Fall Back GIANT Cookies Pack

(Customer Reviews)

Fall is back with these delicious cookies! Ring in the season with 4 delicious fall-inspired cookie flavors.

When we say these cookies are GIANT we mean it – each one is 6 oz. – just shy of half a pound! These cookies are crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, and are meant for sharing with all your friends (or for weight lifting…) Big.Fat.Cookie is a name well earned.

More Details

This Fall Back package includes 4, 8, or 12 GIANT Cookies

  • Each cookie weighs 6 oz. – almost 1/2 a pound!
  • Cookies measure, 3.5” x 1.5" each
  • One cookie serves 1-2 people

Cookie Flavors Include

  • Apple Pie – Butter vanilla bean cookie base with a hint of cinnamon, filled with hand-cut tart, fresh granny smith apples, and covered in house-made crumble and house-made caramel.
  • Marshmallow Fluff – Quadruple chocolate cookie base rolled in crushed Butterfinger, filled with marshmallow, and topped with fudge.
  • Chocolate Chip Toffee -Classic chocolate chip cookie with house-made crunchy toasted almond toffee.
  • Pumpkin Chocolate Chip – Pumpkin chocolate chip s’mores base with white, milk, and semi-sweet chocolate chips.


Contains Wheat, Eggs, Milk, Tree Nuts, Peanuts

Instructions / Storage

  • Cookies arrive ready to enjoy
  • Cookies have a shelf life of 10 days, after that, we suggest freezing.
  • To re-heat, bring to room temperature (if frozen) re-heat on a baking sheet for 5-8 minutes- you will have a melty chocolate inside with a crispy cookie outside!
  • If freezing isn’t your thing, our cookies morph into a versatile biscotti type cookie after 3 days- simply slice- leave uncovered (yes, uncovered) and dunk in your cappuccino for days to come!
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • big.fat.cookie ships Monday – Wednesday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Illinois


Stayed fresh, great packaging
Tia M. - Shorewood, WI
I love the creativity and overall quality of the cookies.
Harold J. - Houston, TX
Incredible!!!! These cookies are unbelievably delicious! Soft and fresh!!! I will buy these every Christmas and for special occasions!!
Danielle D. - Fort Lauderdale, FL
Robin Z. - Scottsdale, AZ
Arrived on time and tasted amazing.
Joyce H. - San Antonio, TX
Everything arrived on time and tasted amazing.
Betty P. - Carrollton, TX
The delivery was perfect and the cookies were even better.
Ashton A. - Fort Lauderdale, FL
Delivery on time cookies were excellent
Hilary C. - Clayton, NC
Product was better than expected. Delicious and gigantic sizes, beautiful presentation of the product.
Kathleen M. - Vestal, NY
Best cookies by mail that I’ve ever had! So delicious and always delivered on time. Fan for life!
Amy T. - West Chester, OH
Amazing cookies that arrived very well packaged and fast delivery. These are beyond just a cookie and been elevated to a whole other level. Will definitely order again soon!
Kimberly D. - Conway, AR
These cookies really are special for a cookie lover.
Janet S. - Ann Arbor, MI
Cookies are all amazing and unique! We have ordered multiple times and they arrive on time and in perfect condition.
Kimberly D. - Conway, AR
Easy to order and track. The birthday boy consumed them quickly!!!! Delicious!!
Kevin E. - Franklin Park, NJ
The delivery pulled through fine. The cookies are great!
Janet S. - Ann Arbor, MI
Everything! Packaged well and shipping time was on point!
Paul S. - Buffalo Grove, IL
Delicious and delivered promptly
RowBear I. - Austin, TX
It was a surprise for my father with quick delivery
GEORGE V. - Staten Island, NY
Delivery was on time my family that received them loved them great experience
Mike M. - Somerset, PA
As always, on time delivery. Also, the delicious nature of the Big Fat Cookies
Barb S. - Newark, DE
Arrived perfect condition and on time.
Leann E. - Oak Ridge, TN
I ordered these cookies for my friend and her family. She sent me a text saying, “That was the best chocolate chip cookie of my life. Possibly one of the best things I've ever eaten.” And she is a wonderful baker, so that’s a huge compliment!
- ,
Arrival time was early and very good packaging.
Kenneth T. - Milwaukee, WI
Everyone loved the cookies and they were delivered on time.
Robert A. - Springfield, MA
It’s so cool to have such good food available when you live in a very rural area. Loved Big Fat Cookie
Stephanie E. - Carmen, ID
Delivery was perfect !! Cookies were fresh. Will order again
Cassie D. - Chicago, IL
Cookies were excellent and well packaged. Delivered as promised.
Amy T. - West Chester, OH
Cookies were better than I imagined! WOW!
EVAN J. - Oxford, OH
Accurate delivery date, email updates and everything arrived in great condition, packaged beautifully!
Justine R. - Mount Kisco, NY
The cookies exceeded all of our expectations! My husband and I have already agreed that they will become a regular favorite treat for us. Delicious!
Amanda E. - Cuba, MO
Cookies are beyond delicious…as always!
Lynn D. - Milledgeville, GA
Delicious! Large, moist and loaded with chocolate chips! Cookies were huge, so we split them and felt decadent with each bite. A great success!
Diana S. - Clearwater, FL
Quality, delivery and packaging were all top notch.
Elaine S. - Raleigh, NC
The recipient of this gift was absolutely thrilled with this delicious shipment. It arrived packaged perfectly and super fresh!
Emery J. - Madison, WI
Cookies were packaged well so none were broken.
EMILY S. - Diamondhead, MS
Cookies were delivered the day after being shipped out. They were wonderful to look at, and even more wonderful to eat. I also loved the free shipping, as that can usually add a lot to the cost of other items I’ve wanted to order from goldbelly, but didn’t because of the high shipping charge. I would definitely order from bigfatcookie again! I will also order from goldbelly again.
Lisa S. - Mount Prospect, IL
Cookies were delicious!
Richard F. - West Harrison, NY
Easy ordering. Fabulously delicious cookies!
Zach B. - Atlanta, GA
The cookies were amazing. Shipment arrived on time in perfect condition.
Jeanmarie L. - Wauwatosa, WI
Product was number 1! Unfortunately not many people I know can afford such expensive treats
Anthony M. - Burlington, MA
Delivery was quick!
Marsha G. - Pleasantville, TN
Start To Finish - Great Experience!
Willie Jr - Conyers, GA
Cookies tasted fresh despite a long delivery time.
James M. - La Mesa, CA
Easy ordering, on time delivery and beautifully packaged.
Bonnie D. - Bolton Landing, NY
Sent as a gift, birthday boy(man) loves them! Would recommend for anyone who loves peanut butter!
Anthony G. - Oxnard, CA
The chocolate “big fat cookies” are spectacular. Expensive, but super good and Individually wrapped. They took several days to arrive.
Nellie S. - Jamestown, RI