Swanky Cookie Assortment

Cake Chicago ships its famous cookies nationwide on Goldbelly! Cake Chicago’s “Damn Good Cookies,” “Jar’d” cakes, and more have delighted fans from all over the country, including Martha Stewart! Your cookies should match your swanky soiree and this elegant spread is up to the task. As delicious as they are beautiful (and perfectly bite-sized), the cookies and their whimsical names may even be a conversation starter.

In 2000, Mary Winslow left her publishing sales job and started baking, but she never thought she would end up becoming one of Chicago’s top bakers. But like any great cake, her rise was slow and deliberate with outstanding results — she began by subletting a small area in a catering kitchen, but soon found herself in a bigger kitchen with a whole new line of pastries. Martha Stewart and countless others are fans of her chubby “Damn Good Cookies,” decadent “Jar’d” cakes, and “Ugly Truffles.”

More Details

  • Choose between 24, 36 or 64 Swanky Cookies
  • Cookies arrive individually wrapped in a beautiful git box with a ribbon

Flavors include:

  • Overprotective Pecans – cookie-coated salty pecan halves and bittersweet chocolate chips
  • Percocious Peanut Butter – peanut butter cookie filled with white chocolate peanut butter cream and topped with a honey-roasted peanut
  • Rockabye Raspberry – sugar cookie coated with vanilla sugar and filled with handmade raspberry conserve
  • Controlling Coconut Cookies – buttery, crispy, coconut cookies surrounded by toasted coconut and generously dusted with powdered sugar
  • Maternal Macadamia Nut Cookies – sugar cookie with macadamia nuts and a sprinkling of vanilla sugar
  • Assorted Chubby Wubby Cookies – 24-pc includes Chocolate & Caramel Chubby Wubbies, 36-pc includes Chocolate, Caramel & Hazelnut Chubby Wubbies, 64-pc includes Chocolate, Caramel, Hazelnut, Peanut Butter, Mint & Raspberry Chubby Wubbies

Instructions / Storage

  • Baked goods are individually wrapped and arrive ready to enjoy!
  • Upon arrival, place in the refrigerator or freezer to enjoy later. They can be stored in the refrigerator for 2 weeks or in the freezer for up to 3 months
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • cake ships Monday-Thursday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Illinois

REVIEWS

Adorable jar cakes! Shipped well and the recipient loved the packaging and the flavors. Cakes were moist. She also loved the brownie flavors and the moist, chewy consistency of the brownies. Ordering was easy and the items arrived on time!
Susana L. - Arlington Heights, IL
10/09/19
The Ugly Truffles had such humor!! And they tasted sooo good!
Linda M. - Yountville, CA
07/22/19
Very fun and unusual gift! Love the jars, label, and bow. Like the ingredients. I would have liked it more if it was a little less sweet.
Carol D. - Vero Beach, FL
05/24/19
I have never seen cake in a jar before the gift I received from Goldbelly.com. I was a bit leery of tasting the cakes; They were delicious! A pleasant and delicious surprise.
Carol C. - Elizabethtown, PA
12/26/18
My mom was thrilled with the Gluten Free Ugly Truffles.
Biji B. - Berea, KY
12/18/19
The food offerings are amazing. Everything I have ordered has arrived in perfect fresh condition and has been delicious. Customer service is always responsive and helpful.
Susan G. - Denver, CO
02/26/20
My friend enjoyed the mini cakes and it got there in a timely fashion.
Saherra B. - Charlotte, NC
04/14/21
Ease of ordering On time delivery Excellent packaging
Tina R. - Texarkana, AR
03/20/21
The rave review from my recipient. If I order from Goldbelly, I'm confident it will be top notch.
K.K.B. T. - Gardnerville, NV
02/22/21
Cake jars were delivered on time and my son said they were delicious. It was a great way to deliver cake to someone who lives alone during the pandemic and couldn't eat a dozen cupcakes by themself. The jars were also a bonus.
Michael N. - Chicago, IL
02/19/21
Clients loved the cookies and the packaging from the small business we bought from. They raved about the packaging and delivery was smooth.
Jill A. - Chicago, IL
02/16/21
I ordered a special treat for my daughter’s family, as we’ve been separated by COVID. Goldbelly provides a lot of ways to send love. They all enjoyed the truffles very much.
Bruno F. - Kalamazoo, MI
01/15/21
Absolutely everything! Fabulous options, easy ordering, delighted recipients!! Goldbelly is me hands-down favorite for sending gifts!!! THANK YOU!!!!
Birthday C. - Sebastian, FL
01/08/21
I received a gift from a friend from Goldbelly and immediately sent another gift to another friend then recommended it to my daughter. Everything was great. Online choices and ordering were a breeze. I was kept updated on the shipping/delivery status and my food arrived fresh and on time.
Charles A. - Chicago, IL
01/01/21
Despite the holidays and a snow storm, package arrived on time and my mom loved the cookies!
Linda F. - Eighty Four, PA
12/23/20
I sent my order as a gift. The recipient loved it and said that the cakes were delicious and beautifully packaged. Thank you.
Mitch F. - Elkridge, MD
12/15/20
The package arrived on time. It was beautifully wrapped. My mother loved all of the individually wrapped truffles and the uniqueness of the gift!
Barbara N. - Sodus, NY
05/15/21
My Aunt loved that her birthday gift was gluten free!
Peggy H. - Springfield, MO
05/15/21
Delivery was great and “the truffles are DELICIOUS”!!!
Sarah B. - San Francisco, CA
05/09/21