Holiday Choose Your Own Ice Cream - 6 Pints

Choose from Capannari’s best-selling flavors to build your own custom 6-pack. Their exceptionally super-rich, small-batch pints of creamy goodness may just change the way you think about ice cream.

Capannari has been designated as the "Best Ice Cream in Chicago” by Chicago Magazine, as one of the top 10 “best Scoops in America” by Good Morning America. In addition, Bon Appetit dubbed their ice cream a “top pick” and “awesome”.

More Details

  • This package includes your choice of 6 pints of Ice Cream

Flavor Options Include

  • Black Raspberry Chip – this signature Capannari flavor is made with super-premium, robust black raspberries and melt-in-your mouth chocolate pieces
  • Butter Pecan – this super-creamy favorite is bursting with the most incredible, mammoth gourmet pecans – freshly-roasted, salted, and buttered to crispy perfection. You’ll taste and feel the difference in every bite!
  • Cake Batter – this perennial customer favorite catapulted to Capannari’s top-5 flavors in record time. And the best part is you don’t have to wait for a cake to come out of the oven!
  • Cinnamon – Imagine the finest quality, premium stick cinnamon masterfully extracted and blended into a smooth and creamy, melt-in-your-mouth ice cream. It’s perfection!
  • Coconut Chip – Imagine the finest quality, premium coconut masterfully blended with melt-in-your-mouth chocolate pieces. It’s absolute perfection!
  • Double Chocolate PB Crunch – Deep, dark chocolate ice cream loaded with melt in your mouth chocolate chip, swirls of creamy peanut butter and heaping handfuls of chocolate peanut butter cups. This flavor is the every peanut butter lover’s dream! It has it all!
  • Java Chip – Rich, robust flavor from the finest Jamaican Blue Mountain coffee beans and melt-in-your mouth chocolate pieces
  • Madagascar Vanilla – this 3-time national award-winner is a vanilla-purist’s dream. The difference is Capannari’s proprietary vanilla blend, extracted from the finest and most flavorful Madagascar vanilla beans.
  • Mint Chocolate Chip – this velvety-rich all-time favorite is the perfect combination of the finest all-natural mint crème paired with the smoothest, melt-in-your-mouth chocolate pieces
  • Rich Chocolate – Creamy, smooth and super-rich with a deep chocolate color, this national award-winner is made with the richest, purest chocolate.
  • Strawberry – Chock full of the sweetest, ripest, premium strawberries, this all-time American favorite is super-smooth and super-creamy.
  • Cookies & Cream – Nothing like the perfect mix of crushed cookies in ice cream. Ice cream lovers both young and old will fall head over heels for this sophisticated take on this classic flavor.
  • Cookie Dough – Chunks of delicious cookie dough wrapped up in our creamy vanilla base to make any dessert lover swoon. Who needs a glass of milk when you can have ice cream.
  • Pumpkin – This rich, creamy flavor with the perfect spice blend pairs beautifully with pie, cake, or on its own.
  • Peppermint – This bright, refreshing flavor is our top choice when it comes to dessert pairing.
  • Chocolate Hazelnut Ganache – Rich, creamy chocolate with toasted and nutty blends.
  • Malted Butter Fudge – Smooth with a chocolatey creamy finish, this is a perfect scoopable version of the classic malt.
  • Bordeaux Cherry – You will never go back to standard fruit blends again. This sweet, tart, creamy dessert will have you enjoying cherry season all year round!

Instructions / Storage

  • Ice cream ships frozen with dry ice, dry ice may thaw in transit
  • Do not remove dry ice with bare hands
  • Immediately place in the freezer, may be enjoyed for up to 3 months
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Capannari Ice Cream ships Monday-Thursday of each week.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via overnight will incur an additional $35 charge. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Illinois


Even though we didn’t get our delivery until 5 in the evening, the ice cream was still firm. I was truly amazed! Definitely pricey, but for a special treat, it was worth it. Thanks! 
Linda D. - Kansas City, MO
Loved how it came with an ice cream scoop, the toppings and the hot fudge in a squeeze bottle! It was packaged beautifully.
Janaki K. - Delanco, NJ
Delivered frozen....I was concerned. Best ice cream ever!
Monica M. - Medford, NJ
It showed up completely frozen despite major heatwave back east. Plus a Today show segment that showed the cargo portion of a UPS truck was hitting 150 degrees! Woot!
Debra J. - Staten Island, NY
The strawberry and chocolate ice cream were really good. Will order again.
Linda C. - St Charles, IL
Best ice cream I ever had! Very smooth and creamy with a rich flavor! I love it!
Zita M. - Westwood, MA
It is impossible to find a better chocolate ice cream anywhere in the world!!!
Ron B. - Aventura, FL
Best ice cream ever! I've already eaten three of the six pints over the past week, it's that good! Can't wait to order again!
Elizabeth S. - Chicago, IL
Flavor choices were excellent. The creaminess was amazing. Best of the lot we have tried by far.
Steve R. - Alfred Station, NY
It came a little soft but still frozen enough. I would recommend to everyone anyway because the ice cream is so darn good!!!!
The K. - Decatur, GA
The ice cream was smooth, creamy, and very tasty. It was a hit with our company.
Jeanette F. - Aurora, CO
Super easy to send great treats to friends far away! I sent ice cream and it arrived perfectly frozen!
Joni C. - Chicago, IL
Everything! Delivery was on time, food was still frozen and the quality of the food was GREAT. CS was super nice and knowledgeable when I called
Brandon S. - Tualatin, OR
Everything. The order was delivered on time before Christmas even amidst the holiday/pandemic online shopping & subsequent shipping frenzy. The ice cream was a hit w/ the unsuspecting recipients. Thx!
Stephen L. - Kent, OH
I’m originally from Chicago and always looking for something special to send to others friends and family that have since moved. You had so many great options, it was hard to pick just one. The delivery was especially quick during the holidays and a pandemic!
Steve A. - Glen Carbon, IL
Everything. Seamless purchase, shipping, delivery & consumption by happy recipients!
Jennifer P. - Fairfield, OH
It was a birthday gift for a good friend and she said it was the best gift - and ice cream- she had ever Been given!
Margot G. - Bronx, NY
Product came frozen as ice cream should, the flavors were incredibly delicious. I sent a package to my daughter.
Denise D. - Lake Worth, FL
I got an ice cream sundae party as a gift for someone who needed a reason to smile. She *loved* it! The ice cream was fantastic, she said, and plus it's just such an unusual, fun gift. She texted me every night to tell me which flavor she was enjoying that night. And she also said she's going to order more of the ice cream because it was so good.
SUSAN R. - Bellevue, WA
Everything! This is the 3rd or 4th time using you.
Beth T. - Richmond Hill, GA
The ice cream was delivered on time and in great condition. The recipients loved it. Will do this again.
Kim B. - Westland, MI
I found immediately what I was searching for. I especially appreciated the updates on my orders because they were being delivered to different address. I am very impressed with your service and the products I ordered.
Jo K. - Whitefish, MT
Food arrived at my brother’s perfectly. He has already placed an order and his sister-in-law already placed an order. Wish we had discovered it sooner!
Terry L. - Munster, IN
Product came on the day it was promised. Packaging for ice cream was great. Ice Cream and toppings were delicious.
Sam K. - Weston, CT
Each family member that received the gift of Capannari Ice Cream through Goldbelly was delighted!
Kim/Denise M. - South Bend, IN
The five orders that arrived in a timely fashion on Thursday as hoped. Ice cream was perfectly frozen and amazing tasting - all four flavors.
Stephanie B. - Seattle, WA
Tracking of delivery was super cool. I liked how I could watch it “travel”. Arrived on time in good condition and communication was excellent. Thank you!
Lisa T. - Toledo, OH
Delivery arrived on time. Recipients LOVED the gift!
Jeff D. - Maplewood, NJ
Delivery ,super fast !!!, , i never had such a delicious ice cream before !my girls and all my family loved it !!, i will get more very soon ,, worth the money 100%.
Alexander A. - Moreno Valley, CA
Great delivery! Awesome ice cream (Cappanari)!
Denise G. - Homer Glen, IL
Delicious ice cream and toppings!
Grace L. - Charlotte, NC
Great product and well packed to stay cold.
L B. - Las Vegas, NV
Fast delivery and my friends said it was packaged well
Steve K. - Mountain Brk, AL
A 30th birthday surprise for my niece the delivery time was perfect and ice cream packed in dry ice and very cold and hard. Excellent packaging.
Lynea M. - Chicago, IL
Great products, easy to maneuver website, quick shipping and arrives well packaged and on time!
Gwen C. - Somis, CA
Perfect from order to delivery to my friends enjoying the ice cream that night.
Cay N. - Saint Louis, MO
Cappinarris ice cream is fantastic. Ordering was simple and delivered on time
Tom R. - Elburn, IL
Delivery was flawless. Ice cream arrived still frozen.
Ainsley F. - Burke, VA
On time, plenty of dry ice!
Gina H. - South Bend, IN
My grandson loved the Ice Cream and all the extra's that came with it I have ordered the ice cream several times and it is the best we have tasted
Richard W. - Brevard, NC
We love the products and their quality. The site is easy to navigate and the shipping has been quick and very accurate.
Lisa M. - Sioux Falls, SD
Delivered on the day requested, ice cream arrived unmelted and perfect.
Ted U. - Hilton Head Island, SC
This was a gift. The person that received it really liked it!!
Alane B. - Malvern, PA