Pumpkin Cheesecake - 8 inch

+ Free Shipping
This product is currently sold out.

Called the “Most Famous Deli in the United States” by USA Today, Carnegie Deli is now offering their heavenly Pumpkin Cheesecake. A twist on a classic dessert, they took the pumpkin out of the pie and baked it into their heavenly, creamy cheesecake. The ultimate sweet ending to your fall feast.

More Details

This Carnegie Deli’s Pumpkin Cheesecake is 8" round and serves approximately 10-12 people (4.5 lbs.)


Cream Cheese, Sugar, Whole Egg, Flour, Sour Cream, Pumpkin, Pumpkin Spice, Vanilla Extract, Lemon Juice, Water, Whole Milk Powder.

Instructions / Storage

  • Carnegie Deli’s cheesecakes are made fresh, frozen and ship with ice packs that may thaw partially or fully during transit
  • To serve, allow cheesecake to thaw in the refrigerator overnight, then at room temperature for 3-4 hours before serving
  • Cheesecakes can be stored in the refrigerator for up to 5 days (preferably in an airtight container) or in the freezer for up to 6 months

Shipping Details

  • Items are prepared fresh and shipped directly from the shop
  • Carnegie Deli ships Monday-Friday of each week.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via overnight will incur an additional $35 charge. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Recommended for you

More from New York


The nostalgia! The flavor and texture were exactly as I remember. Delightful!
Katie P. - Ogden, UT
The pastrami was seasoned perfectly, very tender and not at all fatty. It was just like you'd get at the Carnaeie Deli. It came with an entire loaf of rye bread that was not only fresh but crusty. Just a very good quality Jewish rye. It also came with a jar of their mustard and sour pickles that are out of this world. This really is the Carnegie experience. Thank you!
Sanford S. - Clinton, CT
My pickles were shipped very well. The pickles were fresh and crispy. I’m eating 2 at a time lol. When I eat them they say snap !!! A fan for the rest of my pickle life. Carnegie if you put such love in a pickle what else can you ship me?
Audrey M. - Johnston, RI
The package arrived well preserved and tightly wrapped. The pickles and pastrami were to die for. Did not have the salty taste often associated with shipped items. Had enough to make 6 -7 sandwiches;  advertised to be for four. Those had to be huge slices.
Judith B. - Goshen, IN
We have had pastrami sandwiches from Carnegie Deli, while visiting New York. I didn’t know if they would be as good sent by mail. I sent for them to surprise my husband for Father’s Day, & we were not disappointed. Every component of the sandwich kit was high quality & delicious!
Vicki J. - Elmira, OR
Our 57th anniversary, a surprise for my ex-New Yorker and musician husband, who hung out in that ‘hood a lot, he was amazed and thrilled !! Everything was perfect, authentic, delicious and fun. Very reasonable as well, considering the quality. We can’t wait to do it again.
Melanie H. - Mill Valley, CA
I was able to showcase some delicious, authentic NYC food, which I grew up with, to my own children, especially since we are not living in that part of the country. It was expensive, but it was a rare and delicious treat for us to enjoy together! The cheesecake was a wonderful, decadent birthday cake!!! The Carnegie Deli meat, bread, etc., were 1000% better than I had anticipated. Excellent and exceptional quality and packaging. Truly, a memorable meal with my family.
Donna H. - Portland, OR
Everything was delicious.......the meat was flavorful and so tender.......bread was perfect.....could not have been happier, even though it arrived a day later than expected!!! 
Mary L. - The Villages, FL
The Corned Beef Sandwich Kit was a Hanukkah gift to my daughter and her husband. They gave the corned beef sandwich gift rave reviews, Everything was a 10.0!
Heather G. - Mc Lean, VA
The sandwich kit was good quality. Packed very good. A reasonable amount of money for the quantity of food you get.
Celeste K. - Anahola, HI
We loved all the ingredients, the bread, the meat, especially the mustard and PICKLES!!! We even ordered the exact same thing for some friends who will definitely enjoy it. The meat is so nicely trimmed. I really appreciated that. Just enough fat left for the great taste but not so much that it's overwhelming. Fantastic package! Thank you all so much!!!!
Patricia B. - Arlington, VA
The food was phenomenal. The pastrami from Carnegie deli was excellent the pickles were awesome. Saving the cheese cake for the holidays. Also loved the free shipping. Otherwise I would not have ordered it.
Nan F. - Bradenton, FL
Cheesecake was delicious. Authentic New York Cheesecake. Can't get that in Minnesota. Brought me back to my roots.
Diane P. - Winona, MN
The best cheesecake on the planet. Hands down!
Margaret K. - Falls Church, VA
Great service and cheesecake was delicious 😋
Carol K. - Hobe Sound, FL
This came exactly as advertised. The bread and the pickles were surprisingly fresh.
Jeff C. - Prosper, TX
The corned beef was delicious and pretty lean. The rye bread was fresh and tasty. My family loved it.
Debbie S. - Columbus, OH
It’s simply the best.
Wilhelmina P. - Baton Rouge, LA
The pastrami tasted like home, the delivery was on time, and it was a very easy process from start to finish.
Susan M. - Portland, ME
Delicious food, packaged great for shipment and eating!
Bill P. - San Jose, CA
Everything. The meat, bread, mustard and the pickle was perfect. Brought me back to NY.
Anthony S. - Harvest, AL
Love the Carnegie Deli Mustard. Brings back memories of my youth at Miami Beach Delis.
Joan D. - Saint Simons Island, GA
corn beef was very tender and bread fresh
Janice A. - Sartell, MN
Pastrami was amazing. Cheesecake to die for.
Valerie B. - Gun Barrel City, TX
I love these pickles!
Melissa A. - Fort Collins, CO
Delicious! Fast shipping and the packaging was excellent!
cheryl b. - Sun Prairie, WI
Great quality and timely delivery.
Bob&MaryAnne D. - Winter Garden, FL
Free shipping was the reason for my first order. But the products were excellent and, despite my fears on perishability, packaging was well planned.
Rebecca H. - Madison, IN
The sandwich kit had the bread, the pickles, the mustard and the corned beef. This was a gift for my husband and he was thrilled. It’s been a few years since he was in New York so this was the perfect gift!
Mary G. - Hammond, OR
The food sent looks delicious. I liked the way you sent me emails to update the delivery, etc. You appear to be a classy organization!
Jane L. - Lincoln, NE
Food quality, presentation was excellent. A NYC deli in a box! Loved it.
Sandy W. - Saint Louis, MO
Food was excellent, good quality. Good quantity! Well packed. Pickles were great!
Bruce R. - Wilmington, NC
On time delivery. Simple instructions. Tasted great. 5 of us at the are from New York and all agreed that it was fabulous tasting. The consistency was perfect.
Lauren P. - Colorado Springs, CO
The Carnegie Deli's Famous Cheesecake - 8 inch was the best Cheesecake We've ever had.
Michael L. - Glendale, AZ
The Carnegie pastrami, rye bread, and mustard was out of this world.
Elizabeth P. - Kohler, WI
Love how easy it is to receive Carnegie Deli! Just choose something delicious, pick your delivery date and it shows up on time, well packaged with east to follow instructions. Best way to treat yourself to something unique and high quality.
George R. - El Paso, TX
Pastrami was the best we have ever had, rye bread and mustard were the perfect complement to it. Quantities were generous.
Eugene F. - Wilmington, OH
Packed well.. fast delivery...extremely fresh bread...lean delicious pastrami..Loved the mustard, too. PERFECT TREAT!!!!
Brigid D. - Wells, ME
Absolutely delish! I am from Brooklyn NY but haven't lived there since 1984. Great bread, great pickles, great tender yummy pastrami.
Patricia M. - Brighton, MD
Overall quality very good. Bread, excellent. Mustard, excellent. Pickles, very good. Corned beef, very good, but not as well-trimmed as pictured. Pastrami taste good, but was more than 50% fat.
Dene K. - Moneta, VA
Anybody who has ever been to NYC understands that pastrami from Carnegie Deli is a memorable taste. This delivery was everything I expected and more.
Vincent N. - Waban, MA
Fantastic food. Shipment arrived on time. I gave my wife who's never been to NYC a real York Deli experience 1200 miles away! Serving portion in the description was accurate. Plenty of food for all!
Adam L. - Riverview, FL
Food was delicious. Everything fresh and wonderful. Instructions on how to heat and serve were perfect. I have 2 friends from NY. We didn’t get to go to a deli when we traveled to NY. My friends were very disappointed. When we brought your food to their house they were ecstatic. Happy new year!
Trish R. - Fort Collins, CO
The corn beef was sliced to thick. I love the rye bread and would like to order more.
Kate M. - Eddy, TX
The Pastrami was sooooo good, arrived on time .
Susan W. - Tubac, AZ
Pastrami was great but not as much as expected
Oscar M. - Lakeland, FL
The bread was very fresh, the pastrami was perfect and the pickles delish! The way everything is packed keeps the flavors distinct and just the way you’d get it in the deli.
Lindsay B. - Las Vegas, NV
Packaging was perfect; delivery was as promised. Corned beef was Plentiful & excellent with just right amount of fat. Long thin slices attractively packaged. Rye bread was fresh, tasty and large size. Mustard was delicious and quart of fresh pickles were so good. I would order again. Thank you Goldbelly for making this possible.
June K. - Federal Way, WA
Years ago i was in NYC every other weekend and frequented Carnegie Deli, and I do miss not only the food, but also the delicious aroma when walking through the door. Since I was a regular, Herbie would greet me and give me a cloth napkin, I felt as if i were one of the privileged few! So this delivery from Goldbelly really brought back some wonderful memories. and my kitchen smells like 7th and 54th.
janet w. - Rochester, NY
The beef was excellent, good rye bread, mustard and the pickles...wow! It was a gift and I would order this package for family and friends.
Terry C. - Salado, TX
It was just as I remembered
Virgilio P. - Jacksonville Beach, FL
I ordered for my dad's 91st birthday. He used to live in New York, but now lives in south Texas where this type of food it not available at any price. HE LOVED IT! I was concerned about how perishable food could travel all that way, but he said it was cold and fresh. He said eating it made him feel like he was at home and had just walked down the street for a sandwich. Thanks very much!
Fred M. - Edinburg, TX
It was amazing.....delicious. I live in Arizona, 2,400 miles from the Deli....it arrived in less than 2 days in PERFECT condition. You can bet i will be ordering again AND again. The Rye Bread was ‘the best’.....the Mustard was ample and sooooo good....the pickles were the great ones, too. I purchased ‘SHARK LOCK’ bags on Amazon....these bags can safely be used in boiling water. So, I used my Hamilton Beach Steamer (15min)....for the delicious meat ready for a sandwich....and didn’t have to boil the whole meat package .....perfect for me just needing one sandwich.
TJ J. - Mesa, AZ
Fast delivery, perfectly packaged, and delicious!
Barry R. - Brandon, MS
Cheese cake was fabulous!!
Trish R. - Fort Collins, CO