  • Italian Wedding – A family recipe handed down, this cookie will amaze the senses.
  • White, Dark, & Semisweet Chocolate Chip – This cookie highlights white, dark and semisweet chocolate.
  • Milk Chocolate Caramel Sea Salt – A melt-in-your-mouth delight, milk chocolate, caramel, and sea salt.


Celli’s Chocolate Chips crafts every single cookie by hand using shared equipment that processes dairy, eggs, wheat, peanuts, tree nuts, and soy. While they do their very best to prevent cross-contamination, they are not an allergen-free bakery

Instructions / Storage

  • Cookies arrive ready to enjoy!
  • Enjoy them on the spot or freeze upon arrival to preserve freshness
  • Refrigeration is not recommended
  • May sit on countertop for 3 days
  • Freeze immediately upon arrival for up to a month
  • From frozen, thaw your cookies at room temperature or microwave for 10-15 seconds for fresh-from-the-oven goodness
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Celli’s Chocolate Chips ships Monday-Friday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Virginia


Bought the wedding cookies for my husband's birthday seeing they are his favorite! He LOVED them! Cookies were big and individually wrapped, just perfect!
David M. - Ray, MI
Cookies arrived extremely fast. Package in a lovely box and cookies were individually wrapped. Cookies were beyond delicious. Not only did everyone enjoy them, they said it reminded them of home. I will definitely order again.
Lisa E. - Malverne, NY
The food was shipped to me fast and the food was fresh!
Katherine D. - White Mountain Lake, AZ
The items were delivered right when they said they would. Very Very pleased with Goldbelly’s service.
- ,
Beautifully packaged. Item arrived safely and intact.
Angelique R. - Voorhees, NJ
Loved the cookies!
Patricia B. - Lansing, MI
Delivery was prompt, got to us just in time to be perfectly fresh on Christmas. Especially outstanding considering they came from clear across the country. The cookies themselves were incredible. Loved them!
Yamina S. - Kirkland, WA
Great options to choose from. Reliable shipping and delivery estimations!
- ,
The order was made simple & arrived on time!
Dr M. - Richmond, VA
These seriously are the BEST cookies EVER! We even shared some with our neighbors and they are now just as much in love with these cookies as we are! :)
Jen M. - Ray, MI
Cookies were awesome with just the right amount of pecans. They came in three separate packages -- helps keep cookies fresh and makes gifting easier.
Stacy M. - Half Moon Bay, CA
Delivered when expected. Recipient was very happy with the gift of Celli’s cookies.
Valerie W. - Williamsburg, VA
Everything & the cookies were to scrumptious, they melted in your mouth.
Eleanor M. - Somers, NY
Celli chocolate chip cookies are superb.
Toni D. - New Haven, CT
No problems. The cookies are delicious and service was excellent.
Kim B. - Dayton, OH
Easy online and arrived as stated! Was great way to send a local product!!
Andrew R. - Washington, DC
quick delivery and a great cookie
Michael S. - Monterey, CA
Fresh and delicious cookies!
Susan N. - Albuquerque, NM
Everything! Cookies arrived without any problems and were swiftly consumed.
James S. - Milton, DE
These are the world's best chocolate chip cookies!
ADELE S. - Bloomington, IL
Cookies were delicious and packaged well.
Jennifer N. - New York, NY
Transaction and shipping was great. These cookies are by far the best and most fresh! I've ordered now several times from this vendor. Really well done.
Emily W. - Bend, OR
This shipment was one of the cookie subscriptions I send to family. These cookies, and those from the other bakers have gotten to be a looked-forward-to day of the month. Thanks.
Charles S. - Dothan, AL
Both products were outstanding !
Robert B. - West Barnstable, MA
Efficient and orders arrived as scheduled.. Great product!
Connie H. - Barbourville, KY
Cookies where delicious!!!!
Maria A. - Lompoc, CA
Reshipped order when original order failed to arrive. 2nd order arrived perfectly and timely.
Marlene D. - Wilmington, DE
Ordering was made very easy & pleasant by the agent!! Helped a lot for multiple orders!!
- ,
Everything!! It was fast and easy!! Quick delivery!
Clancy M. - Scarsdale, NY
Arrived on time. My son love them.
Jonathan G. - Falls Church, VA
The cookies from Celli’s arrived fresh, unbroken, packaged well. Goldbelly kept me informed about tracking the cookies. I so appreciate that. I had a big Christmas order.
Pamela F. - Belgrade, MT
Delivery was on time and product was excellent quality.
Jeannine R. - Newport News, VA
delivery as promised. Celli's cookies rock.
Pam L. - Argyle, TX
arrived as predicted, beautifully packaged, perfect condition
thomas m. - Santa Fe, NM
Easy to place orders. Gift to my son in the Navy said the cookies were delicious
Nicholas S. - Virginia Beach, VA
Pleasantly surprised at selection and price. Delivery was fast
Cheryl G. - Hopkinton, MA
I entered the wrong shipping address when I placed my order. I called Goldbelly immediately afterward, and Goldbelly corrected the address immediately.
Sean O. - San Francisco, CA
Individually wrapped. A gift
Fred L. - Alexandria, VA
Easy to select a product and order/pay for it. Tracking the shipment was easy too.
Todd H. - Chicago, IL