Choose Your Own Deep Dish Pizza - 3 Pack

Bartolini’s ships its legendary Chicago deep-dish pizzas nationwide! Bartolini’s Deep Dish Chicago Pizza is thick, rich and cheesy, and baked to perfection. It features an expertly crafted crust topped with their tangy pizza sauce, loads of house shredded whole milk mozzarella and your choice of fresh toppings. It’s as iconic as the city that made deep dish famous!

Since opening in 1995, Bartolini’s Restaurant has assembled many of Chicago’s most iconic eats all under one roof. Brothers Christopher and Dominic Bartolini, who attended the Culinary Institute of America before opening Bartolini’s, are serving up Italian beef sandwiches, thin-crust and deep-dish pizza, and meatballs so spectacular they’ve been named some of the nation’s best.

More Details

This package serves 4 people and includes your choice of 4 pizzas

  • Each pizza measures approx. 12"
  • Choose to add a Bartolini’s T-Shirt and/or Hat!

Pizza Options Include

  • Meatball Lovers
  • Cheese
  • Sausage
  • Pepperoni
  • Mushroom
  • Spinach
  • Sausage + Pepperoni
  • Sausage, Pepperoni + Mushroom
  • Sausage, Pepperoni + Hot Giardiniera
  • Sausage, Green Pepper, Mushroom + Onion

T-Shirt Options Include

  • Meatballs in Your Mouth
  • Meatballin’
  • Like Our Meatballs?
  • Chicago Meatball Flag

Hat Options Include

  • Ladies Adjustable
  • Mens Stretch Mesh

Instructions / Storage

  • Pizzas ship with ice packs and can be stored in your refrigerator for 2-3 days after arrival, or can be frozen for up to 2 months.
  • If frozen, be sure to move pizza to the refrigerator the day before baking, so it can defrost fully overnight.

To Serve

  • Thaw your pizza overnight in the refrigerator.
  • Preheat oven to 400°F.
  • Remove all packaging and place the pizza on a cookie sheet or Pizza Stone.
  • Bake fully thawed pizza about 35-45 minutes, or until the crust is a nice golden brown and pizza is hot throughout.
  • Enjoy!
Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Bartolini’s ships Tuesday – Friday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Corporate Gift Orders

You can send this item to up to 15 different addresses using our regular checkout. Looking to send this item to more than 15 people? Have our Corporate Gifting Team assist you.

Recommended for you

More from Illinois

(
 4.8) REVIEWS

Came frozen and ready to put in freezer. Pizzas are delicious - makes me feel like I’m back home in Chicago! 
Jimmy S. - Houston, TX
09/29/19
The deep-dish meatball was to die for. I’m actually going to be moving to a state where the pizza is meh and will have this a regular order. It was just phenomenal!!
Anthony B. - Wantage, NJ
09/17/19
Fast delivery, 2 days Chicago to Houston! 
Edward M. - Webster, TX
09/17/19
Awesome pizza simply the best I have ever eaten.
Mike S. - Vista, CA
09/11/19
It was really good. Probably about as good as you can get without actually going to Bartolini's. 
Brian B. - Franklin, TN
08/28/19
I was skeptical about the quality of the food being delivered from Chicago to Florida. The best pizza I have ever had, I will be ordering again. 100%
William C. - North Palm Beach, FL
08/27/19
The pizza was really good. I really loved how much cheese they put on there and the ingredients were really fresh. The only thing that could have been better was the crust. Even though it was nice and thin it just didn’t get crispy. But everything else was great.
Chris A. - Euless, TX
08/21/19
The meatballs were amazing! The sauce was fresh and delicious. I will absolutely order again. Flavor-wise...it was perfection! I would advise baking the meatballs longer than suggested on the instructions.
Julie P. - Wake Forest, NC
08/21/19
The pizza was absolutely fantastic! Shipping is tracked very well right up to the time it gets delivered.
Cory W. - Omaha, NE
08/14/19
I ordered the Chicago style pizza from Bartolini's and it was amazing. Expensive but cheaper than a plane ticket out there to have one!
Devin L. - Williston, ND
08/04/19
Great food, well packaged. Timely delivery. Maybe the pricing could have been a little bit better, but I never thought for a second that what I purchased wasn't worth it. 
Scott C. - Ewing, NJ
07/02/19
I have eaten pizza in New York, Chicago, L.A. and many other places. But I have to say this is the best pizza I have ever eaten. When I fix it for friends, unfortunately I never get a second piece. It is truly that good. The other pizzas are also very good, but meatball is the best.....
W.L. - Camden, SC
04/04/19
It arrived on time as usual, but I was very disappointed with the pizza. I’m from Chicago and I ordered this pizza before in the summer. It was great, but this order I can taste the difference in the sauce. It was bland and the pizza was smaller.
Kevin F. - Canyon Country, CA
12/02/19
Ingrédients were top notch! Tasted great, would definitely order again!
Mike L. - Mount Airy, MD
01/22/20
the packaging of the product was excellent!!!!
Sharon D. - Oklahoma City, OK
01/23/20
The red sauce on the deep dish was delicious! We did like the thin crust better because we had trouble cooking the deep dish and the crust was too hard. But it was a great experience and came nice and cold delivered at our door.
Linda C. - Medford, OR
12/19/19
The pizzas were well packed in dry ice and the delivery came as expected. BTW, the pizzas are delicious !!
Diane H. - Northridge, CA
12/02/19
Very easy to order. Product was clearly shown so I knew exactly what I was getting. I had a specific date I needed it delivered on and there were no problems whatsoever. Food came safely packaged. Bartolini's pizza was excellent!! Felt like I was back home in Chicago.
Donald B. - Canal Winchester, OH
12/03/19
So damn yummy!
Eric B. - Portland, TX
12/11/19
My first real Chicago pizza . Awesome 😀😀
Craig S. - Alamo, TN
01/28/20
The pizzas were very good. The tomato sauce had a great flavor and the meatballs were awesome.
Eric S. - Wildwood, MO
12/20/19
Better than most of the pizza actually IN Chicago!
Ernie S. - Fairview Park, OH
12/25/19
As usual, everything came well insulated and in perfect condition. The quality of the food is great and was so tasty!
Jennifer H. - Cumberland, RI
02/05/20
The pizza was easy to reheat and absolutely delicious… Worth every penny!!
Keith L. - Liverpool, NY
11/27/19
The pizza was DELICIOUS! I love giving a gift that someone will enjoy but doesn’t sit on a shelf. Perfect gift for my husband who needs nothing but loves good food!
Mary S. - Murfreesboro, TN
01/14/20
The pizzas were packaged perfectly! I've never had a Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, and it was fantastic. Didn't disappoint!
Daniel T. - Anacortes, WA
01/27/20
My pizza tasted like I was right there in the restaurant it was made in!
Philip S. - Cumming, GA
01/28/20
Everything from packaging and presentation to how it came out of the oven and tasted exceeded expectations.
Jason L. - Dunkirk, NY
01/29/20
My mom loved her bday present. I got the meatball subs before for her and she was hoping to receive them again.
Jamie A. - Lynchburg, VA
02/02/20
First time ordering, got the pizza. It was delicious!! Delivered on time. Would recommend it to friends!
Jennifer D. - Shingle Springs, CA
02/03/20
Fast delivery. Everything was packaged nicely and arrived frozen. The Meatball pizza was AMAZING. I've been telling everyone I know and posted on Facebook. I would expect you will be getting more orders!
Ed H. - Roseville, CA
02/04/20
Authentic Chicago deep dish pizza for Super Bowl party. Everyone loved it!
pat g. - Richland, MI
02/04/20
My delivery was on the day they said would arrive. Packed very well
JEFF C. - Lenoir City, TN
02/06/20
Second time we have ordered these pizzas and they never disappoint!!
STEPHEN W. - Guntersville, AL
02/17/20
My husband never thought he would like a meatball pizza, not even deep dish, but, he loved it. Keep up the good work.
Marianne P. - Vancouver, WA
03/07/20
Everything went well from the order to delivery! And the Bartolini’s pizza was delicious!!!
Tina W. - Henderson, NV
03/10/20
These meatballs are beautifully delicious. OH!! And the sauce is wonderful. You'll be licking the spoon, fork, and possibly your fingers. My only negative comment is the meatballs come in about 16 balls per package, so you get two packages, however, after a learning a lesson I now know to separate the meatballs into containers for 4 to 8 per container and freeze as we are only two people. I found them to freeze perfectly. Really not that expensive if you want take out.
Paul M. - Fort Lauderdale, FL
03/16/20
BEST damn meatballs and red gravy going, my 4th time and the thin crust pizza is one of the best, you wont be disappointed
Michael s. - Venice, FL
01/09/21
Everything. Ordering was a snap. Arrived on time in described condition. Instructions were spot on. Pizza was delicious!
sum f. - bigfork, MT
01/09/21
The sauce and toppings tasted great. Heating and reheating worked very well on a cast iron pizza pan. My favorite delivered Chicago deep dish pizza so far.
Harry B. - Duluth, GA
01/07/21
The pizzas are amazing and they got here lightning fast excellent service.
Jennt K. - Converse, TX
01/02/21
Follow up from Goldbelly was exceptional. Although the pizza arrived a day later than advertised, the superior packing kept the pizza frozen and was enjoyed by all.
Joshua N. - Culpeper, VA
01/01/21
It was great! Delivered as promised, which was a surprise, during Christmas week~ VERY happy with how everything arrived~!
Addie H. - Granada Hills, CA
01/01/21
The Bartolinis pizza far exceeded our expectations! Among the best pizza we have ever eaten! And shipped from Chicago to Tulsa, OK. Imagine that! Thanks Goldbelly!
Billy S. - Ramona, OK
01/01/21
This is terrific pizza, great flavors.
Greg B. - Woodfin, NC
12/23/20
I shipped Bartolini's pizza to friends that were sheltering in a rural area during COVID. They were so delighted with the gift, and they told me the pizzas were amazing and sent me pictures. They ate two right away, and saved two to have Bartolini's instead of traditional Christmas dinner. Its a good feeling to give a gift that makes people so happy. The order arrived on time and in perfect condition, to a rural route!
Paula S. - Alcalde, NM
12/22/20
The deep dish pizza is the best pizza we have ever had ! We got the meatball deep dish and the meatballs are also out of this world !
Jaime P. - Rome, NY
12/17/20
Online ordering was quick and easy, the shipment was received on the date promised!
Mike W. - Nixa, MO
12/15/20
Everything was delish could not have been happier!!!
gabrielle d. - Pittsburgh, PA
12/15/20
Order was received on time and when heated and served pizza was delicious.
Eddie W. - Bluffton, SC
12/09/20
Everything......ordering was very easy.......got a discount,....delivery was quick.....FOOD WAS FABULOUS
Donna Z. - North Brunswick, NJ
12/08/20
Quality and price of food was excellent and delivery timing was spot on..
Lisa G. - De Pere, WI
12/08/20
The order was correct and delivered in a timely manner..it was packed good to reduce damage...my order came in perfect condition
Charles W. - Conway, SC
11/20/20
Items arrived on time and in the quality condition I expected. Items reheated well. I never would have known they had once been frozen.
Johnny P. - Pacific Grove, CA
11/12/20
The pizzas come freshly made. They deliver quickly. LOVE their pizzas!
Audra R. - Putnam, IL
11/18/20
The cheese thin crust was great, and the meatball lovers was amazing. If you cook it a little longer so the cheese on top of the meatballs gets crispy, it's delicious!
Jason D. - Lytle Creek, CA
11/08/20
Shipping was fast and food was delicious! A lot of friends asked where we got the pizza and we recommended goldbelly to them.
Shu L. - Redwood City, CA
11/06/20
All I can say is OUTSTANDING!!!! Both my son and my husband share the same birthday, and since we do not have a good pizza place here in Los Lunas, NM, I wandered over to the Goldbelly site and knew I had to try your pizza.
The ease in ordering was perfect (although I wish there were a few more toppings to choose from). The box that the 4-pack pizzas came in was packed just right, and it was not damaged at all. The product arrived in perfect condition.
As to the quality of the product ~ wow! Now I know what we are missing when it comes to GREAT pizza. In addition, the instructions were very clear as to what I needed to do to store and prepare the pizzas. 
All in all, a great experience! I am now contemplating my next order :) Thank you for making their birthdays very special!
Christine C. -
01/11/21
Amazing pizza!!! Our first order through goldbelly... Chicago deep dis in Oregon with Meatballs to die for. Amazing product, service and food. Thank you for making our covid altered 2020 Christmas Eve SO special in Oregon this year! Not sure we'll be able to order from anyone else. Keep up the good work and stay grounded as you take off! Lots of love from your new Oregon fans. 
Lori L. - OR
12/29/20
Everything came on time and packaged well! We were over the top impressed with the deep dish pizzas. Best ever!
Gayle M. - Davis, CA
04/10/21
Everything went well. Extremely well. We ordered Bartolini's gluten free meatballs. They arrived exactly when they were supposed to. They were beyond delicious. The prep directions were perfect. Everyone loved them. We will definitely be ordering again, and will happily recommend the site and Bartolini's.
Nancy N. - Glen Cove, NY
04/06/21
Right on time. Pizzas in Great condition. Great way to reach out and easily get the better flavors of old-home.
Chris F. - Columbia, SC
03/27/21
The shipment was right on time and packaged nicely. Everything we tried so far is delicious. It was my family’s first time having a deep dish pizza and we loved it! We also enjoyed the thin crust pizza also.
Tracy M. - Poughkeepsie, NY
03/22/21
Ordering was so easy and convenient. Chicago deep dish pizza is my husbands favorite and since we have no places near us that makes them, it was great to find your site. It made for a Perfect birthday dinner.
Kellie P. - Walker, MI
03/20/21
Far exceeded our expectations! Arrived on time. Excellent packaging with crust in perfect shape. Pizza was amazing! We are still talking about it a week later. Goldbelly is a terrific gift idea.
Elizabeth S. - Cincinnati, OH
03/12/21
My order arrived on time, it was packaged well, the included cooking instructions were easy to follow, and the pizza was delicious. I'd definitely order from Bartolini’s again.
Mike S. - Harrisburg, PA
03/07/21
The pizzas were delivered on the exact delivery date. I appreciate that GoldBelly offers free shipping on certain products. The pizzas were incredible! We ordered the 4 pack - w deep dish and 2 thin crust. We are one of each over the weekend and loved them both! Excited about trying the others in the weeks ahead!
Jean Y. - San Jose, CA
02/19/21
Our pizzas were delivered exactly when you said they would be delivered, they were packaged in a way that kept them frozen and undamaged. Oh yeah...and they were incredibly delicious!!!!
Melanie R. - Rotonda West, FL
02/18/21
Customer service was great, pizzas arrived in time for our family to eat for Super Bowl. The food was fan-freaking-tastic. I would 1000% recommend Bartolini’s and hopeful to get there when COVID becomes a thing of the past.
Jenna A. - Brick, NJ
02/14/21
The delivery was on time and well packaged. And the pizza was amazing! So much thick sauce and cheese!
Camille R. - Bulverde, TX
04/25/21
Best frozen pizza I've ever had. There's a dedicated space in my freezer for Bartolini's!!
Hal L. - Carmel, CA
05/04/21
The shipping was quick and receiving it really made my weekend. There’s just something great about being able to taste authentic Chicago pizza in Georgia within a few days of ordering it. The taste was obviously unique to any pizza I could find here!
Mark D. - Cumming, GA
05/12/21
Everything was perfect! Food arrived and tasted delicious! We had a fantastic pizza party with friends with all the pizzas!
Victoria L. - Fremont, CA
05/17/21
Even though we were experiencing record setting heat waves, my order arrived in perfect condition. Thank you!
Dawn V. - Newport, WA
07/06/21
Great pizzas! Wonderful sauce! Arrived frozen and on time! Well packed!
Pat A. - Nevada City, CA
06/22/21
Pizza came in time and some killer Goldbelly stickers were included! They went right onto my yeti cooler. It’s the little things.
Paul L. - Jamison, PA
06/21/21
Product was a gift and the recipients absolutely raved about the food and packaging.
Lisa G. - De Pere, WI
06/23/21
The Chicago Deep Dish Pizzas were perfect! They were perfectly frozen when we received them here on the west coast from Bartolini's in Chicago! In two days! Everything about this experience was great.
Troy T. - Reedsport, OR
06/13/21
Pizza is the Bomb!
Greg L. - Cape Coral, FL
06/12/21