Individual Cheesecake Sampler - 12 Pack
From
Carlo's Bakery
( 4.8)
Carlo’s Bakery signature New York Cheesecake in 4 incredible flavors including Traditional, Strawberry, Cookies, and Cream, and Salted Caramel. Our classic cheesecake has a silky texture and a rich, sweet flavor that pairs well with fresh fruit or a drizzle of warm chocolate.
Add an additional 12 more assorted cheesecakes for just $19.95- a 65% discount in Carlo’s Bakery’s favorite flavors.
Carlo’s Bakery has received nationwide attention since the 2009 series premiere of TLC’s hit series, Cake Boss. Within this North Jersey, square mile town, on the outskirts of New York City, Carlo’s has become a true pastry landmark establishment.
More Details
This package includes 12 Individual Cheesecake Cups
Flavors include:
- 3 Traditional
- 3 Strawberry
- 3 Cookies, and Cream
- 3 Salted Caramel
Designs are subject to change and photos may not be an exact representation of the product
Ingredients
Contains: Coconut, Eggs, Milk, Nuts, Soy, Wheat
Instructions / Storage
- Cakes ship frozen with dry ice may thaw in transit
- Do not remove dry ice with bare hands
- Remove shrink wrap and paper collar while the cheesecake is still frozen
- To serve, leave at room temperature for around 15-30 minutes
Shipping Details
- Items are prepared fresh and shipped directly from the shop
- Carlo’s Bakery ships Monday – Friday of each week
- Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
- Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
- Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.
Recommended for you
More from New Jersey
( 4.8) Carlo's Bakery REVIEWS
Delivery was on time. The cake was delicious. Everything was perfect.
Stephanie A. - Laredo, TX
09/02/19
I am in Ireland and i was able to send Carlo's Bakery birthday cakes to my niece and nephew in Maryland. Thanks I love the service - it's really easy to use.
Niamh G. - Severna Park, MD
08/29/19
The Rainbow cake was a Birthday cake for my son. He is active military. He posted a picture of how beautiful it was on Facebook. Then after he cut into it, he said it was the most delicious cake he’d ever eaten. Thank you for allowing me to send my baby a cake even though we are a thousand miles apart.
Gennie T. - Norfolk, VA
08/07/19
I loved the Rainbow Cake. It was for my son’s 12th birthday and he was elated it was from “The Cake Boss”. I saved some for my colleagues and they loved it too. I have been telling anyone with ears how cool Goldbelly is. Easy, affordable and deliciously a hero. Thank you.
Bethenny H. - Highland Falls, NY
03/19/19
Everything from the packaging for shipment, AWESOME! SO GOOD! I will be shopping with you guys again. I will recommend you to my friends! You all are an A+ rating.
Theresa S. - Alexandria, VA
09/18/19
The cake was amazing. The flavor and presentation was everything. The cake was moist with rich flavors. My boyfriend said this was the best cake he ever had and will order from you guys again.
Victoria P. - 3390380
09/18/19
The cake was delicious. I did it for my 94 year old mother that watches Cake Boss all the time. She just wanted to try one and knows she can’t travel up to get one.
Phyllis S. - Pocahontas, AR
09/30/19
I don’t think I’ve ever had a better Red Velvet. Was a perfect birthday cake. Thanks Carlo’s and Goldbelly!
Tashia M. - Fort Lauderdale, FL
09/27/19
The Cuban Meat Pies were amazing. The pastry was flaky and the meat was flavored perfectly. They were salty, sweet, and a little tangy all in one. Besides that, these pastries arrived less than 48 hours after ordering. They were well packaged and shipped on dry ice.
Andrea S. - Chadds Ford, PA
05/06/19
The cookies were fantastic. I watch Cake Boss all the time and was just dying to try something from Carlos Bakery. Can't make it to Hoboken so brought it to me by mail.
Dianna T. - Vermilion, OH
05/10/19
Showed up and was absolutely perfect. Even after the delivery person left the box upside down. That is how well packed the cake was. Shipped and delivered on time and was absolutely delicious! Couldn't have asked for better.
Kari H. - Burleson, TX
05/07/19
My friend raved about the cookies - so much that she looked for a recipe on line so she could bake them up herself!
Donna K. - The Villages, FL
05/14/19
Shut the front door. The cake was so fresh and moist. All the way in Cali. Everyone wanted to know how I was able to get and keep the cake sooo moist all the way from Jersey. It was the main attraction at a 4 yr olds birthday party. All he wanted was his "rainbow cake." Goldbelly came through, and I earned TOP DAD OF THE YEAR HONORS!
Bennye R. - Elk Grove, CA
05/17/19
I was expecting the cake to be a mess from shipping, but it was so well packaged that it came out of the box in perfect condition! The cake was delicious! I got it for a friend for pride month and she loved it too.
Tracy D. - Lafayette, IN
06/05/19
I ordered this as a gift and the recipient shared it with her entire family and they all loved it. Nothing like a gift to be shared and appreciated. I have ordered this rainbow cake for three different events and it was a big hit at each of them.
Angie R. - Winchester, VA
06/26/19
The delivery of my Rainbow Cake was on time. It was absolutely magnificent and everyone was so impressed when it was cut and you could see the colorful layers. In looking at their Italian pastry, I definitely am planning on the cannoli, or maybe the lobster claws??? So much to chose from.
Rosalyn A. - Providence, RI
07/05/19
The meat pies are great. There was a problem with shipping on my first order. Not by Goldbelly, but the shipper. The replacement order arrived in good condition thanks to Goldbelly!
Elizabeth S. - Kerrville, TX
07/18/19
My order arrived on time and was packaged very well for the trip to Georgia. The meat pies are out of this world delicious. I bought two boxes. I have bought these before. I am hooked. The meat filling is tasty and well seasoned. The puff pastry is crunchy and flaky. Remember to thaw in the fridge overnight. I use these for brunch and stay satisfied all day. The serving size is generous.
Brenda R. - Savannah, GA
07/17/19
It was fast, great website and easy! The performance was outstanding and the cake arrived on time. It was a birthday gift for my son in the Marines, and I understand it was the best cake my son and his buddy's ever had. I will order again over and and over!
Shellie A. - Virginia Beach, VA
10/30/19
The cake was delivered on time and the cake was fresh and delicious! I highly recommend this company! I’ve have several cakes from them and every single time it was excellent and beautifully designed!
Rayna L. - Scottsdale, AZ
11/07/19
Couldn't be happier with the Chocolate Rainbow Cake from Carlo's Bakery. Delicious. Beautifully colored. Cake perfection. Of course I shared it with others to spread the joy, and everyone loved it, felt similarly. Kudos to Carlo's Bakery and Goldbelly.
Timothy J. - Ormond Beach, FL
01/19/20
The delivery was great. Directions, the cake was beautiful and tasted great.
Jesse B. - Purchase, NY
01/19/20
Absolutely nothing easier!!! Ordered, paid, got a delivery estimate, cake showed up exactly when it was supposed to and was PERFECT! Absolutely wonderful experience and an amazing cake!
Penny L. - Beaumont, MS
12/01/19
Prompt delivery, the cake arrived perfectly intact. As far as the actual cake, it was very beautiful and was a hit visually. Very sweet though, small sliver was all that you could have.
Christina G. - Fords, NJ
12/01/19
Absolutely everything from the ordering to shipping to receiving to instructions to the wonderfully delicious cake which was for my mother's 95th birthday. It was an amazing hit! Thanks.
Elizabeth S. - East Rochester, NY
12/02/19
The ease of purchase, the quickness of shipping, the presentation, and the FLAVOR! Ohhhhhh my goodness!!! Everything was amazing about this order!
Casey C. - Panama City, FL
12/02/19
The carrot cake was moist, yummy and small. It was just right for 8 of us at Thanksgiving. The creamy frosting was a happy taste in our mouths. This makes my third order in a year.,
Brenda G. - La Canada, CA
12/03/19
I received my order fast and like the cake was very good, my daughter ask me about the cake and said you pay more for yours then I did, she had brought a store cake. Well guess who's was all gone and one-piece taking out of her cake. I will order from Goldbelly again, always very good.
Ruth P. - Smyrna, SC
12/04/19
I ordered the rainbow sprinkle cake for my daughters birthday, the cake arrived a week early and i kept it in the refrigerator, but it was still moist and delicious.
Nicole M. - Reseda, CA
11/29/19
I got the 7 piece cake sampler from Carlos Bakery for my mother Birthday she just had a big number. We been sampling a cake everyday and wow they are all wonder and I can't even pick a favorite. Every cake is yummy. My mom and I have been splitting a piece to share dailly so we can sample them all. She just had a big number birthday and was very surprised said was the best birthday cake she has ever had.
Marlo H. - Kansas City, MO
12/04/19
I was worried as I ordered cookies and it was longer to get than I expected and was worried they would be stale. They were not. They were very fresh!
Terri A. - Jurupa Valley, CA
12/09/19
Excellent cookies Buddy is the best !!! My son watches Cake Boss . I would love to order his cup cakes they are great !!!
Helen M. - Carbondale, PA
12/09/19
It was the most delicious cake we've ever eaten!
Brittany J. - Hilton Head Island, SC
12/18/19
The cookies were delicious. I live in California and cannot visit a Carlo's bakery so it was nice to be able to enjoy a treat from there.
Tracy K. - Sacramento, CA
12/10/19
The rainbow cookies were delivered on time and were delicious.
Dianne P. - Philadelphia, PA
12/27/19
The cookies were very good, presented very well and arrived quickly without being broken like cookies often do. Thank you.
Jean Z. - Dayton, OH
12/27/19
Fresh, great shipping and storage. Was a perfect addition to Christmas dessert
Tricia G. - Harwich, MA
12/26/19
The packaging was done with care and the cake arrived nice and cold and fresh. The cake was beautiful and not one thing was messed up. Money well spent and one very happy 9 year old little girl knowing she got a cake from the “ the cake boss” thanks goldbelly for making her day so very special and amazing ❤️
Anya A. - Cisco, TX
12/11/19
Easy to order, product arrived well-packaged and the cake was AMAZING!!
Megan G. - Sonoma, CA
12/11/19
The cake was delicious! Loved the icing.
Allie T. - Troy, NC
12/26/19
Arrived fast...cookies were delicious
Diane E. - Philadelphia, PA
12/26/19
Ordered as a birthday gift and it was promptly and accurately delivered in the holiday rush. The birthday girl said it was a fabulous cake — in appearance and taste.
Annette T. - North Chesterfield, VA
12/26/19
I liked how quickly my Item arrived and how it was packaged. The cake was packed so nothing got damaged.
lori f. - Warwick, RI
12/26/19
The Cuban Meat Pies are everything. I have ordered them about four times. They are convenient and satisfying. I love the meat and seasonings, and the puff pastry rises and gets a little bit crunchy. It is best to order two boxes.
Brenda R. - Savannah, GA
12/12/19
We were surprised at how quickly our order came. The container was so cute and the dry ice had kept the order at a very good temperature. THANKS!
Paula H. - Enterprise, AL
12/27/19
Great tasting cookies from Carlo's Bakery and they were beautifully displayed.
Barbara S. - Woodbridge, VA
12/28/19
The cookies were great!!!! Fresh and crispy and flaky!
Cathy D. - Hartselle, AL
12/27/19
Pretty cake but the taste was the best - awesome! Everyone loved it! It disappeared in no time! Will definitely order again!
April D. - Argyle, TX
12/27/19
My grandson and family LOVED his rainbow cake!
Tristan M. - Rancho Cucamonga, CA
12/26/19
Excellent quality and presentation. The cake was fresh and just as pictured. Everyone loved it!
margaret k. - Auburn, NY
12/25/19
This was my first experience ordering from Carlo’s Bakery/Goldbelly. The ordering process was extremely easy. The cake....oh my goodness the cake!!!!!!!!! I have never and I repeat NEVER have had a better cake in my life. It was unbelievably rich and flavorful.
Michael T. - Lubbock, TX
01/04/20
Delicious cake from Carlos Bakery, this is the second one we have ordered this month. Very pleased with Goldbelly delivery and notifications.
Meridith R. - Pine Mountain, GA
01/05/20
The second time I ordered cake from Carlos bakery. It was a good ft for a family members birthday. They loved it and even sent pictures. It was perfect
Perri W. - Sarasota, FL
01/05/20
Cake was beautiful
And delicious !! Came with easy directions on how to defrost etc
Jenny S. - Nantucket, MA
01/08/20
The cake arrived promptly and the packaging had protected it well. It thawed beautifully and was perfect serving temp by the time of the birthday party. Over the next few days we ate every bite - it was delicious and one of the best items we have ever ordered from y’all
Catherine L. - Jacksonville, FL
01/09/20
This carrot cake I ordered was so good and moist l couldn’t believe it. It was packed with dry ice to keep it fresh. I am quite pleased with my purchase . Will orderl from Goldbelly again.
Helen S. - West Covina, CA
11/19/19
It was the prettiest cake I have ever seen.. And the taste was out of this world!!!
Holly H. - Layton, UT
11/25/19
Ease of ordering. Cake was delicious. Would definitely reorder.
Joyce J. - Lantana, FL
11/14/19
Granddaughter was very excited about the "rainbow." The taste of the cake was good, also!
WANDA M. - Panama City, FL
11/20/19
This was a gift for a family member. I was told that it was very rich, decadent and was eaten for breakfast!! :) This is the 2nd cake ordered from Goldbelly; both to the same family member and while he really liked the first cake (Carlo's bakery) he LOVED this one more because it wasn't a "standard" cake!
Justin J. - Simi Valley, CA
11/20/19
Arrived right on time, packaged well to avoid any damage, and was absolutely delicious....will definitely order again!!!
Marcie M. - Flint, MI
11/21/19
The cake arrived on time and was incredible once thawed.
Brooklyn L. - Vail, AZ
11/21/19
Best Rainbow Chocolate Cake ever, so worth it, a must try
Brenda N. - Mandan, ND
01/27/20
Excellent service, delivered where and when we wanted. The dry ice made a special effect for a 4 year olds birthday away from home.
Jacob M. - West Branch, MI
02/02/20
I love the tarelli coated with the sweet hard frosting.
Angie B. - Hollister, CA
02/02/20
Wrapping was unbelievable. Shipment was amazing, package kept the Cake in one piece. Very moist and delicious. Thank you, looking forward to ordering another cake for my daughter’s 16th birthday next month. New York to Oahu Hawaii
Jeannie D. - Honolulu, HI
02/03/20
As usual, the meat pies showed up when scheduled, still solidly frozen, and securely packaged. They also tasted great. There was also enough dry ice left for me to play with for an hour or so. We old folks have to find our fun where we can.
David P. - Indianapolis, IN
02/05/20
The cake Arrived OM time it was delicious and the customer service is 100% on point. They are terrific
Karen G. - Raleigh, NC
02/09/20
THE BEST RAINBOW COOKIES I EVER HAD AND THEY ARRIVED FAST. THANK YOU
CAROL B. - Whiting, NJ
02/10/20
The gift was an excellent choice and the cookies from Carlos were delicious
Mike A. - Newburyport, MA
02/12/20
incredibly fast shipping, great product too!
Adrienne E. - Incline Village, NV
11/14/19
Best red velvet cake I have ever had! Rich and creamy cream cheese frosting, moist and delicious cake, perfectly packed and delivered fresh.
Robert A. - Ithaca, NY
02/17/20
Cake arrived on time and exactly as expected! Instructions were clear, cake tasted wonderfully fresh. Really amazing! Can't believe
Kiersi B. - Sheridan, WY
02/18/20
Everything - arrived on time, arrived fresh, perfect!
Danielle J. - Wilmington, NC
02/18/20
Everything! Product arrived timely and still frozen. Sent as a gift and they have raved about the product. They want more!!
Mike C. - Peoria, AZ
02/18/20
The cookies are delicious, thank you! Delivery on time for a birthday gift.
Michelle M. - Palatine, IL
02/18/20
Everything went great, this is the 2nd cake I have ordered and everyone loves them! The cake was on time, package great and taste outstanding!!! Thank you!
Emma R. - Belmont, MA
02/18/20
The package arrived on time and the cakes were amazing.
Jose L. - Spring, TX
02/18/20
It was a delicious birthday cake ! Ty
Alyssa J. - South Easton, MA
02/19/20
We sent for a customers gift ( like 6 orders) and they all loved it./
Laura D. - Orion, MI
11/13/19
I sent the cake to my daughter in Florida for her birthday she shared it with her fellow firefighters she said it was a great piece of home!! Beautiful Surprise 💖
Shannon C. - Hollywood, FL
02/19/20
The cake was moist, looked even better than the pictures and looked great.
Michael C. - Ferndale, MI
02/24/20
Arrived as promised and the Meat Pies from Carlo's Bakery by Chef Adalberto were excellent.
Judith E. - Oxnard, CA
02/24/20
My brother LOVED the carrot cake from Carlos Bakery.
Ryan T. - Fitchburg, MA
02/29/20
The cake was delicious and beautiful! It came with instructions on how to defrost and serve which was so helpful because I was not serving it until 2 days after it arrived. This really made my daughter’s birthday party special!
Megan K. - Scottsdale, AZ
03/02/20
Everything went well! The cake arrived on time, well packaged , and tasted incredible! My daughter was so surprised! We got the best video and photos of her reaction! She loves the Cake Boss Show and Carlos Bakery ! We can't wait to go there some day in person. Until then we will definitely order again ! Thank you!
Anna S. - Hoffman Estates, IL
03/02/20
The cake was amazing - I bought it for my daughters birthday and now she wants to try other items (that is huge compliment, as she is extremely picky)
Megan D. - Southwick, MA
03/03/20
Carlos bakery red velvet cake delicious! To celebrate my daughters sweet 16. She was excited to have a cake boss cake by Buddy! Thank you!
Melinda M. - Independence, KY
03/04/20
Sent the sampler cake to my daughter at Michigan Tech University in Michigan for her birthday. She loved it! Her first question “Is this from the real cake boss!”
Lauren N. - Houghton, MI
11/13/19
Product was delivered on time and quality was preserved.
Greg S. - Chico, CA
03/05/20
I placed the order and two days later it arrived right on time! Thank you for helping me send a birthday cake to my son on the other side of the states!
Cole S. - Chicago, IL
03/08/20
The cake was a gift she said it was delicious.
Jenna R. - Conover, NC
03/10/20
Cake got here safe and still frozen. Packing was outstanding. The cake was the most delicious cake we ever had.
Jennifer B. - Fort Madison, IA
03/11/20
Food was still in good condition, arrived frozen as promised and no damage to goods. Goldbelly allows me to share my favorite foods with my family from miles away and i love that!
Maritza G. - Miami, FL
03/14/20
Cake was beautiful and delicious! Icing not too sweet!
Ellen K. - Crozet, VA
11/13/19
IT WAS DELIVERED ON HER BIRTHDAY!! That in itself was what made it special..I'm the gma in Fl and my granddaughter that I raised is in Utah!
Ivory H. - West Jordan, UT
03/16/20
