Key Lime Pie

Blue Smoke ships its famous pies nationwide on Goldbelly! Blue Smoke has been serving New Yorkers some of the nation’s best BBQ for decades and now, just in time for the holiday season, they are shipping iconic Southern pies! This Key Lime Pie is tart and creamy—perfect to help get you through the winter.

Blue Smoke is a New Yorker who remains a Southerner at heart. Part of Danny Meyer’s Union Square Hospitality Group, Blue Smoke has been serving Southern style barbecue in the Big Apple since 2002. Named for the curl of smoke that rises from a barbecue pit, Blue Smoke sources ingredients from some of the best Southern farmers and purveyors, proving that roots run deep, even for food. One of New York City’s best barbecue restaurants, Blue Smoke was awarded a star from the New York Times and was featured on Food Network’s “Best Thing I Ever Ate.”

More Details

This package serves 8-10 people and includes a 9" Key Lime Pie

Ingredients

Graham Dough: Crisco (soybean oil, fully hydrogenated palm oil, palm oil, mono- and diglycerides, TBHQ, citric acid), light brown sugar, flour, whole wheat flour, salt, buttermilk
Key Lime Pie Filling sweetened condensed milk, sour cream, key lime juice

Instructions / Storage

  • This pie is shipped frozen with ice packs, ice packs may thaw in transit
  • Pie can be kept refrigerated for up to five days.
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Blue Smoke ships Monday and Wednesday each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New York

(
 4.9) REVIEWS

It was all most belly satisfying. Think I'm going to need an intervention with those potato chips and dip!!!
Pamela S. - Santa Fe, NM
10/01/19
The ribs were amazing. Fell off the bone, flavor perfection!
Stephanie B. - Holliston, MA
02/07/19
The order came fast and the food was fresh, just as described and pictured on the website. The directions on how to prepare were super easy.
Sherry T. - Ogallala, NE
02/06/19
Homemade without having to mess my kitchen!
Ursula M. - Henderson, NV
02/06/19
The ham from Blue Smoke was lean and had so much flavor. It was absolutely delicious.
Cathy R. - Fallbrook, CA
12/27/18
Delivery was great and on time as well as one of the best sweet potato pies we have tasted! Packaging was fantastic and it looked as if it were picked up from the restaurant!
Sandeep S. - Yuba City, CA
12/17/18
My family was pleasantly surprised. Gold belly came through in the clutch for thanksgiving!
Susan N. - Woodstock, VT
12/02/19
Well packaged, fine product, easy instructions and generous portions. Terrific flavor (best of 3 different ribs I have t.ried from goldbelly). Will definitely order again!
Hal L. - Los Angeles, CA
11/25/19
Order came quickly, food was really quite good. Will definitely order from Blue Smoke again. Came with a personalized card. I like that a lot!!!
Galyn S. - Las Vegas, NV
12/09/20
Perishable ribs very well packed in dry ice, which seems to be the only way to assure frozen stays frozen all the way to me. Also, Goldbelly good at keeping me informed re status of order.
Susan F. - San Diego, CA
12/07/20
The Thanksgiving Dinner was well packaged, directions were easy (although it took longer to heat to 165 in my Viking oven) generous proportions and exceptionally well seasoned and prepped. We all 4 thought it was one of our best Thanksgivings ever. To think it was under a pandemic!! thanks!!!
Pat R. - New York, NY
12/01/20
The product cam in COLD- wrapped well. Ice packs still 1/2 frozen.
Ida M. - Nashua, NH
07/21/20
Excellent. Good selections. Easy website. Arrived on time and in great condition.
Michael E. - Chicago, IL
01/04/21
Food was delivered on Time. Instructions were easy to follow.
Van G. - Madison, NJ
01/02/21
Food was delicious, arrived on time and still cold, and reheating instructions were good. Beautiful holiday note and napkin too, A+++, outstanding appeal relative to other restaurants.
Hector L. - Aliso Viejo, CA
01/02/21
The purchase from Blue Smoke was sent as a gift. The recipients were overjoyed. It was their holiday meal, they raved about the taste and tenderness of the brisket and sides. They expressed what a thoughtful gift that was overwhelming appreciated.
Tilmon B. - Las Vegas, NV
01/01/21
It was delivered on time and was a HUGE hit with the recipients of the gift. From the photos that they sent, the food looked amazing.
Danny A. - Ormond Beach, FL
12/30/20
Was a gift and they enjoyed the ribs but really really liked loved the mac and cheese.
Mike M. - Colonial Heights, VA
12/28/20
Everything. I always have a great experience. Packaging is great and quality is superb. And I love that Goldbelly tells me when the goods will arrive.
Terri T. - Washington, DC
04/03/21
Prompt service, packaged very well in freezer bag with ice packs. Ribs were very good. Lots of meat on the ribs!!!
Noreen O. - Marblehead, MA
02/13/21
A five star***** rating for your chili, A five star***** rating for your cole slaw A five star***** rating for your cheese sauce A five star***** rating for your corn bread biscuits
James B. - Buffalo, NY
01/26/21
Without a doubt I always have to give high marks to the care in packaging, the quality of the products (in this case I got the ribs and chicken...Yummy!). I ordered previously from Blue Smoke but as a gift to my daughter as a first time mother's day gift. After she raved about the meal, I had to get some for myself! The ribs fell off the bone and the chicken was so so juicy! I will definitely do this again.
Wanda G. - Saint Peters, MO
06/02/21
Easy AND simple instructions. Food was excellent. Everyone loved it. I will definitely recommend Goldbelly to others. Food was absolutely delicious!
Doran B. - Lebanon, TN
05/13/21
Quick delivery, Spare Ribs were still frozen and everything was professionally packed!!
Anthony S. - Menlo Park, CA
04/17/21
Everything was awesome and I do mean awesome, my hat goes off to you GOLDBELLY! HERE ARE YOUR 5 THUMBS UP 👍👍👍👍👍 KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK.
Terry C. - Cathedral City, CA
07/11/21
Food arrived on time and was delicious. We were impressed with how much food actually was included, enough for 2 meals for the 3 of us.
Karen O. - Wappingers Falls, NY
07/07/21
The chicken was sublime. Tender, juicy, and delicious from leg to wing. Will definitely be ordering again, in the future.
Emma M. - Le Roy, NY
07/05/21
The food was delicious. The best cole slaw I've ever eaten. The ribs and beans were top notch too.
Michael S. - Dolgeville, NY
07/02/21
The baby back ribs were the best! They were packed in a manner that kept the contents frozen. The prep was clear, quick and easy.
Arthur F. - Monmouth Beach, NJ
06/26/21
Ordering was seamless & quick. Filtered on "deliver by Father's Day" and found great options! Recipient LOVED the food and presentation. Enjoyed receiving a Blue Smoke towel along with his delicious ribs and sides.
Gary F. - Lexington, MA
06/22/21
The food was delicious everyone loved it we had the pulled pork and chopped beef brisket I would definitely will be ordering again
Linda B. - Staten Island, NY
06/22/21
The ribs, chicken and cole slaw were delicious. We were very happy and full after dinner!!
Judi S. - Delray Beach, FL
06/26/21
Everything was delicious from the chicken to ribs and the side dishes. I would highly recommend for future purchases. Me and my family truly enjoyed this delightful tasting experience.
Elizabeth J. - Killeen, TX
06/12/21