Choose Your Own Organic Ice Cream - 6 Pints

Blue Marble Organic Ice Cream ships its legendary organic ice cream nationwide on Goldbelly! Create your own variety pack by selecting any six of Blue Marble’s sublime organic ice creams. Blue Marble lets Mother Nature be the star with its pure, elemental, straightforward flavors.

Recognized by Food & Wine as one of the U.S.’s best ice cream makers, Blue Marble uses organic dairy and just enough sugar to create authentically spectacular flavors, from old school favorites to innovative new ones. At their ice cream parlor in Brooklyn, owners Alexis Gallivan and Jennie Dundas, who opened the New York ice cream shop in 2007, strive to make the ice cream your grandmother would have enjoyed: wholesome, rich, pure, organic, and crave-worthy. Blue Marble was voted “Best New Ice Cream” by Time Out NY and has been listed as one of the “Ice Cream Shops you need to visit before you die” by Buzzfeed.

More Details

This package includes your choice of 6 pints of Blue Marble Ice Cream

  • Made with 100% Certified Organic Dairy
  • No pesticides, GMO’s, corn-syrup, antibiotics or artificial flavors—only grass-fed, organic cream, carefully selected, 100% organic ingredients.

Flavor Options Include

  • Vanilla – A natural beauty made with grass-fed, organic cream and gently sweetened with hand-picked, sun-dried, organic vanilla from Madagascar
  • Mexican Chocolate – Styled after the favorite drinking chocolate of Jalisco, this Mexican chocolate is warm with cinnamon, aromatic with almond and packed with dark chocolate chunks
  • Strawberry – The most celebrated flavor! Part sweet, part tart, this entirely delicious strawberry ice cream uses peak season strawberries free from pesticides and GMO’s
  • Sea Salt Caramel – This buttery, decadent flavor blends organic caramel with sea salt from Brittany for a fleur-de-sel finish. No corn syrup, no artificial flavors. Less is so much more
  • Cookies & Cream: – Finally, an organic twist on America’s favorite flavor. Blue Marble adds crushed organic chocolate sandwich cookies to their award-winning vanilla ice cream to create a contemporary classic.
  • RISE Nitro Cold Brew Coffee – In partnership with RISE, Blue Marble has blended organic single-origin nitro cold brew coffee with their rich organic cream. Does this mean ice cream is now for breakfast?
  • Green Tea – Stone ground organic green tea leaves are cold steeped in premium organic dairy to make this earthy Japanese inspired treat
  • Midnight Mint Cookie – You won’t need to “scout” all year for this flavor: rich chocolate ice cream dashed with peppermint and loaded with chocolate sandwich cookies. A badge-worthy treat
  • Chocolate – Rich enough for chocolate lovers, smooth enough for the little ones, our chocolate blends dark and milk using organic cacao from the CONACADO cooperative farmers of the Dominican Republic
  • Banana Cream Pie – This utterly crave-able flavor was inspired by the banana puddings of our childhoods.


Cinnamon Double Dark Chocolate – Cream*, Sugar*, Skim Milk*, Alkalized Cocoa*, Coconut Oil*, Cinnamon*, Almond Extract*, Guar Gum*, Locust Bean Gum*, Non-gmo Soy Lecithin*, Vanilla Extract*, Flavors*.
Contains: Milk, Soy And Tree Nuts.

Salt Kissed Caramel – Cream*, Sugar*, Skim Milk*, Sea Salt, Maltodextrin*, Guar Gum*, Locust Bean Gum*, Gum Arabic* Flavors*
Contains: Milk.

Crumbled Cookies & Cream – Cream*, Sugar*, Skim Milk*, Wheat Flour*, Sunflower Oil*, Alkalized Cocoa*, Chocolate Liquor*, Vanilla Extract*, Guar Gum*, Locust Bean Gum*, Baking Soda, Corn Starch*, Natural Flavors, Sea Salt, Non- Gmo Soy Lecithin.
Contains: Milk, Wheat And Soy.

Summertime Strawberry – Cream*, Sugar*, Skim Milk*, Vanilla Extract*, Guar Gum*, Locust Bean Gum*
Contains: Milk.

Just Vanilla – Cream*, Sugar*, Skim Milk*, Strawberries*, Citric Acid, Red Beet Juice*, Pectin, Guar Gum*, Locust Bean Gum*, Strawberry Flavor*, Lactic Acid*
Contains: Milk

Mint Cocoa & Cookie – Cream*, Sugar*, Skim Milk*, Alkalized Cocoa*, Wheat Flour*, Sunflower Oil*, Cane Syrup*, Chocolate Liquor*, Peppermint Extract*, Guar Gum*, Locust Bean Gum*, Baking Soda, Corn Starch*, Vanilla Extract*, Natural Flavors, Sea Salt, Non-gmo Soy Lecithin
Contains: Milk, Soy And Wheat

Single-origin Chocolate – Cream*, Sugar*, Skim Milk*, Alkalized Cocoa*, Guar Gum*, Locust Bean Gum*, Salt*
Contains: Milk.

Rise Nitro Cold Brew Coffee – Cream*, Sugar*, Skim Milk*, Cold Brew Coffe . Concentrate*, Guar Gum*, Locust Bean Gum*.
Contains: Milk.

Banana Cream Pie – Cream*, Sugar*, Skim Milk*, Bananas*, Wheat Flour*, Sunflower Oil*, Oat Flour*, Molasses*, Vanilla Extract*, Locust Bean Gum*, Guar Gum*, Baking Soda, Sea Salt, Corn Starch*, Ascorbic Acid, Natural Flavors, Non-gmo Soy Lecithin. *= Organic, The Product Is Certified Organic And Certified Kosher

Instructions / Storage

  • Ships frozen with dry ice, dry ice may evaporate in transit
  • Place in freezer immediately upon arrival
  • May be kept frozen for up to 6 months
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Blue Marble ships Tuesday-Thursday of each week.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via overnight will incur an additional $35 charge. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from New York


The ice cream is spectacularly delicious!
Jane W. - Westlake, OH
The ice cream is so delicious! I'd never experienced Mexican Chocolate and was surprised at the underlying spice - perhaps Cinnamon - with the large chunks of dark chocolate? Our assortment included Vanilla, Strawberry, Salted Caramel, Cookies and Cream and Coffee. The Strawberry lingers in the freezer as we're holding onto it until the strawberry fields around the corner from us start producing so we can have decadent sundaes with this delicious organic product. We are enjoying every morsel.
Ray V. - Hemet, CA
Came on time and in good condition for my mom’s birthday. She loved the ice creams.
Linda C. - Bayside, NY
Well packaged. I will buy from them again. Banana cream pie was my favorite.
Kevin S. - Dobbs Ferry, NY
When the wrong order was sent Goldbelly promptly resent the right orders with no extra charge.
Rachel I. - Roscommon, MI
Your communication on all fronts, from the order, confirmation of the order, and the actual of tracking of delivery date. ALL GREAT!
Ethan S. - White River Junction, VT