Frozen Custard + Ice Cream Sandwich Party Box

+ Free Shipping
This product is currently sold out.

This best-of-both-worlds combo pack is a great way to sample their fabulous flavors of Anderson’s signature frozen custard and hand-made ice cream sandwiches. Anderson’s signature frozen custard is made according to Carl and Greta Anderson’s original 1946 recipe, and their handmade ice cream is made in small batches and has earned the highest awards and honors. Package includes an ice cream scooper.

More Details

This Package Includes:

  • Your choice of 3 Pints of Andersons Custard
  • 24 Assorted Vanilla Ice Cream Sandwiches

Flavor Options Include

  • Van/Choc Twist Custard
  • Chocolate Custard
  • Pistachio
  • Vanilla Custard
  • Black Raspberry Custard
  • Strawberry Custard
  • Lemon Ice
  • Chocolate Ice Cream
  • Strawberry Ice Cream
  • Black Cherry Ice Cream
  • Oreo Ice Cream
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream
  • Mint Chocolate Chunk Ice Cream
  • Watson’s Sponge Candy Ice Cream
  • Cinnamon Ice Cream
  • Salty Caramel Pecan Pie
  • Vanilla Ice Cream
  • Cookie Dough Ice Cream
  • Vegan Coconut Chocolate Almond
  • Vegan Chocolate Raspberry
  • Frosty Hot Chocolate (Seasonal)
  • Peppermint Stick Fudge (Seasonal)
  • Rum and Eggnog (Seasonal)
  • Merry Mocha Chocolate Mint (Seasonal)

Please be advised that seasonal flavors ship through December only, any seasonal flavor scheduled for delivery after December will be replaced with another flavor

Instructions / Storage

Storage & Care:
Frozen custard and handmade ice creams from Anderson’s can be kept frozen for up to 3 weeks, but are freshest when consumed within 1 week.

Download Storage and Prep Instructions

Shipping Details

  • Items are prepared fresh and shipped directly from the shop
  • Anderson’s ships Monday-Thursday of each week.
  • Orders cannot be shipped to P.O. Boxes.
  • Orders shipped to Alaska and Hawaii via 2-day will incur an additional $20 charge or $35 for Overnight Shipping. Sorry guys!
  • Have more questions about Shipping? Read our Shipping FAQ page.

Recommended for you

More from New York


Easy to order - hot dogs came packed in refrig packing - ice cold from NY to Texas - I'll never be without my favorite hotdogs - what a great service for so many of us that miss our hometown favorites! Will definitely order again soon and tell others! Thanks - happy customer
Gail R. - Conroe, TX
It was easy to order and have food from out of town delivered. I am not sure how it happened that I had 3 orders instead of one, but Goldbelly easily corrected the mistake.
Anne F. - Wellington, OH
The recipients said it was even better than when they dined in person at Anderson's! That's how fresh everything was. And they send an abundance of ingredients to make the sandwiches. The packaging was pretty wasteful. Lots & lots of plastic bags IN plastic bags. We understand why -- they prep ingredients for the smallest number of sandwiches you can order and multiply out when you buy the larger size. But the amount of plastic in the order would make us reconsider ordering again. It was just way too wasteful (esp for an environmentally conscious household).
Lisa B. - Charlotte, NC
I received Andersons and it was incredible. The best of the best and not one single flaw.
Susan W. - Blakeslee, PA
Hometown Buffalonian....Food was fresh, delicious, and consumed in two nights. We have a Friday Night Supper Club with usually 10 people, the hometown beef on weck is a favorite we’ve had many times!! Thankful you deliver to the Vineyard!
John H. - Edgartown, MA
Free shipping! The beef on weck kit was excellent in all of its components and very generously sized for our family.
Patricia B. - Columbia, SC
Easy to order. Came quickly without overnight delivery charge. Moved away from Buffalo and can still have Buffalo food. Third time ordering and will again. Told all my family to do same. Packed well.
Susan P. - Vestal, NY
We moved from Lockport (Buffalo area) and miss having beef on weck sandwiches - these were so good. Definitely reminded us of our former home. The food was excellent and the delivery time was exceptional.
Carole K. - Fruitland Park, FL
Sandwiches were excellent and potions were fine. Tasted like being there, easy to assemble. Since the meat was frozen hard it would have been impossible to use the day it arrived. Customers should know that.
Brian F. - Painesville, OH
Nice Packaging and 'easy to put ALL together' so that we felt we were eating directly at the GOOD!!!
Betty M. - North Barrington, IL
Living in Florida now it was great receiving this gift from our son. We love Andersons. It was one of our favorites.
Scott C. - Tavares, FL