Meatball Sandwich Kit - 6 Pack

+ Free Shipping

Get ready to sink your teeth into what may be the most epic, tasty sandwich you’ll ever eat. Bartolini’s creates their amazing meatballs with a blend of beef and pork, just the right seasoning, and douses them with their signature “Red Gravy”. Christopher and Dominic (the “Bartolini Brothers”) created this package so you can experience the sandwich that put Bartolini’s on Chicago’s culinary map.

More Details

Each Meatball Sandwich Kit includes everything you need to make 6 hot sandwiches:

  • 2 Trays of Meatballs in Red Gravy (18 meatballs)
  • 6 Par-baked French Rolls
  • 12 Slices Thick-Sliced Mozzarella
  • Sweet Peppers
  • Homemade Hot Giardiniera Peppers

Instructions / Storage

Storage & Care
Meatballs can be stored in your refrigerator for 4 to 5 days after arrival, or can be frozen for up to 2 months. Store French rolls at room temperature if using within 2 days, otherwise store in your freezer. If you freeze the meatballs, defrost in your refrigerator overnight. Rolls can be removed from your freezer 2-3 hours before making sandwiches. Mozzarella cheese and peppers should be stored in your refrigerator. Peppers will stay fresh for 1-2 days after arrival. Cheese will stay fresh for up to 1 week.

Bread: If frozen, defrost. Pre Heat Oven to 350 Degrees. Bake bread for 8-10 Minutes until Golden Brown. Remove and let sit at room temp.

Meatballs (Thawed): Remove Plastic Film from tray, transfer meatballs and red gravy into an over-safe casserole or baking dish with cover or foil and bake in 350-degree oven for 20-25 minutes.

To Serve: Slice Bread ¾ the way through. Add 3 meatballs per sandwich and Cover with Red Gravy. Add Peppers, Cover with 2 Slices of Mozzarella Cheese and Bake face-up on foil-lined baking sheet until melted – about 5-6 Minutes. Enjoy!

Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Items are prepared fresh and shipped directly from the shop
  • Bartolini’s ships Tuesday – Friday of each week
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Recommended for you

More from Illinois


Came frozen and ready to put in freezer. Pizzas are delicious - makes me feel like I’m back home in Chicago! 
Jimmy S. - Houston, TX
The deep-dish meatball was to die for. I’m actually going to be moving to a state where the pizza is meh and will have this a regular order. It was just phenomenal!!
Anthony B. - Wantage, NJ
Fast delivery, 2 days Chicago to Houston! 
Edward M. - Webster, TX
Awesome pizza simply the best I have ever eaten.
Mike S. - Vista, CA
It was really good. Probably about as good as you can get without actually going to Bartolini's. 
Brian B. - Franklin, TN
I was skeptical about the quality of the food being delivered from Chicago to Florida. The best pizza I have ever had, I will be ordering again. 100%
William C. - North Palm Beach, FL
The pizza was really good. I really loved how much cheese they put on there and the ingredients were really fresh. The only thing that could have been better was the crust. Even though it was nice and thin it just didn’t get crispy. But everything else was great.
Chris A. - Euless, TX
The meatballs were amazing! The sauce was fresh and delicious. I will absolutely order again. was perfection! I would advise baking the meatballs longer than suggested on the instructions.
Julie P. - Wake Forest, NC
The pizza was absolutely fantastic! Shipping is tracked very well right up to the time it gets delivered.
Cory W. - Omaha, NE
I ordered the Chicago style pizza from Bartolini's and it was amazing. Expensive but cheaper than a plane ticket out there to have one!
Devin L. - Williston, ND
Great food, well packaged. Timely delivery. Maybe the pricing could have been a little bit better, but I never thought for a second that what I purchased wasn't worth it. 
Scott C. - Ewing, NJ
I have eaten pizza in New York, Chicago, L.A. and many other places. But I have to say this is the best pizza I have ever eaten. When I fix it for friends, unfortunately I never get a second piece. It is truly that good. The other pizzas are also very good, but meatball is the best.....
W.L. - Camden, SC
It arrived on time as usual, but I was very disappointed with the pizza. I’m from Chicago and I ordered this pizza before in the summer. It was great, but this order I can taste the difference in the sauce. It was bland and the pizza was smaller.
Kevin F. - Canyon Country, CA
Ingrédients were top notch! Tasted great, would definitely order again!
Mike L. - Mount Airy, MD
the packaging of the product was excellent!!!!
Sharon D. - Oklahoma City, OK
The red sauce on the deep dish was delicious! We did like the thin crust better because we had trouble cooking the deep dish and the crust was too hard. But it was a great experience and came nice and cold delivered at our door.
Linda C. - Medford, OR
The pizzas were well packed in dry ice and the delivery came as expected. BTW, the pizzas are delicious !!
Diane H. - Northridge, CA
Very easy to order. Product was clearly shown so I knew exactly what I was getting. I had a specific date I needed it delivered on and there were no problems whatsoever. Food came safely packaged. Bartolini's pizza was excellent!! Felt like I was back home in Chicago.
Donald B. - Canal Winchester, OH
So damn yummy!
Eric B. - Portland, TX
My first real Chicago pizza . Awesome 😀😀
Craig S. - Alamo, TN
The pizzas were very good. The tomato sauce had a great flavor and the meatballs were awesome.
Eric S. - Wildwood, MO
Better than most of the pizza actually IN Chicago!
Ernie S. - Fairview Park, OH
As usual, everything came well insulated and in perfect condition. The quality of the food is great and was so tasty!
Jennifer H. - Cumberland, RI
The pizza was easy to reheat and absolutely delicious… Worth every penny!!
Keith L. - Liverpool, NY
The pizza was DELICIOUS! I love giving a gift that someone will enjoy but doesn’t sit on a shelf. Perfect gift for my husband who needs nothing but loves good food!
Mary S. - Murfreesboro, TN
The pizzas were packaged perfectly! I've never had a Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, and it was fantastic. Didn't disappoint!
Daniel T. - Anacortes, WA
My pizza tasted like I was right there in the restaurant it was made in!
Philip S. - Cumming, GA
Everything from packaging and presentation to how it came out of the oven and tasted exceeded expectations.
Jason L. - Dunkirk, NY
My mom loved her bday present. I got the meatball subs before for her and she was hoping to receive them again.
Jamie A. - Lynchburg, VA
First time ordering, got the pizza. It was delicious!! Delivered on time. Would recommend it to friends!
Jennifer D. - Shingle Springs, CA
Fast delivery. Everything was packaged nicely and arrived frozen. The Meatball pizza was AMAZING. I've been telling everyone I know and posted on Facebook. I would expect you will be getting more orders!
Ed H. - Roseville, CA
Authentic Chicago deep dish pizza for Super Bowl party. Everyone loved it!
pat g. - Richland, MI
My delivery was on the day they said would arrive. Packed very well
JEFF C. - Lenoir City, TN
Second time we have ordered these pizzas and they never disappoint!!
STEPHEN W. - Guntersville, AL
My husband never thought he would like a meatball pizza, not even deep dish, but, he loved it. Keep up the good work.
Marianne P. - Vancouver, WA
Everything went well from the order to delivery! And the Bartolini’s pizza was delicious!!!
Tina W. - Henderson, NV
These meatballs are beautifully delicious. OH!! And the sauce is wonderful. You'll be licking the spoon, fork, and possibly your fingers. My only negative comment is the meatballs come in about 16 balls per package, so you get two packages, however, after a learning a lesson I now know to separate the meatballs into containers for 4 to 8 per container and freeze as we are only two people. I found them to freeze perfectly. Really not that expensive if you want take out.
Paul M. - Fort Lauderdale, FL