Make Your Own Old Forge Pizza 2 Pack

+ Free Shipping

Located in the Pizza Capital of the World, Arcaro & Genell bake their pizzas using the decades-old traditions first created by the wives of the coalminers in town. Using homemade dough that’s baked until light and crispy and topped with fresh tomato sauce (red-style) or black pepper and rosemary (white-style), choose your favorite style of Old Forge pizza that’s somewhere between New York thin crust and Chicago-style.

More Details

  • Each package serves 8-10 people
  • This product only ships overnight in the summer

Choose any combination of these pizza styles:

  • “RED” Style Pizza: A square, thick crust pizza made with tomato sauce and cheese
  • “WHITE” Style Pizza: A square, double crust cheese only pizza with olive oil and rosemary sprinkled on top

Instructions / Storage

Pizzas are made-to-order and promptly frozen. Although each box is carefully packed with ice packs and picked up for immediate shipment, it is normal for the pizza and ice packs to partially or fully thaw during shipment. Upon receipt, please, cook, refrigerate or place in the freezer.

Pizzas will stay fresh in the fridge for up to 1-2 days. If you wish to keep them longer, you can store them in the freezer for up to 2 months.

Detailed storage instructions are included in the box.

Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Items are prepared fresh and shipped directly from the shop
  • Arcaro & Genell Pizza ships on Monday-Friday of each week.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Recommended for you

More from Pennsylvania


Tasted just like we were in the restaurant eating it!
Ashley P. - Abilene, TX
Best pizza in Old Forge. Arrived fresh and on time.
Richard H. - North Venice, FL
Their pizza is always great, it's been exactly the same since I was a little girl. Their packaging keeps getting better. In this order, the pizza was in large ziplock bags, which was way better than being wrapped in plastic wrap.
Leslie G. - Kingston, WA
It was terrific. ALMOST like eating at Arcaro & Genell's, but without the great atmosphere. I was particularly impressed with the packaging.
Lisa D. - Long Island City, NY
Was a gift! Got the email alerting us to arrival date and it arrived on time and was packaged really well. Arcaro and Genell pizza from Old Forge PA is the BEST PIZZA!!! 🍕
Nina B. - Antrim, NH
There’s no better pizza then Old Forge, PA!!! My hometown!!
Ann-Marie B. - Naples, FL
I love that I was able to send two nice, big pizzas to my family in Virginia, who live in an area where pizza delivery isn't available. They LOVED the pizza and enjoyed the surprise!
Anjelia T. - New York, NY
Best pizza. Wrapped perfect. It's my favorite!
Ronald L. - Aventura, FL