Butterfinger Cream Pie

From Betty's Pies (Customer Reviews)

Betty’s Pies ships its famous pies nationwide on Goldbelly! The candy bar pie packs chocolate and Butterfinger into one delicious, mouth-watering specialty Butterfinger Cream Pie. Tastebuds…you’ve been warned!

What started as a fish shack that sold coffee and donuts on Highway 61 in 1956 has grown to be one of the best pie companies in the world. Betty’s Pies in Two Harbors, Minnesota, is famous for their crave-worthy cream pies, “crunch pies,” and old-fashioned double-crusts. Betty’s Pies bakes dozens of flavors, including Coconut Cream, French Cherry Cream, Caramel Apple Crunch, and the Five-Layer Chocolate Cream Pie.

More Details

Each pie is approximately 9" in diameter and serves 6-8 people

Ingredients

Butterfinger Cream Pie: Heavy Whip Cream, Butterfinger Candy, Chocolate Chips, Vanilla Pudding, Sugar, Salt.
Crust – Wheat Flour, Lard, Egg, Milk, Baking Powder, Salt

Instructions / Storage

Keep frozen until ready to serve!

Your pie is ready to eat once it is thawed. Just unwrap and thaw overnight in your refrigerator. Once your pie is thawed, store covered in the refrigerator for 3 days. Pies can be frozen for up to 2 months.

Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

Betty’s Pies Ships Monday – Thursday of each week
Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!

Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Betty's Pies REVIEWS

THE FRENCH CREME CHERRY AND BLUEBERRY PIES ARE MAGNIFICENT! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED! I'VE ORDERED FIVE OF THESE AND EACH ONE IS FANTASTIC!

Terral B. - Milton, FL

11/05/19

I ordered a strawberry rhubarb for my father, for his birthday. It was the BEST he has ever tasted. I feel like the Goldbelly experience made his day special. Thank you!

Kelly V. - Longview, TX

09/27/19

The pies were delicious! I ordered the 5 Layer Chocolate and the Cherry Cream. The chocolate was my favorite. Loved the hint of cinnamon. They arrived on time and looking great.

Rana K. - San Diego, CA

07/16/19

For Betty's Pies-- we tried the French Blueberry Creme pie and..omg..it is as my son stated, what tasting heaven must be like. Would love to get the recipe ;)

Terri P. - Calverton, NY

04/08/19

The pie is creamy and smooth! It did not disappoint and I would order another in the future!

Laura L. - San Antonio, TX

03/31/19

The coconut cream pie from Betty's Pies was absolutely delicious. My dad loves coconut cream and he thought it was outstanding. To add one more note, we received the pie on National Pie Day! Thus, it couldn't have been better than that!

Gus P. - Deer Park, NY

01/28/19

THE PIES WERE FANTASTIC! THE FRENCH BLUEBERRY AND CHERRY CREME PIES ARE THE BEST. I'LL BE ORDERING THESE PIES AGAIN. THANKS BETTY'PIES AND GOLDBELLY TOO!

Terral B. - Pensacola, FL

11/11/19

The pie was good and its fun getting pie in the mail. ( :

Allie L. - Broken Arrow, OK

01/29/20

The pie was delicious; wasn't crazy about the price though!

Dawn J. - Colorado Springs, CO

02/03/20

Everything was perfect. The pies were the best ever.

Candi B. - Carrabelle, FL

02/18/20

It was good but ice pack did not stay solid so box and top of pie were slightly wet.

Michelle M. - Raleigh, NC

02/27/20

The maple walnut pie was awesome! It was absolutely delicious!

Lynn B. - Pittsburgh, PA

03/18/20

everything from packaging to delivery was great,but the cherry cheese pie was so Awesome! delicious and can't wait to order again! i saved my daughter a piece as she loves cheese pie! yours is perfect and highly recommended! wish i lived right on your street! YUMMY!not

margaret q. - Villas, NJ

03/15/20

Ordering was easy, and It was shipped in a timely manner. It was a gift for my sister, she loved it.

Sue B. - Prior Lake, MN

04/17/21

All of the pies we purchased were fresh & delicious. We had several different pie requests for Easter & we were able to fulfill everyone’s request.

Melissa S. - Gentry, MO

04/05/21

I sent two pies to my mom for her birthday and pie day . As always they were wonderful . The delivery was timely and the pies couldn't have been a better gift . Thank you Betty's and Goldbelly

Myrene M. - Blanchard, OK

03/26/21

Arrived on time. After thawing, it was sooo delicious.

DELORIS P. - Lindale, TX

03/26/21

I’ve placed roughly 10 orders from Goldbelly and have had such a wonderful experience. I have mostly ordered sweets such as cakes, pies, jarred desserts, etc, and only 1 order of fresh veggies. Betty’s pies were our latest delivery and were part of a gift subscription for my dad. He is LOVING the subscription! Betty’s pies, in particular, are absolutely to die for!! We ended up ordering 2 pies from that bakery for a birthday, and then a 3rd flavor came in his subscription and we loved them all. In fact, dad only shared a small bite with each, and then kept the rest for his breakfasts and desserts for the next few days. Love the variety, reliability, and overall quality with the choices you have to offer, and I will continue to use this as my go-to for food gifting. Let’s face it, who doesn’t love receiving something yummy at their front door!

Warren P. - Clermont, FL

02/26/21

The butterscotch pie and rhubarb strawberry pie were awesome 😎

Judith V. - Knightdale, NC

02/25/21

Everything was great with this order, as usual! Pies came right on time and were delicious! Our second order from Betty's Pies! They're the BEST!

Ivy M. - Mesa, AZ

01/14/21

Betty's Pies were so incredible the first time, it was necessary to revisit. And once again...there's a reason for the legends. Shipped quickly, arrived on time, and absolutely delicious. Cannot recommend highly enough!

Thomas P. - Woodbridge, VA

01/14/21

OMG...these pies are AMAZING! I will definitely be ordering again!

Linda K. - Grand Junction, CO

12/01/20

The pie was perfect! Arrived on time and not one crumb was disturbed, which was a very pleasant surprise, coming all the way to Florida from Minnesota. Outstanding!

Debbie N. - Ocala, FL

05/16/21

Such a unique gift to get in the mail. Packaged perfectly. Delivered on time and was excellent tasting!

Linda M. - Fremont, IN